Stay up to date with notifications from The Independent

Notifications can be managed in browser preferences.

Making a Murderer: ‘my emotions regarding Steven Avery are complicated’ rape victim Penny Beernsten says

‘The day I learned of the exoneration was worse than the day I was assaulted’

Loulla-Mae Eleftheriou-Smith
Wednesday 06 January 2016 10:52 GMT

The rape survivor who wrongly identified Steven Avery as her attacker has spoken for the first time since the airing of Netflix’s docu-series ‘Making a Murderer’, stating that her feelings towards him today are “complicated”.

‘Making a Murderer’ focuses on the events following Avery’s release from prison after his wrongful conviction, but details his imprisonment for the violent attack on Ms Beernsten and his subsequent conviction in 2005 for the murder of Teresa Halbach.

Speaking to The Marshall Project, survivor Penny Beernsten said that “the day I learned of the exoneration was worse than the day I was assaulted”.

“After the DNA results came back, I just felt powerless. I can’t un-ring this bell. I can’t give Steve back the years that he’s lost.”

Making A Murderer- Where are they now?

In 1985, Ms Beernsten was attacked and raped by a stranger as she ran along a beach near her house. Avery was presented to her in a police line-up and she picked him out as the assailant.

Ms Beernsten was convinced of his guilt. He was convicted of rape and sentenced to 32 years, but in 2003 Avery was released after DNA evidence proved the real attacker was a serial rapist named Gregroy Allen, who had been arrested on unrelated rape charges. Avery was released after serving 18 years in prison.

Steven Avery (Netflix)

When Avery was released from prison, he said: “I don’t blame the victim, what happened to her was horrible. It’s the cops that set me up,” Ms Beernsten claimed, but she said she “went from having sympathy to being this horrible person who made a mistake and is responsible for someone else’s suffering”.

“The first time I went out in public, an acquaintance of mine said: ‘I can’t believe you’re brave enough to show your face’,” she recalled.

Ms Beernsten later met with Avery and apologised to him and to his family. A few months later, Avery contacted Ms Beernsten to ask her to buy him a house. He told her he didn’t have any money and couldn’t get a job and that he wanted to get his own place to live, she claimed.

She told him it would not be possible to buy him a house and instead “called job services” and passed the information to Avery’s attorney.

Two years after he was released from prison Avery was convicted and imprisoned for the murder of Ms Halbach, which ‘Making a Murderer’ focuses on.

Laura Ricciardi, left, and Moira Demos, right, on the set of ‘Making A Murderer’

The docu-series has made a significant impact on the public since its release; petitions calling for Avery to be pardoned for his murder charge have gained more than 100,000 signatures while online activist group Anonymous claims to have evidence proving Avery is innocent. The prosecutor involved in the murder case, Ken Katz, has been attacked online by the show’s fans and hundreds of people on the internet have been trying to solve the murder case on Reddit.

But Ms Beernsten said her feelings towards Avery are complicated due to the Halbach case.

“Then I get a call that a young woman has gone missing and the last place she was seen was on Steven Avery’s property. So my emotions regarding Steven Avery are complicated,” she said.

Join our commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies


Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in