North Korea's nuclear test site has collapsed, say geologists

Findings raise questions about recent announcement Pyongyang will halt testing programme

Samuel Osborne
Thursday 26 April 2018 15:04 BST
North Korea 'suspends' missile and nuclear tests

North Korea’s main nuclear test site has collapsed following its latest bomb test and could be at risk of leaking radiation, research by Chinese geologists has shown.

As a result, the Punggye-ri site under Mount Mantap has been rendered unsafe for further testing and should be monitored, scientists from the University of Science and Technology of China have said.

Their findings raise questions about Kim Jong-un’s announcement his country was ceasing its testing programme ahead of planned meetings with the US president, Donald Trump, and his South Korean counterpart, Moon Jae-in.

Data was collected following the detonation of the most powerful of North Korea’s six nuclear bomb tests on 3 September, thought to have triggered four earthquakes.

At the time, Japanese media said the detonation caused one of the tunnels to collapse, potentially killing 200 construction workers.

The yield of the bomb was estimated at more than 100 kilotons of TNT, at least 10 times stronger than anything Pyongyang had tested previously.

The Chinese paper, authored by Tian Dongdong, Yao Jiawen and Wen Lianxing, said the first of those earthquakes, which occurred eight-and-a-half minutes after the explosion, was “an onsite collapse toward the nuclear test centre,” while the subsequent quakes were an “earthquake swarm” in similar locations.

“In view of the research finding that the North Korea nuclear test site at Mantapsan has collapsed, it is necessary to continue to monitor any leakage of radioactive materials that may have been caused by the collapse,” the authors said.

Seismic waves from North Korea’s latest bomb test which were caused by ‘artificial earthquakes’ near the Punggye-ri nuclear test site

Another similar test “would produce collapses in an even larger scale, creating an environmental catastrophe,” the study said.

The peer-reviewed study has been accepted for publication by the Geophysical Research Letters journal.

A study published last month by the journal, authored by a team led by Liu Junqing at the earthquake bureau in Jilin province along the border with North Korea, found similar results of the 3 September test.

It described the aftershock which followed seconds later as most likely the “rapid destruction of an explosion-generated cracked rock chimney due to cavity collapse.”

North Korea’s nuclear tests have caused seismic events in Chinese border towns and cities, forcing the evacuations of schools and offices, sparking fears of wind-born radiation and leading to a backlash among some Chinese against their country’s unpredictable traditional ally.

Chinese authorities have said they have not detected any radiation risk from samples collected along the border.

North Korea’s leader, Kim Jong-un, inspects the country’s most powerful hydrogen bomb

Pyongyang said the promise to shut down the Punggye-ri site was to “transparently guarantee” its dramatic commitment to stop all nuclear and missile tests.

But experts have now warned that damage to the complex could be the reason North Korea is willing to dismantle the site.

“They’re not giving up anything,” Robert Kelley, a former inspector for the Vienna-based International Atomic Energy Agency, told Reuters. “That complex, I would guess, has been damaged beyond reuse.”

But 38 North, a website run by the Johns Hopkins School of Advanced International Studies, said satellite imagery showed tunnelling was conducted this year, suggesting the site was still operational, although recent activity had slowed considerably.

“There is no basis to conclude that the Punggye-ri nuclear test site is no longer viable for future nuclear testing,” it reported on Monday.

It comes ahead of a meeting between Kim Jong-un and Moon Jae-in, which will see Mr Kim become the first North Korean leader to cross the highly militarised border since the end of the 1950-1953 Korean War.

Additional reporting by agencies

Join our commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies


Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in