Trump mistakenly tells weeping voter her mother died of coronavirus, not cancer

'That is just devastating because I can imagine how you feel and it sounds like a great woman and I’ll tell you she ... and I can … I’m pretty good with people'

Justin Vallejo
New York
Wednesday 16 September 2020 22:30 BST
Trump mistakenly tells weeping voter her mother died of Covid not breast cancer

Support truly
independent journalism

Our mission is to deliver unbiased, fact-based reporting that holds power to account and exposes the truth.

Whether $5 or $50, every contribution counts.

Support us to deliver journalism without an agenda.

Louise Thomas

Louise Thomas


Donald Trump has come under fire for mistakenly telling a participant of Tuesday night's ABC News town hall that her mother, who died of cancer, suffered from Covid-19.

As Flor Cruceta became emotional during the event in Pennsylvania, Mr Trump asked "did you say your mum got Covid? Your mum?" Holding back tears, she remembered how she and her mother immigrated from the Dominican Republic in 2006 to live their American dream.

"She had breast cancer but it made metastases on her brain, bone, and lungs and she passed on the 19th," Ms Cruceta said.

"I'm here because of her. She was supposed to be here and ask you and thank you for this -- if they should take -- during this epidemic, you made people closer. We lost our jobs but we learned how to love our family. So I'm saying that from her."

After being asked what he would do to make the immigration system easier for families like hers to become citizens and vote, Mr Trump went into his answer about a merit-based system before returning to Ms Cruceta's mother.

"I mean as far as your situation with your mother, that is just devastating because I can imagine how you feel and it sounds like a great woman," Mr Trump began.

"The love that you have for your mother, I can see that, it’s hard. And so many people and they die alone. They die alone because this is such a vicious thing. You can’t go there and hold their hand. You can’t give them a kiss good night. It’s a terrible, terrible thing. And hopefully the vaccines are going to be very soon, hopefully. Did you have Covid? You didn’t have it right?"

When she replied "No", the president seemed confused.

"You didn’t have it, your mother. We’ll have it taken care of. It’s going to get taken care of. The vaccines are going to make a big difference. What has made a big difference is Remdesivir."

Ms Cruceta, who lives in Harrisburg, Pennsylvania and recently became a citizen at the urging of her mother, said on Wednesday that she was thankful for the opportunity to speak to the president.

"He did answer about immigration a little, but he misunderstood my mum succumbing from brain, lungs and bones cancer, no Covid-19," she said in a Facebook post.

While Mr Trump's answer included a commitment to soon announce a new merit-based system that would allow more legal immigration like that of the Cruceta family, the reaction focused on the president's seeming confusion.

Join our commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies


Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in