Young "Capoeiristas" in training
(
Charles Bouessel/AFP/Getty
)
Mestre Bimba, the Brazilian martial arts expert, was born on this date in Salvador, Bahia, in 1899.
The subject of the latest Google Doodle, Manuel dos Reis Machado is known as the first to legitimise the centuries old Afro-Brazilian fighting style of capoeira.
Developed in the 16th century by African slaves as a form of self-defence, capoeira incorporates elements of dance and acrobatics, which allowed its earliest practitioners to train in it without arousing suspicion among slave masters, who assumed the strange exercises being practised were a form of tribal ritual rather than the roots of an uprising.
We’ll tell you what’s true. You can form your own view.
From
15p€0.18$0.18USD 0.27
a day, more exclusives, analysis and extras.
Google Doodles
Show all 116
Google Doodles
1/116 St David's Day
Google Doodle celebrating St David's Day
Google
2/116 St Valentine's Day
Google Doodle celebrating St Valentine's Day
Google
3/116 Chinese New Year
Google Doodle celebrating Chinese New Year
Google
4/116 Winter Solstice
Google Doodle celebrating Winter Solstice
Google
5/116 Nelly Sachs
Google Doodle celebrating Nelly Sachs
Google
6/116 Edith Cavell
Google Doodle celebrating Edith Cavell
Google
7/116 St Andrew's Day 2018
Google Doodle celebrating St Andrew's Day 2018
Google
8/116 Mestre Bimba
Google Doodle celebrating Mestre Bimba
Google
9/116 Thanksgiving 2018
Google Doodle celebrating Thanksgiving 2018
Google
10/116 Nigerian Independence Day
Google Doodle celebrating Nigerian Independence Day
Google
11/116 Mary Prince
Google Doodle celebrating Mary Prince
Google
12/116 Google's birthday
Google Doodle celebrating company's own birthday
Google
13/116 US Voter Registration Day 2018
Google Doodle celebrating US Voter Registration Day 2018
Google
14/116 Mister Rogers
Google Doodle celebrating Mister Rogers
Google
15/116 Joanna Baillie
Google Doodle celebrating Joanna Baillie
Google
16/116 Labor Day 2018
Google Doodle celebrating Labor Day 2018
Google
17/116 Ebenezer Cobb Morley
Google Doodle celebrating Ebenezer Cobb Morley
Google
18/116 Mary G Ross
Google Doodle celebrating Mary G Ross
Google
19/116 Octavia E Butler
Google Doodle celebrating Octavia E Butler
Google
20/116 Dame Cicely Saunders
Google Doodle celebrating Dame Cicely Saunders
Google
21/116 Virginia Apgar
Google Doodle celebrating Virginia Apgar
Google
22/116 Tamara de Lempicka
Google Doodle celebrating Tamara de Lempicka
Google
23/116 Maria Reiche
Google Doodle celebrating Maria Reiche
Google
24/116 Georges Melies
Google Doodle celebrating Georges Melies
Google
25/116 Johann Carl Friedrich Gauss
Google Doodle celebrating Johann Carl Friedrich Gauss
Google
26/116 Fanny Blankers-Koen
Google Doodle celebrating Fanny Blankers-Koen
Google
27/116 Omar Sharif
Google Doodle celebrating Omar Sharif
Google
28/116 Maya Angelou
Google Doodle celebrating Maya Angelou
Google
29/116 John Harrison
Google Doodle celebrating John Harrison
Google
30/116 Hannah Glasse
Google Doodle celebrating Hannah Glasse
Google
31/116 Katsuko Saruhashi
Google Doodle celebrating Katsuko Saruhashi
Google
32/116 Guillermo Haro
Google Doodle celebrating Guillermo Haro
Google
33/116 Sir William Henry Perkin
Google Doodle celebrating Sir William Henry Perkin
Google
34/116 Gabriel Garcia Marquez
Google Doodle celebrating Gabriel Garcia Marquez
Google
35/116 Holi
Google Doodle celebrating Holi
Google
36/116 St. David's Day
Google Doodle celebrating St. David's Day
Google
37/116 Carter G Woodson
Google Doodle celebrating Carter G Woodson
Google
38/116 Wilder Penfield
Google Doodle celebrating Wilder Penfield
Google
39/116 Virginia Woolf
Google Doodle celebrating Virginia Woolf
Google
40/116 Sergei Eisenstein
Google Doodle celebrating Sergei Eisenstein
Google
41/116 Winter Solstice
Google Doodle celebrating Winter Solstice
Google
42/116 St Andrew's Day
Google Doodle celebrating St Andrew's Day
Google
43/116 Gertrude Jekyll
Google Doodle celebrating Gertrude Jekyll
Google
44/116 Children's Day 2017
Google Doodle celebrating Children's Day 2017
Google
45/116 Cornelia Sorabji
Google Doodle celebrating Cornelia Sorabji
Google
46/116 Pad Thai
Google Doodle celebrating Pad Thai
Google
47/116 Jackie Forster
Google Doodle celebrating Jackie Forster
Google
48/116 Halloween 2017
Google Doodle celebrating Halloween 2017
Google
49/116 Studio for Electronic Music
Google Doodle celebrating the Studio for Electronic Music
Google
50/116 Selena Quintanilla
Google Doodle celebrating Selena Quintanilla
Google
51/116 Olaudah Equiano
Google Doodle celebrating Olaudah Equiano
Google
52/116 Fridtjof Nansen
Google Doodle celebrating Fridtjof Nansen
Google
53/116 Amalia Hernandez
Google Doodle celebrating Amalia Hernandez
Google
54/116 Dr Samuel Johnson
Google Doodle celebrating Dr Samuel Johnson
Google
55/116 Sir John Cornforth
Google Doodle celebrating Sir John Cornforth
Google
56/116 British Sign Language
Google Doodle celebrating British Sign Language
Google
57/116 Eduard Khil
Google Doodle celebrating Eduard Khil
Google
58/116 James Wong Howe
Google Doodle celebrating James Wong Howe
Google
59/116 Eiko Ishioka
Google Doodle celebrating Eiko Ishioka
Google
60/116 Eva Ekeblad
Google Doodle celebrating Eva Ekeblad
Google
61/116 Fourth of July
Google Doodle celebrating Fourth of July
Google
62/116 Wimbledon Championship
Google Doodle celebrating Wimbledon
Google
63/116 Victor Hugo
Google Doodle celebrating Victor Hugo
Google
64/116 Google Doodle celebrating Oskar Fischinger
Google Doodle celebrating Oskar Fischinger
Google
65/116 UK General Election 2017
Google celebrates the UK General Election
Google
66/116 Zaha Hadid
Google celebrates the acclaimed architect for becoming the first woman to win the Pritzker Architecture Prize on this day in 2004
Google
67/116 Richard Oakes
