Stay up to date with notifications from The Independent

Notifications can be managed in browser preferences.

Residents of French town where cancer rate is nearly double the average file criminal complaint against polluting companies

Groundbreaking action takes fight to one of Europe's most toxic industrial regions

Adam Nossiter
Thursday 02 April 2020 11:52 BST
Comments
The cancer rate in Fos-Sur-Mer is nearly half the national average
The cancer rate in Fos-Sur-Mer is nearly half the national average (AFP/Getty)

The line of giant chimneys ceaselessly belching smoke in the air stretches to the horizon in one of the most polluted industrial zones in Europe.

For years, the inhabitants of Fos-sur-Mer, France accepted their illnesses — for example, a cancer rate that is double the national average — in exchange for jobs in the nearly 200 factories, warehouses, gas terminals and industrial sheds that surround them.

Doctors’ waiting rooms were often full. At the cemetery, tombstones recorded the deaths of young men cut down in their prime. In addition to the cancer rate, the asthma rate is also considerably higher than the national average, according to a publicly funded health study.

But citizens in this otherwise sun-dappled corner of the Mediterranean, just west of Marseille, decided not long ago that they would take action, whatever their misgivings about losing their jobs.

In a groundbreaking move, they took their fight to a place rarely used in France to resolve such disputes: the country’s justice system.

Many of the citizens of Fos-sur-Mer have banded together to file a criminal complaint accusing the steel, oil and petrochemical companies in the region of putting their lives at risk. It is a first in France: Hundreds of citizens taking on an entire region’s industry in court and threatening criminal sanctions.

Nearly 20 per cent of France’s factories classified as high risk by the European Union are clustered in Fos-sur-Mer, built alongside a giant inland lagoon.

The citizens are calling into question a decades-old state industrial strategy that looked to pack as much heavy industry as possible into a confined area without questioning the human costs.

Now the state, typically seen in France as the ultimate protector, is being blamed for failing to shield residents from the pollution and is accused of going easy on the companies for decades and damaging the health of the whole region along the way.

Whatever the outcome of the lawsuits, both criminal and civil, the novel legal battle underway in Fos-sur-Mer is likely to have far-reaching effects on citizen efforts to push back against polluters in France.

“This is a first,” said Christelle Gramaglia, sociologist at the National Research Institute for Environment, Agriculture, Food. “In Fos, the originality of it is, you’ve got the unions in the factories who are saying: The residents’ problems are the same as ours.”

The New York Times

Join our commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies

Comments

Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in