Community outrage as rural Brazilian schools go vegan

It is a surprising paradox of life here: Brazil, the world’s number one exporter of beef – a country where cows outnumber people, and a party isn’t a party without a barbecue – also has one of the highest rates of vegetarianism, writes Terrence McCoy

Saturday 23 November 2019 13:36
Elione Mascarenhas dos Santos hands out the vegan equivalent of sloppy joes to children in the rural Brazilian town of Teofilandia
Elione Mascarenhas dos Santos hands out the vegan equivalent of sloppy joes to children in the rural Brazilian town of Teofilandia

Squeezed into plastic chairs, hand fans going full tilt, hundreds of parents listen in the summer heat. The planet is in big trouble, they are told, and the time has come for their community in rural Brazil to do something about it.

The messenger isn’t one of their own. She speaks with the hard Rs of the wealthier southeast, not the lilting cadence of Bahia, one of the poorest states in Brazil. But what Leticia Baird has to tell the parents is even more striking: here in meat-producing, meat-eating, meat-loving Brazil, the schools are going vegan.

Baird, a prosecutor in the Bahia state public ministry, has convinced four municipalities anchoring this dusty landscape of cactuses and farmland to swap out animal protein for plant protein at all public schools. By the end of 2019, only plant-based meals will be served to the area’s more than 33,000 students. “To preserve the environment for the present and for future generations, we need to take additional measures,” she declares. “Including changing our own habits.”

It’s a surprising paradox of life here: Brazil, the world’s number one exporter of beef – a country where cows outnumber people, and a party isn’t a party without a barbecue – also has one of the highest rates of vegetarianism.

In the past decade, amid mounting awareness of the repercussions of humanity’s meat addiction – from growing rates of obesity to the deforestation of the Amazon – the number of Brazilians who consider themselves vegetarian has nearly doubled, from 8 per cent of the population to 14 per cent in 2018, according to surveys. By some measures, only India, with its cultural and religious traditions of vegetarianism, has a higher rate.

The carnivores and the herbivores mostly coexist harmoniously, if discordantly. Near the churrascaria sits the vegan sushi shop. In Rio de Janeiro, Burger King rents billboards to tout its newest offering: a plant-based patty with the “flavour and texture of meat”.

But the meeting of meat and health food, conservative tradition and liberal environmentalism plays out differently here in the northeastern state of Bahia, where people eat meat because that’s what people have always eaten. There are threats. Furious parents. A battle over science. Eventually, the federal government gets involved.

But before all of that, there was Baird, trying to establish the consequences of inaction before hundreds of parents. The health of their children is on the line. The planet is facing an ecological crisis. “How are we going to resolve this?” she asks.

An exotic food is set out on a table: organic peanut butter. Parents inspect it with suspicion.

* * *

There’s a question that Baird won’t stop asking. “Why not? Why not try?” she asks. “The forest is burning, and the water is harder to get to, and the public health – these are very big things. So why not?” Driving to a nut-butter producer offering an alternative protein source for schools, she shakes her head.

In a rural environment, she asks, with little money and even less water, why not remove meat, a product that required a lot of both? In a region where kids suffer from high rates of obesity, why not help them become a bit healthier? Why not save the community some money in medical costs?

She stares out of the window at the desolate expanse of endless brown and tan. She is from Mato Grosso do Sul in southern Brazil, which unfurls like a green blanket, but this is home now. After moving to Bahia in 2011, she met her husband, took a prosecutor job monitoring community health and discovered what she believes is the key to sustainable living.

The forest is burning, and the water is harder to get to, and the public health – these are very big things. So why not?

Leticia Baird, teacher

She’d always eaten like a southern Brazilian – lots of breads, meats and cakes. But after coming to Bahia, where the culture was defined by descendants of West African slaves, she found a completely different cuisine, one based on roots such as yuca and yam. All the nutrients she’d ever need were right there, from vegetables – and she wanted to share the news with others. “I’m now trying to cut out gluten, too,” she says.

While she navigated a personal journey to a healthier lifestyle, Brazil was in the midst of its own. By 2015 – even as obesity and diabetes surged – it had become the fifth largest market for healthy food in the world. Surveys showed three in four people not only wanted to reduce their animal-product consumption – they admired those who did. That set Brazil apart from most western countries, where, among groups that face prejudice, only drug addicts are liked less than vegans and vegetarians, according to at least one study.

“At first I couldn’t believe [the numbers] because there wasn’t any public policy promoting vegans,” says Monica Buava, a campaign manager at the Brazilian Vegetarian Society. “But this isn’t some fad. It’s happening.”