Google Doodle celebrating Richard Oakes' 75 birthday
Google
68/116 Google Doodle celebrating the Antikythera Mechanism
Google Doodle celebrating the Antikythera Mechanism
Google
69/116 Ferdinand Monoyer
The famous French ophthalmologist, who invented the eye test, would have celebrated his 181st birthday today
Google
70/116 Google Doodle celebrating Giro d'Italia's 100th Anniversary
Google Doodle celebrating Giro d'Italia's 100th Anniversary
Google
71/116 Google Doodle celebrating Nasa's Cassini probe
Google Doodle celebrating Nasa's Cassini probe
Google
72/116 Google Doodle celebrating Fazlur Rahman Khan
Google Doodle celebrating Fazlur Rahman Khan
Google
73/116 Google Doodle celebrating Sergei Diaghilev
Google Doodle celebrating Sergei Diaghilev
Google
74/116 Google Doodle celebrating St. Patrick's Day
Google Doodle celebrating St. Patrick's Day
Google
75/116 Google Doodle celebrating Holi Festival
Google Doodle celebrating Holi Festival
Google
76/116 Google Doodle celebrating St. David's Day
Google Doodle celebrating St. David's Day
Google
77/116 Abdul Sattar Edhi
Google Doodle of Abdul Sattar Edhi on February 28 2017
Google
78/116 Seven earth-sized exoplanets discovered
Google Doodle celebrates Nasa's discovery of seven earth-sized exoplanets in new solar system
Google
79/116 Bessie Coleman
Google Doodle honours the first African American woman to get an international pilot licence on her 125th birthday
Google
80/116 Caroling
Google Doodle celebrates Christmas caroling
Google
81/116
Today's Google Doodle features activist Steve Biko
Google
82/116 Walter Cronkite
Google celebrates Walter Cronkite's 100th birthday
Google celebrates Valentine's Day with a romantic Doodle
105/116 Dmitri Mendeleev
Google celebrate Dmitri Mendeleev's 182nd birthday
106/116 "The televisor" demonstartion
Google Doodle celebrates 90 years since the first demonstration of television or "the televisor" to the public
107/116 Professor Scoville
Google marks Professor Scoville’s 151st birthday
108/116 Sophie Taeuber-Arp
Google marks Sophie Taeuber-Arp's 127th birthday
109/116 Charles Perrault
Google celebrates author Charles Perrault's 388th birthday
110/116 Mountain of Butterflies discovery
Google celebrates the 41st anniversary of the discovery of the Mountain of Butterflies
111/116 Winter Solstice 2015
Google celebrate the Winter Solstice
112/116 St Andrew's Day 2015
Google marks St Andrew's Day with doodle featuring Scotland's flag and Loch Ness monster
113/116 41st anniversary of the discovery of 'Lucy'
Google marks the 41st anniversary of the discovery of 'Lucy', the name given to a collection of fossilised bones that once made up the skeleton of a hominid from the Australopithecus afarensis species, who lived in Ethiopia 3.2 million years ago
114/116 George Boole
Google marks George Boole's 200th birthday
115/116 Halloween 2015
Google celebrates Halloween using an interactive doodle game "Global Candy Cup"
116/116 Prague Astronomical Clock
Google celebrates the 605th anniversary of the Prague Astronomical Clock, one of the oldest functioning timepieces in the world
1/116 St David's Day
Google Doodle celebrating St David's Day
Google
2/116 St Valentine's Day
Google Doodle celebrating St Valentine's Day
Google
3/116 Chinese New Year
Google Doodle celebrating Chinese New Year
Google
4/116 Winter Solstice
Google Doodle celebrating Winter Solstice
Google
5/116 Nelly Sachs
Google Doodle celebrating Nelly Sachs
Google
6/116 Edith Cavell
Google Doodle celebrating Edith Cavell
Google
7/116 St Andrew's Day 2018
Google Doodle celebrating St Andrew's Day 2018
Google
8/116 Mestre Bimba
Google Doodle celebrating Mestre Bimba
Google
9/116 Thanksgiving 2018
Google Doodle celebrating Thanksgiving 2018
Google
10/116 Nigerian Independence Day
Google Doodle celebrating Nigerian Independence Day
Google
11/116 Mary Prince
Google Doodle celebrating Mary Prince
Google
12/116 Google's birthday
Google Doodle celebrating company's own birthday
Google
13/116 US Voter Registration Day 2018
Google Doodle celebrating US Voter Registration Day 2018
Google
14/116 Mister Rogers
Google Doodle celebrating Mister Rogers
Google
15/116 Joanna Baillie
Google Doodle celebrating Joanna Baillie
Google
16/116 Labor Day 2018
Google Doodle celebrating Labor Day 2018
Google
17/116 Ebenezer Cobb Morley
Google Doodle celebrating Ebenezer Cobb Morley
Google
18/116 Mary G Ross
Google Doodle celebrating Mary G Ross
Google
19/116 Octavia E Butler
Google Doodle celebrating Octavia E Butler
Google
20/116 Dame Cicely Saunders
Google Doodle celebrating Dame Cicely Saunders
Google
21/116 Virginia Apgar
Google Doodle celebrating Virginia Apgar
Google
22/116 Tamara de Lempicka
Google Doodle celebrating Tamara de Lempicka
Google
23/116 Maria Reiche
Google Doodle celebrating Maria Reiche
Google
24/116 Georges Melies
Google Doodle celebrating Georges Melies
Google
25/116 Johann Carl Friedrich Gauss
Google Doodle celebrating Johann Carl Friedrich Gauss
Google
26/116 Fanny Blankers-Koen
Google Doodle celebrating Fanny Blankers-Koen
Google
27/116 Omar Sharif
Google Doodle celebrating Omar Sharif
Google
28/116 Maya Angelou
Google Doodle celebrating Maya Angelou
Google
29/116 John Harrison
Google Doodle celebrating John Harrison
Google
30/116 Hannah Glasse
Google Doodle celebrating Hannah Glasse
Google
31/116 Katsuko Saruhashi
Google Doodle celebrating Katsuko Saruhashi
Google
32/116 Guillermo Haro
Google Doodle celebrating Guillermo Haro
Google
33/116 Sir William Henry Perkin
Google Doodle celebrating Sir William Henry Perkin
Google
34/116 Gabriel Garcia Marquez
Google Doodle celebrating Gabriel Garcia Marquez
Google
35/116 Holi
Google Doodle celebrating Holi
Google
36/116 St. David's Day
Google Doodle celebrating St. David's Day
Google
37/116 Carter G Woodson
Google Doodle celebrating Carter G Woodson
Google
38/116 Wilder Penfield
