Nepalese woman dies in ‘menstruation hut’ fire after being banished during period

Death come weeks after mother and two children die in similar circumstances following 'chhaupadi' tradition

Bhadra Sharma,Kai Schultz
Sunday 03 February 2019 16:09 GMT
Woman in Nepal who observe the chhaupadi taboo are banished to mud or stone huts, some of them no bigger than closets
Woman in Nepal who observe the chhaupadi taboo are banished to mud or stone huts, some of them no bigger than closets

A Nepalese woman has died of suspected suffocation from smoke inhalation while banished to an abandoned hut during her period, police said.

Her death comes just weeks after the death of a mother and two children in similar circumstances sparked outrage.

Parbati Bogati, 21, sequestered herself in the abandoned house on Wednesday evening, in keeping with a centuries-old taboo that declares menstruating women impure.

As the temperature dropped below freezing, she tried to keep warm by apparently burning wood and clothing. By the next morning, her legs were charred and she was dead.

“It seems she also died from suffocation,” said Lal Bahadur Dhami, deputy superintendent of the area’s police. At least three other people died this year while following the same superstition.

The taboo, which has its roots in Hinduism, is called chhaupadi, from the Nepali words meaning someone who bears an impurity.

During women’s periods, it bars them from touching neighbours’ food or entering temples. They cannot use communal water sources or kitchen utensils. It is considered bad luck to touch them.

Instead, women who observe the taboo are banished to mud or stone huts, some of them no bigger than closets. Each year, at least a couple of women die in these huts from exposure, animal bites or smoke inhalation after building fires to stay warm during the Himalayan winter.

Many women who follow chhaupadi say they do so out of social pressure or guilt. Reports of sexual assault from men who prey on them while they are alone are also common.

A 2010 Nepali government survey, which was cited in a State Department human rights report, found that 19 per cent of women ages 15 to 49 in the country followed chhaupadi.

But in Nepal’s midwestern and far western regions, some of the poorest pockets of Asia, the proportion climbed to 50 per cent.

Women’s rights activists have desperately tried to end chhaupadi. Nepal’s Supreme Court banned the practice in 2005. In August, the government went a step further and criminalised it. Anyone who forces menstruating women into huts faces up to three months in jail.

But the law has barely rippled through many villages in western Nepal, and activists say the police are not enforcing it.

In January, Amba Bohara, 35, and two of her sons – aged seven and nine – apparently suffocated in a menstruation hut after lighting a fire to stay warm. Nobody has been arrested in their deaths.

Officials said no men forced Ms Bogati to follow chhaupadi in her village of Purbichauki, a small outpost in western Nepal. Ms Bogati’s father-in-law was dead.

Her husband, Shankar, was in Malaysia for a job. She stayed more or less on her own, which complicated the task of filing charges, the police said.

“She was alone in her house,” Ms Dhami said. “Tell us, who should be held responsible for this crime?”

Mr Dhami said the local government had organized more than 50 programs educating people from Bogati’s district about the dangers of chhaupadi and its illegality. A few days before her death, Ms Bogati had attended one of these programmes, according to a distant relative, Dirgha Raj Bogati.

That did not stop her from following chhaupadi. One villager, Chandra Bogati, blamed M Bogati for her death.

“She would be alive if she had not gone to the abandoned house to follow chhaupadi and burned the fire,” he said.

Support free-thinking journalism and attend Independent events

Activists said they planned to demolish many menstruation huts starting in March. But Amrita Thapa, a lawmaker based in Kathmandu, Nepal’s capital, said it was hard to imagine the situation improving anytime soon.

On a recent visit to the village where Bohara and her two children died in January, she found shocking levels of resistance.

“I realised that changing people’s mindsets and ending chhaupadi was more difficult than hardships we endured while fighting in the war,” she said, referring to a conflict with a Maoist insurgency in Nepal in which thousands of people died.

New York Times

Join our commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies


Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in