Melting Arctic ice caps bolstering China’s military, warns UK navy chief

Russia also likely to exploit the environmental crisis, says admiral 

Kim Sengupta
Defence Editor
Thursday 08 October 2020 22:07 BST
Ship navigates through melting ice in the Arctic
Ship navigates through melting ice in the Arctic

The melting Arctic ice cap is opening up a new passage into the Atlantic for the expanding Chinese Navy in a potential new challenge to the UK and the west, the chief of the Royal Navy has warned. 

Russia is also likely to assert itself even more in that part of the Atlantic, a strategic area for Europe and the US, said Tony Radakin, the First Sea Lord.

Climate change is a concern for us all but it is opening up maritime trade routes across the top of the world, halving the transit time between Europe and Asia. And we sit on the gateway to these routes”, he said. 

Speaking aboard the new aircraft carrier HMS Prince of Wales, in Portsmouth, he stated: “When China sails its growing navy into the Atlantic, which way will it come – the long route or the short route. And these routes skirt the coast of that resurgent Russia. A Russia that is now more active in the Atlantic – our back yard – than it has ever done for over 30 years.” 

Admiral Radakin continued: “As the ‘High North’ becomes more open and accessible it’s going to be more contested and competitive as well. We are already doing much more in the High North, we’ve been operating with our Norwegian friends, with our American friends and in the Barents Sea. 

“That’s one of a series of operations. We will be looking in the ‘High North” to join with our partners. Our taking stock will involve looking at the capabilities, it will also involve us working and looking at what do our partners offer us - the Norwegians, the Americans, the Canadians, other nations across the world who have got that specific interest in the High North.” 

The Northern Sea Route is currently navigable between August and October, but that window is expected to expand steadily. The Bureau for Economic Policy Analysis in the Netherlands envisaged that it might be ice free by 2030, while the Copenhagen Business School projected 2040 as the time when large-scale shipping would become viable. Beijing has applied to join the Arctic Council. It is an organisation set up by countries bordering the region but China has designated itself a “near-Arctic” state and, having lobbied hard for membership, has managed to obtain observer status. 

China’s official policy has been that its activities in the Arctic are concentrated on scientific exploration, trade and development. But its research stations in the region now include satellite systems capable of tracking missiles and intercepting military communications. 

Russia’s nuclear-powered icebreaker Arktika, designed to transport liquefied natural gas from the Arctic

The Danish Defence Intelligence Service pointed out last year that the Chinese Army, which has been increasingly using scientific research to establish a presence, has acknowledged that some activities serve a “dual purpose”. A US Department of Defence report to Congress earlier this year claimed “China could use its civilian research presence in the Arctic to strengthen its military presence, including by deploying submarines to the region as a deterrent against attacks”. 

Admiral James Stavridis, a former head of Nato military, has pointed out that “the Chinese are building nuclear-powered icebreakers, something the US has not even contemplated. At more than 30,000 tons, the Chinese ships will outpace any other nation’s capability with the exception of Russia and will join a fleet of six conventionally powered ships”. 

While Adm Radakin warned of the Chinese military’s incursion in the High North, there has been increasing tension on the other side of the world, in the Indo-Pacific region, with Beijing claiming ownership of 90 per cent of the South China Sea – a claim strongly rejected by neighbouring states and the west. Two US carrier groups, led by USS Ronald Reagan and USS Nimitz, carried out exercises in the South China Sea last July with Beijing accusing Washington of “provocation”. 

Earlier this week the "Quadrilateral" group of states – US, Japan, Australia and India – met in Tokyo and stressed the need to uphold freedom of navigation in  the disputed waters. Last November Adm Radakin signed the Trilateral Agreement with US Navy Adm Mike Gilday and Adm Hiroshi Yamamura of the Japan Maritime Self-Defence Force, on cooperation on a range of issues in the Indo-Pacific, including access to waterways under international law. 

That meeting was aboard Britain’s second new aircraft carrier HMS Queen Elizabeth which is due to embark on its first mission in May. “HMS Queen Elizabeth will sail from this dockyard, at the heart of a multinational Carrier Strike Task Group, with 40 aircraft. The floating embodiment of Global Britain,” said Adm Radakin on board the Prince of Wales

The government has refused to say where the Queen Elizabeth is heading, but there is widespread expectation that it will be to Indo-Pacific. Senior Chinese officials have warned that sending British and the US warships into disputed waters would be considered “hostile action” with serious consequences, and urged that London not get sucked into carrying out “dirty jobs” for Washington. All the indications are that the already fraught relations between China and Britain and the west are likely to get even more tense as a military dimension is added from the High North to the South China Sea.  

Join our commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies


Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in