Google Doodle celebrating Wilder Penfield
Google
39/116 Virginia Woolf
Google Doodle celebrating Virginia Woolf
Google
40/116 Sergei Eisenstein
Google Doodle celebrating Sergei Eisenstein
Google
41/116 Winter Solstice
Google Doodle celebrating Winter Solstice
Google
42/116 St Andrew's Day
Google Doodle celebrating St Andrew's Day
Google
43/116 Gertrude Jekyll
Google Doodle celebrating Gertrude Jekyll
Google
44/116 Children's Day 2017
Google Doodle celebrating Children's Day 2017
Google
45/116 Cornelia Sorabji
Google Doodle celebrating Cornelia Sorabji
Google
46/116 Pad Thai
Google Doodle celebrating Pad Thai
Google
47/116 Jackie Forster
Google Doodle celebrating Jackie Forster
Google
48/116 Halloween 2017
Google Doodle celebrating Halloween 2017
Google
49/116 Studio for Electronic Music
Google Doodle celebrating the Studio for Electronic Music
Google
50/116 Selena Quintanilla
Google Doodle celebrating Selena Quintanilla
Google
51/116 Olaudah Equiano
Google Doodle celebrating Olaudah Equiano
Google
52/116 Fridtjof Nansen
Google Doodle celebrating Fridtjof Nansen
Google
53/116 Amalia Hernandez
Google Doodle celebrating Amalia Hernandez
Google
54/116 Dr Samuel Johnson
Google Doodle celebrating Dr Samuel Johnson
Google
55/116 Sir John Cornforth
Google Doodle celebrating Sir John Cornforth
Google
56/116 British Sign Language
Google Doodle celebrating British Sign Language
Google
57/116 Eduard Khil
Google Doodle celebrating Eduard Khil
Google
58/116 James Wong Howe
Google Doodle celebrating James Wong Howe
Google
59/116 Eiko Ishioka
Google Doodle celebrating Eiko Ishioka
Google
60/116 Eva Ekeblad
Google Doodle celebrating Eva Ekeblad
Google
61/116 Fourth of July
Google Doodle celebrating Fourth of July
Google
62/116 Wimbledon Championship
Google Doodle celebrating Wimbledon
Google
63/116 Victor Hugo
Google Doodle celebrating Victor Hugo
Google
64/116 Google Doodle celebrating Oskar Fischinger
Google Doodle celebrating Oskar Fischinger
Google
65/116 UK General Election 2017
Google celebrates the UK General Election
Google
66/116 Zaha Hadid
Google celebrates the acclaimed architect for becoming the first woman to win the Pritzker Architecture Prize on this day in 2004
Google
67/116 Richard Oakes
Google Doodle celebrating Richard Oakes' 75 birthday
Google
68/116 Google Doodle celebrating the Antikythera Mechanism
Google Doodle celebrating the Antikythera Mechanism
Google
69/116 Ferdinand Monoyer
The famous French ophthalmologist, who invented the eye test, would have celebrated his 181st birthday today
Google
70/116 Google Doodle celebrating Giro d'Italia's 100th Anniversary
Google Doodle celebrating Giro d'Italia's 100th Anniversary
Google
71/116 Google Doodle celebrating Nasa's Cassini probe
Google Doodle celebrating Nasa's Cassini probe
Google
72/116 Google Doodle celebrating Fazlur Rahman Khan
Google Doodle celebrating Fazlur Rahman Khan
Google
73/116 Google Doodle celebrating Sergei Diaghilev
Google Doodle celebrating Sergei Diaghilev
Google
74/116 Google Doodle celebrating St. Patrick's Day
Google Doodle celebrating St. Patrick's Day
Google
75/116 Google Doodle celebrating Holi Festival
Google Doodle celebrating Holi Festival
Google
76/116 Google Doodle celebrating St. David's Day
Google Doodle celebrating St. David's Day
Google
77/116 Abdul Sattar Edhi
Google Doodle of Abdul Sattar Edhi on February 28 2017
Google
78/116 Seven earth-sized exoplanets discovered
Google Doodle celebrates Nasa's discovery of seven earth-sized exoplanets in new solar system
Google
79/116 Bessie Coleman
Google Doodle honours the first African American woman to get an international pilot licence on her 125th birthday
Google
80/116 Caroling
Google Doodle celebrates Christmas caroling
Google
81/116
Today's Google Doodle features activist Steve Biko
Google
82/116 Walter Cronkite
Google celebrates Walter Cronkite's 100th birthday
Google celebrates Valentine's Day with a romantic Doodle
105/116 Dmitri Mendeleev
Google celebrate Dmitri Mendeleev's 182nd birthday
106/116 "The televisor" demonstartion
Google Doodle celebrates 90 years since the first demonstration of television or "the televisor" to the public
107/116 Professor Scoville
Google marks Professor Scoville’s 151st birthday
108/116 Sophie Taeuber-Arp
Google marks Sophie Taeuber-Arp's 127th birthday
109/116 Charles Perrault
Google celebrates author Charles Perrault's 388th birthday
110/116 Mountain of Butterflies discovery
Google celebrates the 41st anniversary of the discovery of the Mountain of Butterflies
111/116 Winter Solstice 2015
Google celebrate the Winter Solstice
112/116 St Andrew's Day 2015
Google marks St Andrew's Day with doodle featuring Scotland's flag and Loch Ness monster
113/116 41st anniversary of the discovery of 'Lucy'
Google marks the 41st anniversary of the discovery of 'Lucy', the name given to a collection of fossilised bones that once made up the skeleton of a hominid from the Australopithecus afarensis species, who lived in Ethiopia 3.2 million years ago
114/116 George Boole
Google marks George Boole's 200th birthday
115/116 Halloween 2015
Google celebrates Halloween using an interactive doodle game "Global Candy Cup"
116/116 Prague Astronomical Clock
Google celebrates the 605th anniversary of the Prague Astronomical Clock, one of the oldest functioning timepieces in the world
Capoeira was eventually outlawed in 1890 by the Brazilian government, concerned about eruptions of street violence.
“In those days, when capoeira was spoken of, it was in whispers. Those who learned capoeira only thought about becoming criminals,” Bimba recalled.
The man himself was one of an astonishing 25 children born to Luiz Candido Machado and Maria Martinha do Bonfim, the father a champion in batuque, another fighting sport loosely comparable with judo or wrestling in which the opponent must be thrown from a ring.
