War crimes investigation into US forces in Afghanistan can go ahead, ICC rules

Judges overturn decision made last year 

Rory Sullivan
Thursday 05 March 2020 11:06 GMT
US soldiers in Afghanistan in 2019: the ICC’s decision comes just days after a peace deal was signed by Washington and the Taliban
US soldiers in Afghanistan in 2019: the ICC’s decision comes just days after a peace deal was signed by Washington and the Taliban

An investigation into alleged war crimes by the US and others in the Afghanistan war can go ahead, the International Criminal Court has ruled.

The US invaded Afghanistan in 2001 in order to dismantle al-Qaeda and deny it a safe base by removing the Taliban from power. About 13,000 US troops are still based in the country.

The global court upheld an appeal by prosecutors on Thursday, meaning that the investigation into alleged war crimes by the US military, the Taliban and Afghan forces has now been authorised.

This follows the rejection of a request by prosecutor Fatou Bensouda in April last year to open an inquiry, despite pretrial judges acknowledging that widespread crimes had taken place.

Both Afghanistan, which is an ICC member country, and the US, which does not recognise the court, have strongly objected to the investigation.

As such, it remains unclear whether any suspects who are later charged will appear at the court in The Hague.

The presiding judge, Piotr Hofmanski, said: “The Appeals Chamber considers it appropriate to amend the appealed decision to the effect that the prosecutor is authorised to commence an investigation into alleged crimes committed on the territory of Afghanistan since 1 May 2003, as well as other alleged crimes that have a nexus to the armed conflict in Afghanistan.”

Ms Bensouda, a Gambian lawyer, asked judges to allow a far-reaching investigation in November 2017, following a preliminary probe into the conflict in Afghanistan.

She said there is information showing that members of the US military and intelligence agencies “committed acts of torture, cruel treatment, outrages upon personal dignity, rape and sexual violence” against detainees in Afghanistan and other locations, largely between 2003 and 2004.

The prosecutor also said that other crimes had been committed by the Taliban and other insurgent groups, including the killing of 17,000 Afghan civilians since 2009 – of which 7,000 were targeted killings.

She added that Afghan security forces are thought to have tortured prisoners at government detention centres.

In a hearing in December last year, the Afghan government said it was opposed to the investigation and that it had set up its own probe.

As the ICC is the court of last resort, it only brings cases if national jurisdictions are either unable or unwilling to bring a genuine prosecution.

The US has also spoken out against the investigation. Jay Sekulow, a lawyer for Donald Trump, appearing on behalf of the American Centre for Law and Justice, told appeals judges in December that the US would not change its position.

Mr Sekulow said: ”It is not in the interests of justice to waste the court’s resources while ignoring the reality of principled non-cooperation.”

Commenting on Thursday’s ruling, Preetha Gopalan, deputy head of UK litigation at the legal charity Reprieve, told The Independent: “This decision is welcome news to everyone who believes that the perpetrators of war crimes should not enjoy impunity, no matter how powerful they are.”

The ICC’s decision comes just days after a peace deal was signed by the US and the Taliban.

On Wednesday, the US carried out its first air raid against the Taliban since signing the deal on Saturday in Doha, Qatar.

Additional reporting from AP

Join our commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies


Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in