Donald Trump set to completely scrap US consumer protection agency, says man expected to lead it

Exclusive: Former Texan Congressman tells The Independent his Republican colleagues want the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau to be completely dismantled

Tom Batchelor@_tombatchelor
Tuesday 14 March 2017 17:00
Mr Neugebauer is leading calls for the agency in its current form to be dismantled
Mr Neugebauer is leading calls for the agency in its current form to be dismantled

Donald Trump is facing mounting pressure to completely scrap America’s consumer protection agency, the man lined up by the President to head the watchdog has revealed.

Loan sharks, payday lenders and rogue debt collectors could be given carte blanche to rip off American customers as part of a touted shake up of the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB).

Randy Neugebauer, considered the favourite to replace the current director of the CFPB, said Mr Trump was facing pressure from inside the Republican Party to dismantle the agency entirely.

Following Mr Trump’s election last November, he emerged as the frontrunner to take charge of the watchdog. The former Texan Congressman, who retired in January, held talks with the then-President-Elect in Trump Tower shortly before his inauguration.

Speaking exclusively to The Independent in his first interview since the new administration was installed in the White House, Mr Neugebauer said his meeting with Mr Trump included discussions about deregulating financial markets and gutting the CFPB.

“Some of my colleagues want to do away with the CFPB,” he said. “I don’t think you want to do away with consumer protection but you want to change it.

“The government ought not to be telling you what kind of financial products are appropriate for you.”

The CFPB is tasked with protecting the public from unfair or abusive practices by mortgage servicers, payday lenders, and debt collectors.

It has powers to take action against companies that break the law and in a recent case sued a law firm for allegedly “scamming 9/11 heroes out of money intended to cover medical costs”.

The watchdog also acts on cases of suspected age or race discrimination.

But Mr Neugebauer is leading calls for the agency in its current form to be dismantled and his appointment to lead it would likely see the watchdog lose much of its clout.

He claimed American consumers were being suffocated with regulations and should be free to choose loans and mortgages, regardless of whether the deals on offer were good or bad.

​Mr Neugebauer said he would accept an offer from the President to run the agency “depending on what the long-range plan is”.

“We had a broad discussion. We did not discuss a specific job. It has been rumoured, but an offer has not been extended.”

Mr Neugebauer, who represented west Texas’s 19th congressional district, also voiced his support for payday lenders, despite a lack of transparency and often crippling rates of interest that have led to calls for them to be banned.

“Millions and millions of people use payday lending as a source of credit because they have poor credit scores,” he said.


He also gave his backing to the President’s executive order calling for a review of the 2010 Dodd-Frank financial regulations.

Obama-era rules designed to curb the riskiest actions of banks before the financial crisis had been an overreaction, he said.

“Blanket regulation over the entire financial market is impacting some of the entities that possibly were part of the cause, but in many cases entities that really didn’t have anything to do with the crisis are affected.

“Many folks, including myself, think we went too far.”

Under the CPFB’s current director, Richard Cordray, billions of dollars have been returned to consumers caught up in credit scams or malpractice in the banking sector.

Trump spokesperson complains everyone believes Obama and no one believes Trump

But Mr Neugebauer suggested that the problem was being overstated, and said individual states were often doing a better job than the federal agency.

“Obviously there are people out there that abuse the system, but people have [already] taken action against those,” he said on the sidelines of an event at London Metropolitan University.

“There is some uniformity that can come from having consumer protection at a federal level [but] I think the states have done a pretty good job.”

The CFPB has been under threat since a federal appeals court found in October the agency’s structure was unconstitutional.

The court also ruled that the US president should be able to dismiss the director at will, putting at risk the job of Mr Cordray, whose five year term doesn’t end until 2018.

The agency was born out of the 2010 Dodd-Frank Wall Street reform law and is considered one of Barack Obama’s top domestic policy achievements.

President Obama signs the the financial reform bill into law in 2010

However, it is hated by libertarians who say it is guilty of mission creep and should be reformed or disbanded.

Fellow Texas Republicans senator Ted Cruz and representative John Ratcliffe introduced a one-page bill to kill the bureau entirely last month.

Winding up the agency would prove hugely controversial, and even some in the banking sector have warned against clipping the CFPB’s wings.

Join our new commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies

View comments