Interestingly, his nickname translates as “Master Phallus”, derived from a bet between his mother and her midwife during labour about whether the newborn would be a boy or a girl. When the child was delivered, the first sighting of his “bimba” provided the answer.
Bimba began to study capoeira in secret under the guidance of a ship’s navigator known as Bentinho as a 12-year-old.
He worked in various odd jobs throughout his youth, serving as a coal miner, carpenter, longshoreman and warehouse operative, but Bimba’s true passion was always capoeira, the young combatant alive to the potential of a sport too long consigned to the shadows.
By 18, he was developing his own version, which would become known as capoeira regional, incorporating elements of batuque picked up from his father as well as inventions of his own.
At the same time, another advocate, Mestre Pastinha, was active in keeping alive a more traditional style: capoeira angola. The pair would become respectful rivals.
In 1928, Mestre Bimba was invited to give a demonstration of his art before Bahia’s governor, Juracy Magalhaes, who was so impressed he overturned the ban in his state and invited Bimba to establish his own teaching school, giving the combat structure and a serious platform away from the streets.
The Academia-escola de Cultura Regional at the Engenho de Brotas opened in Salvador in 1932, its students expected to wear pristine white uniforms, carry themselves with good posture and behave honourably, abstaining from intoxicants.
An empowering undertaking for black Brazilians, Bimba’s school helped capoeira shake off its association with scrappy street violence and soon began to attract middle-class men and women to its dojos.
Prospective students were initially tested by being subjected to a three-minute neck lock, before Mestre Bimba swapped this gruelling initiation rite for a written exam and physical.
World news in pictures
Show all 50
World news in pictures
1/50 14 March 2019
Relatives of crash victims mourn and grieve at the scene where the Ethiopian Airlines Boeing 737 Max 8 crashed shortly after takeoff on Sunday killing all 157 on board, south-east of Addis Ababa. The French air accident investigation authority said that it will handle the analysis of the black boxes retrieved from the crash site and they have already arrived in France but gave no time frame on how long the analysis could take
AP
2/50 13 March 2019
Men carry a child who was rescued at the site of a collapsed building containing a school in Lagos, Nigeria
Reuters
3/50 12 March 2019
A crab stuck in plastic in Verde Island Passage, Philippines. According to data from the Global Alliance for Incinerator Alternatives (GAIA), Filipinos dispose 163 million pieces of single-use plastic sachets daily. An underwater exploration conducted by Greenpeace in Batangas, found single-use plastic sachets between, beneath, and on the corals and seabed of Verde Island Passage, the epicenter of marine biodiversity in the world
EPA
4/50 11 March 2019
Representatives of bereaved families from the affected prefecture offer flowers at an altar for victims of the 2011 earthquake and tsunami disaster during the 8th national memorial service in Tokyo on. On March 11, 2011 a devastating 9.0-magnitude quake struck under the Pacific Ocean and the resulting tsunami caused widespread damage and claimed thousands of lives.
AFP/Getty
5/50 10 March 2019
South Sudanese Catholic faithful believers attend a church service in Udier town
AFP/Getty
6/50 9 March 2019
Activists of Ukrainian nationalist parties scuffle with police officers during a rally to demand an investigation into the corruption of Ukraine's armed forces officials, in Kiev
Reuters
7/50 8 March 2019
Algerian protesters demonstrate against their ailing president's bid for a fifth term in power, in Algiers
AFP/Getty
8/50 7 March 2019
French gendarmes arrive for evacuation as prison guards block the entrance to the penitentiary center of Alencon, in Conde-sur-Sarthe, northwestern France, two days after a prison inmate seriously wounded two guards in a knife attack before being detained in a police raid. - The prison of Alencon / Conde-sur-Sarthe, where two guards were seriously stabbed on March 5 by a radicalized detainee, was blocked again on March 7 by about a hundred prison guards.
AFP/Getty
9/50 6 March 2019
Hindu devotees participate in a traditional activity known locally as "Perang Api" or fire war one day ahead of Nyepi in Mataram, West Nusa Tenggara. Devotees in Indonesia will celebrate Nyepi day or the "Day of Silence" on March 7, the first day of the Saka Lunar calendar
AFP/Getty
10/50 5 March 2019
Time exposure photo shows a series of lightning strikes over Santa Barbara seen from Stearns Wharf in the city's harbor. The storm soaked California and could trigger mudslides in wildfire burn areas where thousands of residents are under evacuation orders, authorities warned
Santa Barbara County Fire Department/AP
11/50 4 March 2019
Members of Unidos da Tijuca samba school perform during the first night of Rio's Carnival at the Sambadrome
AFP/Getty
12/50 3 March 2019
The SpaceX team in Hawthorne watches as the SpaceX Crew Dragon docks with the International Space Station's Harmony module. SpaceX's new crew capsule arrived at the International Space Station on Sunday, acing its second milestone in just over a day
Nasa/AP
13/50 2 March 2019
US Senator Bernie Sanders (centre) waves to supporters at a rally to kick off his 2020 US presidential campaign, in the Brooklyn borough of New York
AFP/Getty
14/50 1 March 2019
Destroyed and deserted buildings are seen at the scene of ongoing fighting between Somali soldiers and al-Shabab fighters in Mogadishu, Somalia. Somali security forces have been exchanging gunfire with gunmen holed up in a building since previous night when a suicide car bomb exploded nearby
EPA
15/50 28 February 2019
Activists of Al-Badr Mujahideen burn an effigy of Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi and the Indian national flag during an anti-India protest in Peshawar on. Prime Minister Narendra Modi asked Indians to "stand as a wall" with anger boiling over Pakistan's capture of a pilot as a crisis escalates between the nuclear-armed rivals. In his first remarks since India and Pakistan both claimed to have shot down each other's fighter planes near the disputed border of Kashmir, the prime minister urged his countrymen to unite "as the enemy seeks to destabilise India
