Trump’s lawyers claim he cannot be forced to testify, leaked letter reveals

Letter argues president could not have committed obstruction because he has absolute authority over all federal investigations

Jonathan Lemire
Sunday 03 June 2018 17:10 BST
Comments
Donald Trump had previously signalled he would be willing to sit for an interview, but his legal team have privately and publicly expressed concern the president could risk charges of perjury
Donald Trump had previously signalled he would be willing to sit for an interview, but his legal team have privately and publicly expressed concern the president could risk charges of perjury (Getty)

Support truly
independent journalism

Our mission is to deliver unbiased, fact-based reporting that holds power to account and exposes the truth.

Whether $5 or $50, every contribution counts.

Support us to deliver journalism without an agenda.

Louise Thomas

Louise Thomas

Editor

Donald Trump’s lawyers composed a secret 20-page letter to special counsel Robert Mueller to assert he cannot be forced to testify.

It also argued he could not have committed obstruction because he has absolute authority over all federal investigations.

The existence of the letter, which was first reported by The New York Times on Saturday, was a bold assertion of presidential power and another front on which Mr Trump’s lawyers have argued that the president can’t be subpoenaed in the special counsel’s ongoing investigation into Russian meddling in the 2016 election.

The letter is dated 29 January and addressed to Mr Mueller from John Dowd, one of Mr Trump’s lawyers at the time who has since resigned from the legal team.

Donald Trump suggests he would override his legal team submit to interview with Robert Mueller

In the letter, Mr Trump’s lawyers argue a charge of illegal obstruction is moot because the Constitution empowers the president to ”if he wished, terminate the inquiry, or even exercise his power to pardon.”

Mr Trump weighed in on Saturday on Twitter, asking “Is the Special Counsel/Justice Department leaking my lawyers letters to the Fake News Media?”

He added: “When will this very expensive Witch Hunt Hoax ever end? So bad for our Country.”

Mr Mueller has requested an interview with the president to determine whether he had criminal intent to obstruct the investigation into his associates’ possible links to Russia’s election interference.

Mr Trump had previously signalled he would be willing to sit for an interview, but his legal team, including head lawyer Rudy Giuliani, have privately and publicly expressed concern that the president could risk charges of perjury.

If Mr Trump does not consent to an interview, Mr Mueller will have to decide whether to forge ahead with a historic grand jury subpoena.

His team raised the possibility in March of subpoenaing the president but it is not clear if it is still under active consideration.

Mr Giuliani has told The Associated Press that the president’s legal team believes the special counsel does not have the authority to do so.

A court battle is likely if Mr Trump’s team argues that the president can’t be forced to answer questions or be charged with obstruction of justice.

President Bill Clinton was charged with obstruction in 1998 by the House of Representatives as part of his impeachment trial. And one of the articles of impeachment prepared against Richard Nixon in 1974 was for obstruction.

Topics of Mr Mueller’s obstruction investigation include the firings of both Mr Comey and former national security adviser Michael Flynn, as well Mr Trump’s reaction to attorney general Jeff Sessions’ recusal from the Russia investigation.

In addition to the legal battles, Mr Trump’s team and allies have waged a public relations campaign against Mr Mueller to discredit the investigation and soften the impact of the special counsel’s potential findings.

Mr Giuliani said last week that the special counsel probe may be an “entirely illegitimate investigation” and need to be curtailed because, in his estimation, it was based on inappropriately obtained information from an informant and former FBI director James Comey’s memos.

In reality, the FBI began a counterintelligence investigation in July 2016 to determine if Mr Trump campaign associates were coordinating with Russia to tip the election. The investigation was opened after the hacking of Democratic emails that intelligence officials later formally attributed to Russia.

Mr Giuliani has said a decision will not be made about a possible presidential interview with the special counsel until after Mr Trump’s summit with North Korean leader Kim Jong-un on 12 June in Singapore.

Associated Press

Join our commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies

Comments

Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in