Hong Kong protester shot by police during Facebook live stream as demonstrators block major roads

In third incident of police using live rounds on protesters, video shows officer opening fire at abdomen of black-clad demonstrator

Adam Withnall
Asia Editor
Monday 11 November 2019 06:38
Hong Kong police shoot man in day of violence

A Hong Kong protester has been shot by a police live round, with the incident streamed live on Facebook, as demonstrators disrupted the Monday morning commute leading to chaotic scenes across the city.

Video of the incident showed a police officer grappling with a protester dressed in white at a zebra crossing. As other protesters approach, the officer pulls out his service-issue revolver and fires at the abdomen of a man dressed in black.

Elsewhere in the city, a man was set on fire as two groups appeared to argue over national identity, and there have been widespread reports of teargas firing across Hong Kong – unusual scenes during daylight hours in the working week.

At a hastily called news conference, the city’s chief executive Carrie Lam described both the police shooting and the incident with the man on fire as “very worrying”. The latter, which appeared to involve a masked protester throwing flammable liquid on an older man who had said the demonstrators were “not Chinese”, she called an “inhumane act”.

Ms Lam described the protesters as “enemies of the people”, saying they “will never win” – comments which may signal a hardening stance from the government.

Asked about the police shooting, she rejected calls to set up an independent inquiry into allegations of excessive force, saying that this would mean giving in to one of the protest movement’s demands.

“If there’s still any wishful thinking that by escalating violence the Hong Kong government will yield to pressure to satisfy the so-called political demands, I’m making this statement clear and loud here: that will not happen,” Ms Lam said.

“Violence is not going to give us any solution to the problems that Hong Kong is facing. Our joint priority now, as a city, is to end the violence and to return Hong Kong to normal as soon as possible.”

Video of the Sai Wan Ho district shooting show the police officer firing multiple rounds before he and a colleague pinned down two protesters, including the one who was wounded.

Police said only one of the protesters was hit, and that he was undergoing surgery. Later in the day hospital sources were quoted as saying he was resting and not at “immediate risk of death”, having previously been described as “critical”.

According to the South China Morning Post, police told reporters at a briefing that the protesters were trying to take the officer’s gun, so he attempted to fire warning shots but inadvertently hit one of the protesters.

But Amnesty International issued a statement calling the shooting a “shocking low for the Hong Kong police” and “clear evidence of a reckless use of force”.

They cited another incident on Monday in which a police officer had been filmed apparently driving his motorbike at high speed into a group of protesters. Police said the officer had been immediately suspended pending an investigation of the “very serious” case.

“These are not policing measures – these are officers out of control with a mindset of retaliation,” said Man-Kei Tam, director of Amnesty International Hong Kong.

“This pervasive, heavy-handed behaviour shows the police cannot investigate themselves. Today’s actions again require an urgent independent investigation. The authorities must review their approach to help de-escalate the situation and prevent more lives being put at risk.”

It is the third time a protester has been shot by the police since the demonstrations began in June with anger at an unpopular extradition bill and the perceived encroachment of Hong Kong’s freedoms by Beijing.

Each incident has sparked outrage and allegations of excessive use of force, first on 1 October when an 18-year-old student was shot in the chest in an incident that was also caught on video, and then when a 14-year-old boy was shot in the leg on 4 October.

A video grab shows the moment a police officer shoots a black-clad pro-democracy protester in the abdomen during a protest in Sai Wan Ho district, in Hong Kong, on Monday morning (Cupid News/AFP/Getty)

Tensions are already enflamed after a weekend in which six pro-democracy politicians were arrested on charges of obstructing the local assembly, relating to a raucous 11 May meeting over the extradition bill.

All were freed on bail, but the decision to arrest them now was seen as a sign of patience wearing thin among Ms Lam and her Beijing-backed devolved administration.

On Friday, the city saw its first confirmed death directly related to the at-times violent street demonstrations, as a protester who fell during clashes with police last Monday finally succumbed to his injuries in hospital.

The morning protests this Monday saw thousands attempt to block major roads and MTR metro routes, at times throwing heavy objects onto the streets below.

The rail operator was forced to suspend several lines, and public broadcaster RTHK reported that a fire had been started inside a train at Kwai Fong station.

The number of high-profile violent incidents has increased as Hong Kong prepares to conduct district elections on 24 November, with pro-Beijing parties expected to take a hit at the ballot box.

Opposition MPs have accused the government of deliberately trying to provoke violence in order to justify cancelling or postponing the elections.

In a news release regarding the Sai Wan Ho district shooting incident, the Hong Kong government said police had been responding to vandalism and disruptions to traffic.

“During police operations, one police officer has discharged his service revolver, one male was shot,” the release said, adding that officers also drew their guns in the Shatin and Tung Chung neighbourhoods.

The release denied what it called online rumours saying police had been ordered to “recklessly use their firearms”, calling the allegation “totally false and malicious”. “All police officers are required to justify their enforcement actions,” the statement said.

Register for free to continue reading

Registration is a free and easy way to support our truly independent journalism

By registering, you will also enjoy limited access to Premium articles, exclusive newsletters, commenting, and virtual events with our leading journalists

Already have an account? sign in

By clicking ‘Register’ you confirm that your data has been entered correctly and you have read and agree to our Terms of use, Cookie policy and Privacy notice.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy policy and Terms of service apply.

Join our new commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies


Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in