AFP/Getty
16/50 27 February 2019
US President Donald Trump (left) shakes hands with North Korea's leader Kim Jong-un following a meeting at the Sofitel Legend Metropole hotel in Hanoi
AFP/Getty
17/50 26 February 2019
An Indian paramilitary solider fires tear gas shell towards Kashmiri protesters in Srinagar. They were protesting against raids on key separatist leaders by Indian intelligence officers
AP
18/50 25 February 2019
US President Donald Trump speaks at the 2019 White House Business Session with Our Nation's Governors in the State Dining Room. Trump spoke about the Chinese trade deal, the proposed border wall, and his upcoming summit with North Korean dictator Kim Jong-un
EPA
19/50 24 February 2019
Rami Malek (left) winner of Best Actor in a Leading Role award for 'Bohemian Rhapsody, Olivia Colman (second left) winner of Best Actress for 'The Favourite,' Mahershala Ali (right) winner of Best Supporting Actor for 'Green Book,' and Regina King (second right) winner of Best Supporting Actress for 'If Beale Street Could Talk,' pose during the 91st Academy Awards ceremony in Hollywood
EPA
20/50 23 February 2019
Supporters of Venezuelan opposition leader Juan Guaido gather to take part in a rally in Caracas, Venezuela braced for a showdown between the military and regime opponents at the Colombian border on Saturday, when self-declared acting president Juan Guaido has vowed humanitarian aid would enter his country despite a blockade
AFP/Getty
21/50 22 February 2019
A worker walks amongst piles of rubbish at a garbage dump in Blang Bintang, near Banda Aceh
AFP/Getty
22/50 21 February 2019
Firefighters at the scene of a fire in Dhaka. At least 69 people have died in a huge blaze that tore through apartment buildings also used as chemical warehouses in an old part of the Bangladeshi capital Dhaka, fire officials said
AFP/Getty
23/50 20 February 2019
Children ride in the back of a truck that is part of a convoy evacuating hundreds out of the last territory held by Islamic State militants, in Baghouz, eastern Syria. The evacuation signals the end of a week long standoff and opens the way to US-backed Syrian Democratic Forces recapture of the territory
AP
24/50 19 February 2019
Bangladeshi Muslim devotees leave by train after taking part in the Akheri Munajat, or final prayers, at the Biswa Ijtema in Tongi. Several million Muslim devotees from around the world join the four-day long event that ends with a special prayer on the final day
AFP/Getty
25/50 18 February 2019
Flames and smoke billows from a residential building where militants are suspected to have taken refuge during a gun battle in Pulwama, south of Srinagar, Indian controlled Kashmir. Tensions continued to rise in the aftermath of a suicide attack in disputed Kashmir, with seven people killed Monday in a gunbattle that broke out as Indian soldiers scoured the area for militants.
AP
26/50 17 February 2019
People walk down the Champs-Elysees avenue on February protest, called by the yellow vest (gilets jaunes) movement, against French President's policies and top-down style of governing, high cost of living, government tax reforms and for more "social and economic justice."
AFP/Getty
27/50 16 February 2019
US-backed Syrian Democratic Forces (SDF) assault's overall commander Jia Furat (C) answers the press near the Omar oil field in the eastern Syrian Deir Ezzor province. Kurdish-led forces said they were holding up the announcement of final victory over the Islamic State group for "a few days" because the large number of civilians remaining on the battlefield had forced a delay.
AFP/Getty
28/50 15 February 2019
Demonstrators overturn a car during a protest against the attack on a bus that killed 44 Central Reserve Police Force personnel in south Kashmir on Thursday, in Jammu
Reuters
29/50 14 February 2019
Albania's Prime Minister Edi Rama reacts as ink is thrown at him by members of the opposition during parliamentary session in Tirana
Reuters
30/50 13 February 2019
A man cleans a car from snow during a snowfall in Moscow, Russia
Reuters
31/50 12 February 2019
A general view shows the Hotel Arpit Palace after a fire broke out on its premises in New Delhi. At least 17 people died on February 12 as a fire tore through the budget hotel in Delhi before dawn, in the latest disaster to raise concerns over fire safety in India.
AFP/Getty
32/50 11 February 2019
Priyanka Gandhi Vadra, a leader of India's main opposition Congress party and sister of the party president Rahul Gandhi, greets her supporters from atop a vehicle during a roadshow in Lucknow, India,
Reuters
33/50 10 February 2019
Female artists dominated the Grammys with Alicia Keys opening the show up by inviting her “sisters” Lady Gaga, Jennifer Lopez, Michelle Obama and Jada Pinkett Smith onto the stage. “Every voice we hear deserves to be honoured and respected,” said Pinkett Smith. “Tonight we celebrate the greatest in each other, through all of us, through music,” added Alicia Keys. “Who runs the world?” The most notable female triumph was Cardi B’s. The only woman in her category, competing against Nipsey Hussle, Pusha T, Travis Scott and Mac Miller, Cardi won Best Rap Album for her playfully inventive debut Invasion of Privacy. This made her the first female solo artist in history to win in the category
Reuters
34/50 9 February 2019
Democratic senator Elizabeth Warren arrives to announce her candidacy for the 2020 Democratic presidential nomination at Everett Mills in Lawrence, Massachusetts
EPA
35/50 8 February 2019
Thai Raksa Chart Party leader Preechapol Pongpanich (C-L) submits the election registration form to an officer at the Election Commission in Bangkok, Thailand. A political party linked with Thaksin Shinawatra, the Thai Raksa Chart Party nominated Princess Ubolratana Mahidol, elder sister of King Maha Vajiralongkorn, as prime minister candidate for the upcoming general election. Thailand is set to hold a general election on 24 March 2019, the first poll in five years since the May 2014 military coup.
