2020 election: Black and gay candidates to cause record number of upsets on back of George Floyd protests

In New York, nonwhite candidates are poised to capture nominations for House seats in majority-white suburbs

David Weigel,Paul Kane
Thursday 25 June 2020 10:45 BST
Eliot Engels caught on hot mic saying 'if I didn't have a primary I wouldn't care' at George Floyd protest

Support truly
independent journalism

Our mission is to deliver unbiased, fact-based reporting that holds power to account and exposes the truth.

Whether $5 or $50, every contribution counts.

Support us to deliver journalism without an agenda.

Louise Thomas

Louise Thomas


Young black and gay candidates were heading for electoral breakthroughs this week, turning the public clamour for racial justice and equality into likely primary upsets in New York, Kentucky and Virginia.

Those results have revealed a resurgent left, which has pivoted from defeat in the Democratic presidential primary to a focus on down-ballot races. In safe blue seats, and in places where the party has tended to nominate moderates, a coalition of white liberals and nonwhite voters is transferring energy from the past month’s protest movements into challenges of the party’s establishment.

“Let’s allow this to be a moment where every single person in this district, and every single person in this country, feels like they are a part of our democracy,” said Jamaal Bowman, a former middle school principal who declared victory over 16-term representative Eliot Engel, D-N.Y. “You know what Donald Trump is more afraid of than anything else? A black man with power.”

Mr Bowman’s likely win came during protests that upended American cities following the death of George Floyd, an unarmed black man who died in Minneapolis police custody a month ago. Potential wins for two openly gay candidates came a week after the Supreme Court ruled that gay and transgender workers are protected from workplace discrimination under the landmark 1964 civil rights law, a major victory for the LGBT+ movement.

The apparent victories of many of the candidates – the wait for hundreds of thousands of absentee ballots has delayed calls on the outcome – stretch from New York’s Westchester County to Virginia’s Blue Ridge Mountains.

In Virginia, Cameron Webb – an African American physician, former White House fellow and health policy researcher – easily won the Democratic nomination in a sprawling House district that includes the city of Charlottesville. In Kentucky’s Senate primary, black state legislator Charles Booker was running close with Amy McGrath, a retired Marine Corps fighter pilot and suburban mother backed by the national party.

And in New York, nonwhite candidates were poised to capture nominations for House seats in majority-white suburbs, gaining ground in the sort of races where party machines had long resisted change.

Mr Engel, chairman of the House Foreign Affairs Committee, called Mr Bowman’s victory claim premature in a district that encompasses the northern Bronx and a southern swath of suburban Westchester County. But Mr Bowman was already accepting congratulations from the national liberal groups that backed him.

Wins in many of the primaries would be tantamount to capturing the seat in the heavily Democratic districts.

And while these Democrats replacing Democrats will not be shifting the balance of power in the House, they represent a massive generational change that could pose a challenge to house speaker Nancy Pelosi, D-Calif., and disrupt the more tradition-supporting Congressional Black Caucus and Congressional Hispanic Caucus.

“People are beginning to look at black candidates not through the lens of electability, but through whether they’re the right person for the job,” said Stefanie Brown James, the co-founder of Collective PAC, which spent hundreds of thousands of dollars in ads across the three states voting Tuesday. “I’ve known Mondaire Jones since high school, and to see him ascend from being an NAACP youth leader to, potentially, a congressman, is just crazy.”

Mr Jones, an attorney and former official in the Obama Justice Department, held a primary lead in a crowded field vying to replace retiring representative Nita Lowey, D-N.Y., chairman of the House Appropriations Committee. Ms Lowey will turn 83 on July 5.

If he wins, Mr Jones would be the first openly gay black member of Congress, representing a district that includes Rockland and northern Westchester counties – home to Bill and Hillary Clinton.

“For most of this race, much of Westchester County’s Democratic establishment doubted that I could win this election. And so I hope that these people will reconsider the next time they make assumptions about candidates like myself and our viability even as we outperform the competition by all conceivable measures,” Mr Jones said in an interview on Wednesday. “We have to cultivate diverse talent and support diverse talent and not push them to the side or marginalise them.”

Mr Jones had the endorsement of senator Bernie Sanders, I-Vt., the unsuccessful Democratic presidential candidate, and other leading liberals as he backed several of their priorities, including the Green New Deal.

New York Democratic House candidate Jamaal Bowman is set to unseat representative Eliot Engel (D-NY) for the 16th congressional district
New York Democratic House candidate Jamaal Bowman is set to unseat representative Eliot Engel (D-NY) for the 16th congressional district (Getty)

“I was never running for Congress to make history, but the historic nature of this campaign is obviously not lost on me,” Mr Jones said. “And the power of representation in particular is something I could have benefited from directly growing up.”