It’s happening in the business community: “There is still unmet demand,” the Good Food Institute reported recently. It’s happening in the country’s urban enclaves: “There is a growing perception,” says Semiramis Domene, a professor of public policy and health at the Federal University of Sao Paulo, “that food choices are a political act – as in, ‘I can influence food product chains.’”

Soy-based sloppy joes are now on the menu

And it is happening in the rural northeast, where Baird is puttering down dusty roads outside Serrinha, closing in on the home-run operation of an organic peanut butter producer. “Why not?” she repeats.

* * *

Ariane Souza Santiago Silva can think of a few reasons why not. An intense 32-year-old woman, she directs the Serrinha chapter of the Council of School Food, and from the start, Baird’s sustainable eating programme has irritated her. To Santiago, it hasn’t been a choice, but “an imposition”.

There had been no public debate. No vote. Just an announcement: The old school menu – with its pasta and meats and margarine – would be replaced with one that features oatmeal, vegan bread and meat-free kibbe.

It isn’t that Santiago doesn’t want kids to eat healthier, or to save public money. It is a question of identity. What Serrinha is and what it is not. And this food, with its exotic ingredients and protein alternatives, isn’t Serrinha. “It’s a culture here,” Santiago says. “And this shows a lack of respect for our culture. [Baird] isn’t of Bahia. She’s not of the northeast.”

It’s a culture here. And this shows a lack of respect for our culture. [Baird] isn’t of Bahia. She’s not of the northeast

Ariane Souza Santiago Silva

Santiago started to investigate. As vegan food overtook the schools – first one, then two, then three days a week – she and four other women fanned out across the region. They visited 48 schools and day-care centres, she says, snapping photographs and interviewing 55 students, 25 parents and numerous lunchroom cooks.

They found school cooks churning out meals that were barely edible. Trash bins filled with uneaten vegan food. Kids refusing to eat and going home hungry. Students bringing meat from their own kitchens. The menus being unilaterally altered back to traditional food.

“It’s an absurdity!” says Jucineide Santos, 42, a chicken and sheep farmer. She says her 12-year-old daughter often returns home from school hungry, having refused to eat. “Most of the products are peanuts! They make milk with peanuts. What is that?”

Food wasted, kids hungry: an attempt to save public resources, Santiago says, seems only to be wasting more of them. She typed out a report declaring that the new food hadn’t been “accepted by the school community”. By then, she’d alerted the local Regional Council of Nutritionists in the state capital of Salvador, which also came down hard on the programme. “Risky,” it called the initiative. “Not compatible with the regional reality.”

The Federal Council of Nutritionists took it even further: “It could compromise the development of schoolchildren.”

Baird produced a lengthy rebuttal to the criticisms, enumerating the benefits of a vegan diet, listing the dozens of studies that she believes would prove her points. But it was too late. The National Fund for Educational Development, the agency that oversees school meals, was threatening to suspend funding if local mayors removed animal products every day of the week.

The battle of vegan food has reached a stalemate. Was it too much, too soon? Was it the flavour of the food?

Baird drove deep in the countryside one recent day to inspect the quality of the vegan meals at a rural school. Until recently, the cafeteria had been serving vegan food three days a week. But it scaled back to two days after the federal threat. On the menu were oranges and soy-based sloppy joes, and students were lining up to get their share. The kids tore into the food, eating all of the sandwiches, laughing and joking. It wasn’t the hellish experience that the programme’s critics described.

But it still isn’t ideal, some young food critics say. “It doesn’t have much flavour, soy,” says one student, Alan Delon. “It’s good,” insists Leticia Silva Santos, a schoolmate. “It’s healthy, and I eat everything. It’s better for nature, too.”

Baird walks past the throng of students eating, proud of what she sees. The teachers tell her they are on her side. So are the school’s administrators. And the mayors. Even the students seem to be coming around.

People here – they want kids to be healthy. They want to do what they can to save nature. She just knew it. Even if the rollout has been delayed, vegan food is the way forward. By the end of next year, she vows, the students will be eating vegan food four out of five school days. She hopes that will keep the feds happy. It isn’t over yet. “A good fight is a good one,” she says.

© Washington Post

Support free-thinking journalism and attend Independent events

Register for free to continue reading

Registration is a free and easy way to support our truly independent journalism

By registering, you will also enjoy limited access to Premium articles, exclusive newsletters, commenting, and virtual events with our leading journalists

Already have an account? sign in

By clicking ‘Register’ you confirm that your data has been entered correctly and you have read and agree to our Terms of use, Cookie policy and Privacy notice.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy policy and Terms of service apply.

Join our new commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies


Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in