EPA
36/50 7 February 2019
Technicians set up material and work on the western section of the remains of the Morandi bridge in Genoa on the eve of the official start of the demolition work
AFP/Getty
37/50 6 February 2019
Rescue workers and people try to remove debris of an eight-story building which collapsed in Istanbul which killed at least one person and trapped several others inside the rubble, Turkish media reports said
AP
38/50 5 February 2019
For many President Trump's State of the Union address was overshadowed by Democratic House Speaker Nancy Pelosi's applause after his call for political unity, which many interpreted as "sarcastic"
AFP/Getty
39/50 4 February 2019
Thousands of Hindu devotees take dips at Sangam, the confluence of three sacred rivers the Yamuna, the Ganges and the mythical Saraswati, on Mauni Amavsya or the new moon day, the most auspicious day during the Kumbh Mela or the Pitcher Festival, in Prayagraj, Uttar Pradesh state, India. The Kumbh Mela is a series of ritual baths by Hindu sadhus, or holy men, and other pilgrims at Sangam that dates back to at least medieval times. Pilgrims bathe in the river believing it cleanses them of their sins and ends their process of reincarnation. The event, which UNESCO added to its list of intangible human heritage in 2017, is the largest congregation of pilgrims on earth. Some 150 million people are expected to attend this year's Kumbh, which runs through early March
AP
40/50 3 February 2019
Tom Brady celebrates after New England Patriots won Super Bowl LIII against the Los Angeles Rams at Mercedes-Benz Stadium
USA TODAY Sports
41/50 2 February 2019
Venezuelan opposition leader and self-proclaimed interim president Juan Guaido waves to supporters during a rally against Venezuelan President Nicolas Maduro's government in Caracas, Venezuela
Reuters
42/50 1 February 2019
Palestinians perform Friday prayers as smoke rises from burning tires during a protest against Jewish settlements, in al-Mughayyir village near Ramallah, in the Israeli-occupied West Bank
AFP/Getty
43/50 31 January 2019
Ice covers the Lake Michigan shoreline in Chicago, US. Businesses and schools have closed, Amtrak has suspended service into the city, more than a thousand flights have been cancelled and mail delivery has been suspended as the city copes with record-setting low temperatures
Getty
44/50 30 January 2019
Man moves luggage in snow during a winter storm in Buffalo, New York
Reuters
45/50 29 January 2019
Firemen try to extinguish burning cars at the scene where a car bomb exploded in front of a restaurant in Mogadishu, Somalia
Reuters
46/50 28 January 2019
A tornado and pounding rains smashed into the eastern part of Cuba's capital overnight, toppling trees, bending power poles and flinging shards of metal roofing through the air as the storm cut a path of destruction across eastern Havana
AP
47/50 27 January 2019
Policemen and soldiers keep watch as body bags (in white), containing the remains of blast victims, as seen in a cordoned area outside a church in Jolo, Sulu province on the southern island of Mindanao. At least 18 people were killed when two bombs hit a church on a southern Philippine island that is a stronghold of Islamist militants, days after voters backed the creation of a new Muslim autonomous region
AFP/Getty
48/50 26 January 2019
Aerial view showing firemen looking for people in heavy machinery (L and R) and a locomotive (C) after the collapse of a dam which belonged to Brazil's giant mining company Vale, near the town of Brumadinho in southeastern Brazil
AFP/Getty
49/50 25 January 2019
Indian police personnel block unemployed Indian teachers, as they march towards the residence of Punjab Education Minister Om Parkash Soni during a protest against the Punjab state government to demand jobs in Amritsar
AFP/Getty
50/50 24 January 2019
Supporters of newly elected President of the Democratic Republic of Congo Felix Tshisekedi cheer as they arrive to attend his Presidential Inauguration in Kinshasa. Tshisekedi took the oath of office before receiving the national flag and a copy of the constitution from outgoing president Joseph Kabila, stepping aside after 18 years at the helm of sub-Saharan Africa's biggest country, marking the country's first-ever peaceful handover of power after chaotic and bitterly-disputed elections
AFP/Getty
1/50 14 March 2019
Relatives of crash victims mourn and grieve at the scene where the Ethiopian Airlines Boeing 737 Max 8 crashed shortly after takeoff on Sunday killing all 157 on board, south-east of Addis Ababa. The French air accident investigation authority said that it will handle the analysis of the black boxes retrieved from the crash site and they have already arrived in France but gave no time frame on how long the analysis could take
AP
2/50 13 March 2019
Men carry a child who was rescued at the site of a collapsed building containing a school in Lagos, Nigeria
Reuters
3/50 12 March 2019
A crab stuck in plastic in Verde Island Passage, Philippines. According to data from the Global Alliance for Incinerator Alternatives (GAIA), Filipinos dispose 163 million pieces of single-use plastic sachets daily. An underwater exploration conducted by Greenpeace in Batangas, found single-use plastic sachets between, beneath, and on the corals and seabed of Verde Island Passage, the epicenter of marine biodiversity in the world
EPA
4/50 11 March 2019
Representatives of bereaved families from the affected prefecture offer flowers at an altar for victims of the 2011 earthquake and tsunami disaster during the 8th national memorial service in Tokyo on. On March 11, 2011 a devastating 9.0-magnitude quake struck under the Pacific Ocean and the resulting tsunami caused widespread damage and claimed thousands of lives.
AFP/Getty
5/50 10 March 2019
South Sudanese Catholic faithful believers attend a church service in Udier town
AFP/Getty
6/50 9 March 2019
Activists of Ukrainian nationalist parties scuffle with police officers during a rally to demand an investigation into the corruption of Ukraine's armed forces officials, in Kiev
Reuters
7/50 8 March 2019
Algerian protesters demonstrate against their ailing president's bid for a fifth term in power, in Algiers
AFP/Getty
8/50 7 March 2019
French gendarmes arrive for evacuation as prison guards block the entrance to the penitentiary center of Alencon, in Conde-sur-Sarthe, northwestern France, two days after a prison inmate seriously wounded two guards in a knife attack before being detained in a police raid. - The prison of Alencon / Conde-sur-Sarthe, where two guards were seriously stabbed on March 5 by a radicalized detainee, was blocked again on March 7 by about a hundred prison guards.
AFP/Getty
9/50 6 March 2019
Hindu devotees participate in a traditional activity known locally as "Perang Api" or fire war one day ahead of Nyepi in Mataram, West Nusa Tenggara. Devotees in Indonesia will celebrate Nyepi day or the "Day of Silence" on March 7, the first day of the Saka Lunar calendar
AFP/Getty
10/50 5 March 2019
Time exposure photo shows a series of lightning strikes over Santa Barbara seen from Stearns Wharf in the city's harbor. The storm soaked California and could trigger mudslides in wildfire burn areas where thousands of residents are under evacuation orders, authorities warned
Santa Barbara County Fire Department/AP
11/50 4 March 2019
Members of Unidos da Tijuca samba school perform during the first night of Rio's Carnival at the Sambadrome
