Chinese musician who sang about Tiananmen Square disappears ahead of 30th anniversary

'Under President Xi Jinping no stone will be left unturned'

Yanan Wang
Sunday 02 June 2019 17:16 BST
Popular rock musician Li Zhi, who sang about taboo Tiananmen Square massacre, goes missing ahead of anniversary
Popular rock musician Li Zhi, who sang about taboo Tiananmen Square massacre, goes missing ahead of anniversary

It has been three months since Chinese rock musician Li Zhi disappeared from public view.

First, an upcoming tour was cancelled and his social media accounts were taken down. Then his music was removed from all of China’s major streaming sites — as if his career had never existed at all.

Mr Li is an outspoken artist who performs folk rock. He sang pensive ballads about social ills, and unlike most entertainers in China, dared to broach the taboo subject of the Tiananmen Square pro-democracy protests that ended in bloodshed on 4 June 1989.

“Now this square is my grave,” Mr Li sang. “Everything is just a dream.”

China’s ruling Communist Party has pushed people like Mr Li into the shadows as it braces for this week's 30th anniversary of the military crackdown. Hundreds, if not thousands, are estimated to have died on the night of 3 June and in the early hours of 4 June.

The party’s effort to scrub any mention of the movement has been consistent through the decades since then and ramps up before major anniversaries every five years. This year, the trade war with the US has added to government skittishness about instability.

“They are certainly nervous,” said Jean-Pierre Cabestan, a political science professor at Hong Kong Baptist University. “Under (President) Xi Jinping, no stone will be left unturned.”

Many of the actions appear aimed at eliminating any risk of individuals speaking out, however small their platforms. Bilibili, a Chinese video streaming site, announced last week that its popular real-time comments feature will be disabled until 6 June for “system upgrades”.

Chinese Human Rights Defenders, an advocacy group, said 13 people have either been detained or taken away from their homes in connection with the anniversary.

Among them are several artists who recently embarked on a “national conscience exhibit tour” and a filmmaker who was detained after tweeting images of a liquor bottle commemorating 4 June.

The bottle’s label featured a play on words using “baijiu”, China’s signature grain alcohol, and the Chinese words for 89, or “bajiu.” A court convicted four people involved in designing the bottle in April.

Foreign companies are not immune.

Apple Music has removed from its Chinese streaming service a song by Hong Kong singer Jackie Cheung that references the Tiananmen crackdown.

Tat Ming Pair, a Hong Kong duo, have been deleted entirely from the app. They released a song this month called “Remembering is a Crime” in memory of the protests.

Wikipedia also announced this month that the online encyclopedia is no longer accessible in China. While the Chinese-language version has been blocked since 2015, most other languages could previously be viewed, Wikipedia said.

The disappearance of Mr Li, the musician, has left fans searching for answers.

On 20 February, the official Weibo social media account for the 40-year-old’s concert tour posted a photograph of its team in front of a truck about to embark on scheduled performances in Sichuan province in China’s southwest.

The Tiananmen square protest

Just two days later, however, the account posted an image of a hand wearing what appeared to be a hospital wrist band and the words: “Very sorry.”

The next post, published the same day, announced without explanation that the tour was cancelled and that ticket purchasers would shortly receive a refund. Fans flooded the comment section with wishes for a speedy recovery.

But the suggestion that a health issue was behind the cancellations was later thrown into doubt.

A statement published in April by Sichuan’s culture department said it had “urgently halted” concert plans for a “well-known singer with improper conduct” who was previously slated for 23 performances — the same number of concerts which Li had scheduled in the province. It said 18,000 tickets were fully refunded.

Authorities in China regularly use “improper conduct” to describe political transgressions.

Around the same time, Mr Li’s presence on the Chinese internet was completely erased.

A central government directive on 21 April ordered all websites to delete any audio or video content relating to five of Mr Li’s songs, according to China Digital Times, an organisation that publishes leaked censorship instructions.

The Associated Press could not independently verify the authenticity of the directive.

“There’s pretty much a consensus” among those working in the industry that Mr Li’s disappearance from public view is due to the sensitive anniversary, said a music industry professional who spoke on condition of anonymity because of fear of government retribution.

“He did a number of songs that were considered politically risky, making references to 4 June 1989, and so he’s been out of the picture,” the industry professional said.

The AP could not confirm Mr Li’s current whereabouts. His company and record label did not respond to repeated interview requests.

Li’s songs alluding to the Tiananmen Square protests — “The Square”, “The Spring of 1990” and “The Goddess”, in honour of the Goddess of Democracy that students erected — were part of his earlier works.

In recent years, the bespectacled singer has avoided making public political statements, focusing more on promoting his performances.

In 2015, the state-run China Daily newspaper published a profile of Mr Li, describing him as a performer who easily sells out concerts. After years of working as an independent artist, he signed last autumn with Taihe Music Group, a major Chinese record label.

Fans who knew Mr Li as a largely apolitical entertainer expressed bewilderment online about his disappearance. Others made veiled references to China’s internet censorship.

On Zhihu, a question-and-answer website similar to Quora, one user wrote that people posed questions every day about what might have happened to Mr Li, but these posts always disappeared the next morning “as if nothing had happened at all”.

Another user said: “I don’t dare to say it, nor do I dare to ask.”

A fan who has been sharing Mr Li’s music on his personal account spoke to the AP on condition of anonymity because he feared his employers would punish him for discussing the subject.

“Everyone knows the reason for Li Zhi’s disappearance,” the fan said. “But I’m sorry, I can’t tell you, because I follow China’s laws and also hope that Li Zhi can return.”

Quoting one of Mr Li’s lyrics, the fan added: “The world will be all right.”

Fans continue to circulate videos of Mr Li’s performances online. His complete discography has been uploaded onto file-sharing websites, with back-up links in case the original ones are shuttered. Some users shared tribute art, including a black T-shirt with the words “improper conduct”.

A few years ago, in a performance in Taiwan, Mr Li bounced around on stage, strumming his guitar and repeating a chorus in apparent tribute to the spirit of Chinese propaganda.

“The people don’t need freedom,” he sang energetically.

“This is the best era!” the crowd roared back. "The people don’t need freedom. This is the best era!”

Associated Press

Join our commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies


Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in