In another New York district, Afro-Latino state legislator Ritchie Torres also led a crowded primary field to fill the seat of retiring 15-term representative José Serrano, a Democrat.

Mr Torres, who was 2 years old when Mr Serrano first won his congressional seat, was the first openly gay elected official in the Bronx when he won a City Council seat. His father is from Puerto Rico and his mother is black.

In a Long Island district, where Republican representative Peter King is retiring, Jamaica-born Iraq and Afghanistan war veteran Jackie Gordon held a commanding primary lead, unlikely to be reversed by absentee ballots.

Mr Bowman, Mr Jones, and Mr Torres all gained ground after the killing of Floyd sparked protests and calls for police restructuring across the country. That energy also reshaped 14-term representative Carolyn B Maloney’s re-election bid, which was far too close to call on Tuesday night.

After nearly 40,000 votes were counted, Ms Maloney had just 42 per cent of the vote against three challengers; Suraj Patel, who had lost to her handily in 2018, trailed by a few hundred votes, with thousands of absentee ballots left to count.

While Ms Maloney holds the gavel of the powerful House Committee on Oversight and Reform, clout she did not have in 2018, Mr Patel honed a pitch of generational change. The combination of the coronavirus and the mass protests gave him an opening to criticise Ms Maloney’s past scepticism of mandatory vaccination, and her vote for the 1994 crime bill.

“It’s a change election, much more so than two years ago,” the 36-year-old Mr Patel said in an interview. “The generational piece of this race is so much more persuasive to a lot of people because the systems all around us are broken. It’s not abstract anymore when 60 per cent of coronavirus deaths in New York are in public housing.”

Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, who is endorsing some of the newcomers, campaigns in the Bronx borough of New York City on Tuesday
Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, who is endorsing some of the newcomers, campaigns in the Bronx borough of New York City on Tuesday (Getty)

The results in New York came after years of recruiting and investment by the city’s left-wing activists, supercharged by the 2018 victory of representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, D-N.Y. The 30-year old congresswoman easily defeated a former CNBC anchor while endorsing Mr Bowman and Mr Jones.

She did not support Mr Torres, but the shock of Ms Ocasio-Cortez’s first win had helped groups such as Justice Democrats and the Working Families Party recruit more candidates and earn more media attention, crucial to winning races where the novel coronavirus had put a halt to traditional campaigning.

“It’s like BC and AD – before AOC and after AOC,” Mr Torres said. “In the post-AOC world, incumbency is no longer an entitlement, no longer a guarantee of elected office.”

Ms Pelosi has, so far, threaded the needle between the competing wings of her caucus, from the 30 Democrats sitting in districts Mr Trump won four years ago to more liberal members of the Congressional Progressive Caucus.

Now, these newcomers might link arms with Ms Ocasio-Cortez, who upset Joseph Crowley, a lieutenant in Ms Pelosi’s leadership team at the time, to try to more aggressively push the caucus to the left on some issues.

Ms Ocasio-Cortez has at times fought lonely battles over legislation, sometimes with only a few allies from her self-declared “squad” of four young female Democrats, and sometimes she’s the lone voice of opposition, as she was on the more than $2tn (£1.6tn) Cares Act in late March.

In those moments, leaders of the Progressive Caucus, after pushing Ms Pelosi as far as they thought they could go, mostly fell in line behind the speaker’s legislative tactics. If the rising star from the Bronx can coax these potential allies to join her cause, they could become a bigger thorn in Ms Pelosi’s side next year.

None of the Democrats defeated or replaced in New York were as conservative as representative Daniel Lipinski of Illinois, an antiabortion Democrat ousted by a primary challenge three months ago. But all of the challengers promised a shift to the left, and all linked themselves to protest movements that some Democrats had viewed warily.

“The power of social movements is essential, but insufficient, to secure victories that these cries from the street demand,” said Maurice Mitchell, the national director of the Working Families Party. “You need the power to govern, and you need to ensure that that power is accountable to social movements.”

As they voted on Tuesday, black voters who supported Kentucky’s Mr Booker said they were confident that he could run competitively against Senate majority leader Mitch McConnell, R-Ky.

Danyle Washington cast ballots for “BB” – Mr Booker and Joe Biden, the presumptive Democratic presidential nominee – and said the state legislator would be a stronger candidate in November.

“He’s not changing minds of people who are racist,” Mr Washington said. “I think he’s changing minds of people who are open.”

Athey Ajak, a 20-year-old college student, said he saw a strong connection between Mr Booker’s candidacy and the protests that had transformed the country’s debate over-policing and racial justice.

“All of this protesting,” he said, “means nothing if you don’t vote.”

The Washington Post

Join our commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies


Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in