AFP/Getty
12/50 3 March 2019
The SpaceX team in Hawthorne watches as the SpaceX Crew Dragon docks with the International Space Station's Harmony module. SpaceX's new crew capsule arrived at the International Space Station on Sunday, acing its second milestone in just over a day
Nasa/AP
13/50 2 March 2019
US Senator Bernie Sanders (centre) waves to supporters at a rally to kick off his 2020 US presidential campaign, in the Brooklyn borough of New York
AFP/Getty
14/50 1 March 2019
Destroyed and deserted buildings are seen at the scene of ongoing fighting between Somali soldiers and al-Shabab fighters in Mogadishu, Somalia. Somali security forces have been exchanging gunfire with gunmen holed up in a building since previous night when a suicide car bomb exploded nearby
EPA
15/50 28 February 2019
Activists of Al-Badr Mujahideen burn an effigy of Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi and the Indian national flag during an anti-India protest in Peshawar on. Prime Minister Narendra Modi asked Indians to "stand as a wall" with anger boiling over Pakistan's capture of a pilot as a crisis escalates between the nuclear-armed rivals. In his first remarks since India and Pakistan both claimed to have shot down each other's fighter planes near the disputed border of Kashmir, the prime minister urged his countrymen to unite "as the enemy seeks to destabilise India
AFP/Getty
16/50 27 February 2019
US President Donald Trump (left) shakes hands with North Korea's leader Kim Jong-un following a meeting at the Sofitel Legend Metropole hotel in Hanoi
AFP/Getty
17/50 26 February 2019
An Indian paramilitary solider fires tear gas shell towards Kashmiri protesters in Srinagar. They were protesting against raids on key separatist leaders by Indian intelligence officers
AP
18/50 25 February 2019
US President Donald Trump speaks at the 2019 White House Business Session with Our Nation's Governors in the State Dining Room. Trump spoke about the Chinese trade deal, the proposed border wall, and his upcoming summit with North Korean dictator Kim Jong-un
EPA
19/50 24 February 2019
Rami Malek (left) winner of Best Actor in a Leading Role award for 'Bohemian Rhapsody, Olivia Colman (second left) winner of Best Actress for 'The Favourite,' Mahershala Ali (right) winner of Best Supporting Actor for 'Green Book,' and Regina King (second right) winner of Best Supporting Actress for 'If Beale Street Could Talk,' pose during the 91st Academy Awards ceremony in Hollywood
EPA
20/50 23 February 2019
Supporters of Venezuelan opposition leader Juan Guaido gather to take part in a rally in Caracas, Venezuela braced for a showdown between the military and regime opponents at the Colombian border on Saturday, when self-declared acting president Juan Guaido has vowed humanitarian aid would enter his country despite a blockade
AFP/Getty
21/50 22 February 2019
A worker walks amongst piles of rubbish at a garbage dump in Blang Bintang, near Banda Aceh
AFP/Getty
22/50 21 February 2019
Firefighters at the scene of a fire in Dhaka. At least 69 people have died in a huge blaze that tore through apartment buildings also used as chemical warehouses in an old part of the Bangladeshi capital Dhaka, fire officials said
AFP/Getty
23/50 20 February 2019
Children ride in the back of a truck that is part of a convoy evacuating hundreds out of the last territory held by Islamic State militants, in Baghouz, eastern Syria. The evacuation signals the end of a week long standoff and opens the way to US-backed Syrian Democratic Forces recapture of the territory
AP
24/50 19 February 2019
Bangladeshi Muslim devotees leave by train after taking part in the Akheri Munajat, or final prayers, at the Biswa Ijtema in Tongi. Several million Muslim devotees from around the world join the four-day long event that ends with a special prayer on the final day
AFP/Getty
25/50 18 February 2019
Flames and smoke billows from a residential building where militants are suspected to have taken refuge during a gun battle in Pulwama, south of Srinagar, Indian controlled Kashmir. Tensions continued to rise in the aftermath of a suicide attack in disputed Kashmir, with seven people killed Monday in a gunbattle that broke out as Indian soldiers scoured the area for militants.
AP
26/50 17 February 2019
People walk down the Champs-Elysees avenue on February protest, called by the yellow vest (gilets jaunes) movement, against French President's policies and top-down style of governing, high cost of living, government tax reforms and for more "social and economic justice."
AFP/Getty
27/50 16 February 2019
US-backed Syrian Democratic Forces (SDF) assault's overall commander Jia Furat (C) answers the press near the Omar oil field in the eastern Syrian Deir Ezzor province. Kurdish-led forces said they were holding up the announcement of final victory over the Islamic State group for "a few days" because the large number of civilians remaining on the battlefield had forced a delay.
AFP/Getty
28/50 15 February 2019
Demonstrators overturn a car during a protest against the attack on a bus that killed 44 Central Reserve Police Force personnel in south Kashmir on Thursday, in Jammu
Reuters
29/50 14 February 2019
Albania's Prime Minister Edi Rama reacts as ink is thrown at him by members of the opposition during parliamentary session in Tirana
Reuters
30/50 13 February 2019
A man cleans a car from snow during a snowfall in Moscow, Russia
Reuters
31/50 12 February 2019
A general view shows the Hotel Arpit Palace after a fire broke out on its premises in New Delhi. At least 17 people died on February 12 as a fire tore through the budget hotel in Delhi before dawn, in the latest disaster to raise concerns over fire safety in India.
AFP/Getty
32/50 11 February 2019
Priyanka Gandhi Vadra, a leader of India's main opposition Congress party and sister of the party president Rahul Gandhi, greets her supporters from atop a vehicle during a roadshow in Lucknow, India,
Reuters
33/50 10 February 2019
Female artists dominated the Grammys with Alicia Keys opening the show up by inviting her “sisters” Lady Gaga, Jennifer Lopez, Michelle Obama and Jada Pinkett Smith onto the stage. “Every voice we hear deserves to be honoured and respected,” said Pinkett Smith. “Tonight we celebrate the greatest in each other, through all of us, through music,” added Alicia Keys. “Who runs the world?” The most notable female triumph was Cardi B’s. The only woman in her category, competing against Nipsey Hussle, Pusha T, Travis Scott and Mac Miller, Cardi won Best Rap Album for her playfully inventive debut Invasion of Privacy. This made her the first female solo artist in history to win in the category
Reuters
34/50 9 February 2019
Democratic senator Elizabeth Warren arrives to announce her candidacy for the 2020 Democratic presidential nomination at Everett Mills in Lawrence, Massachusetts
EPA
35/50 8 February 2019
Thai Raksa Chart Party leader Preechapol Pongpanich (C-L) submits the election registration form to an officer at the Election Commission in Bangkok, Thailand. A political party linked with Thaksin Shinawatra, the Thai Raksa Chart Party nominated Princess Ubolratana Mahidol, elder sister of King Maha Vajiralongkorn, as prime minister candidate for the upcoming general election. Thailand is set to hold a general election on 24 March 2019, the first poll in five years since the May 2014 military coup.
EPA
36/50 7 February 2019
Technicians set up material and work on the western section of the remains of the Morandi bridge in Genoa on the eve of the official start of the demolition work
AFP/Getty
37/50 6 February 2019
Rescue workers and people try to remove debris of an eight-story building which collapsed in Istanbul which killed at least one person and trapped several others inside the rubble, Turkish media reports said
AP
38/50 5 February 2019
For many President Trump's State of the Union address was overshadowed by Democratic House Speaker Nancy Pelosi's applause after his call for political unity, which many interpreted as "sarcastic"
AFP/Getty
39/50 4 February 2019
Thousands of Hindu devotees take dips at Sangam, the confluence of three sacred rivers the Yamuna, the Ganges and the mythical Saraswati, on Mauni Amavsya or the new moon day, the most auspicious day during the Kumbh Mela or the Pitcher Festival, in Prayagraj, Uttar Pradesh state, India. The Kumbh Mela is a series of ritual baths by Hindu sadhus, or holy men, and other pilgrims at Sangam that dates back to at least medieval times. Pilgrims bathe in the river believing it cleanses them of their sins and ends their process of reincarnation. The event, which UNESCO added to its list of intangible human heritage in 2017, is the largest congregation of pilgrims on earth. Some 150 million people are expected to attend this year's Kumbh, which runs through early March
AP
40/50 3 February 2019
Tom Brady celebrates after New England Patriots won Super Bowl LIII against the Los Angeles Rams at Mercedes-Benz Stadium
USA TODAY Sports
41/50 2 February 2019
Venezuelan opposition leader and self-proclaimed interim president Juan Guaido waves to supporters during a rally against Venezuelan President Nicolas Maduro's government in Caracas, Venezuela
Reuters
42/50 1 February 2019
Palestinians perform Friday prayers as smoke rises from burning tires during a protest against Jewish settlements, in al-Mughayyir village near Ramallah, in the Israeli-occupied West Bank
AFP/Getty
43/50 31 January 2019
Ice covers the Lake Michigan shoreline in Chicago, US. Businesses and schools have closed, Amtrak has suspended service into the city, more than a thousand flights have been cancelled and mail delivery has been suspended as the city copes with record-setting low temperatures
Getty
44/50 30 January 2019
Man moves luggage in snow during a winter storm in Buffalo, New York
Reuters
45/50 29 January 2019
Firemen try to extinguish burning cars at the scene where a car bomb exploded in front of a restaurant in Mogadishu, Somalia
Reuters
46/50 28 January 2019
A tornado and pounding rains smashed into the eastern part of Cuba's capital overnight, toppling trees, bending power poles and flinging shards of metal roofing through the air as the storm cut a path of destruction across eastern Havana
AP
47/50 27 January 2019
Policemen and soldiers keep watch as body bags (in white), containing the remains of blast victims, as seen in a cordoned area outside a church in Jolo, Sulu province on the southern island of Mindanao. At least 18 people were killed when two bombs hit a church on a southern Philippine island that is a stronghold of Islamist militants, days after voters backed the creation of a new Muslim autonomous region
AFP/Getty
48/50 26 January 2019
Aerial view showing firemen looking for people in heavy machinery (L and R) and a locomotive (C) after the collapse of a dam which belonged to Brazil's giant mining company Vale, near the town of Brumadinho in southeastern Brazil
AFP/Getty
49/50 25 January 2019
Indian police personnel block unemployed Indian teachers, as they march towards the residence of Punjab Education Minister Om Parkash Soni during a protest against the Punjab state government to demand jobs in Amritsar
AFP/Getty
50/50 24 January 2019
Supporters of newly elected President of the Democratic Republic of Congo Felix Tshisekedi cheer as they arrive to attend his Presidential Inauguration in Kinshasa. Tshisekedi took the oath of office before receiving the national flag and a copy of the constitution from outgoing president Joseph Kabila, stepping aside after 18 years at the helm of sub-Saharan Africa's biggest country, marking the country's first-ever peaceful handover of power after chaotic and bitterly-disputed elections
AFP/Getty
A second school was opened in 1942 and Bimba was honoured by Brazilian president Getulio Dorneles Vargas in 1953, who proclaimed: “Capoeira is the only sport that is truly Brazilian.”
Never shying away from the ring, Mestre Bimba was known as a fierce fighter in his own right, dubbed “Tres Pancadas” (“Three Hits”) for his ability to quickly dispatch rivals.
Support free-thinking journalism and subscribe to Independent Minds
One of the most famous anecdotes about his life, as reported by the newspaper A Tarde in August 1936, recounts his being attacked by a corrupt police chief and six officers after the former had lost money on one of his bouts, knocking all seven men senseless. Another version of the same story suggests Bimba himself had started the brawl by intervening to stop the drunken officers attacking a young boy.
A legend in his own lifetime, Mestre Bimba passed away of a stroke in Goiania, Golas, on 5 February 1974.
We’ll tell you what’s true. You can form your own view.
At The Independent, no one tells us what to write. That’s why, in an era of political lies and Brexit bias, more readers are turning to an independent source. Subscribe from just 15p a day for extra exclusives, events and ebooks – all with no ads.
Subscribe to Independent Minds to debate the big issues
Want to discuss real-world problems, be involved in the most engaging discussions and hear from the
journalists? Try Independent Minds free for 1 month.
Subscribe to Independent Minds to debate the big issues
Want to discuss real-world problems, be involved in the most engaging discussions and hear from the
journalists? Try Independent Minds free for 1 month.
Independent Minds Comments can be posted by members of our membership scheme, Independent Minds.
It allows our most engaged readers to debate the big issues, share their own experiences, discuss
real-world solutions, and more. Our journalists will try to respond by joining the threads when
they can to create a true meeting of independent minds. The most insightful comments on all subjects
will be published daily in dedicated articles. You can also choose to be emailed when someone replies
to your comment.
The existing Open Comments threads will continue to exist for those who do not subscribe to
Independent Minds. Due to the sheer scale of this comment community, we are not able to give each post
the same level of attention, but we have preserved this area in the interests of open debate. Please
continue to respect all commenters and create constructive debates.
Comments
Share your thoughts and debate the big issues
Please be respectful when making a comment and adhere to our Community Guidelines.
You can find our Community Guidelines in full here.
Please be respectful when making a comment and adhere to our Community Guidelines.
Community Guidelines
You can find our Community Guidelines in full here.
Follow comments
Vote
Report Comment
Subscribe to Independent Minds to debate the big issues
Want to discuss real-world problems, be involved in the most engaging discussions and hear from the journalists? Try Independent Minds free for 1 month.
Already registered? Log inReport Comment
Delete Comment
Subscribe to Independent Minds to debate the big issues
Want to discuss real-world problems, be involved in the most engaging discussions and hear from the journalists? Try Independent Minds free for 1 month.
Already registered? Log inAbout The Independent commenting
Independent Minds Comments can be posted by members of our membership scheme, Independent Minds. It allows our most engaged readers to debate the big issues, share their own experiences, discuss real-world solutions, and more. Our journalists will try to respond by joining the threads when they can to create a true meeting of independent minds. The most insightful comments on all subjects will be published daily in dedicated articles. You can also choose to be emailed when someone replies to your comment.
The existing Open Comments threads will continue to exist for those who do not subscribe to Independent Minds. Due to the sheer scale of this comment community, we are not able to give each post the same level of attention, but we have preserved this area in the interests of open debate. Please continue to respect all commenters and create constructive debates.