Netanyahu rejects Biden’s call to drop controversial judicial overhaul plans

The Israeli prime minister struck a more conciliatory tone later in the day, calling calling the alliance between his country and the US ‘unshakable’

Ilan Ben Zion
Thursday 30 March 2023 15:22 BST
Biden, Netanyahu go back and forth over Israeli judicial reform plan

Israel's Benjamin Netanyahu has rejected President Joe Biden's suggestion that the prime minister walk away from a controversial plan to overhaul the legal system – saying that his country makes its own decisions.

The exchange was a rare bout of public disagreement between the two close allies and signals building friction between Israel and the United States over Mr Netanyahu's judicial changes, which he postponed after massive protests.

Asked by reporters what he hopes happens with the legislation, Mr Biden replied, "I hope he walks away from it." The president added that Mr Netanyahu's government "cannot continue down this road" and urged compromise on the plan.

The president also stepped around US Ambassador Thomas Nides' suggestion that Mr Netanyahu would soon be invited to the White House in his remarks late on Tuesday, saying: "No, not in the near term."

Mr Netanyahu responded by saying that Israel is sovereign and "makes its decisions by the will of its people and not based on pressures from abroad, including from the best of friends."

Later on Wednesday, Mr Netanyahu struck a more conciliatory tone, saying that while "Israel and the United States have had their occasional differences," the alliance between them was "unshakable."

"Nothing can change that," he said in remarks to the State Department's Summit for Democracy.

The frosty exchange came a day after Mr Netanyahu called for a halt to his government's contentious legislation "to avoid civil war" in the wake of two consecutive days of mass protests that drew tens of thousands of people to Israel's streets that followed weeks of demonstrations.

"Hopefully the prime minister will act in a way that he can try to work out some genuine compromise. But that remains to be seen," Mr Biden said to reporters as he left North Carolina to return to Washington.

The hardline Itamar Ben-Gvir, a close Netanyahu ally and minister in charge of police, told Israel's Army Radio that Israel "is not another star in the American flag."

"I expect the US president to understand this point," he added.

Speaking to Kan public radio, the education minister, Yoav Kisch, said that "a friend may not try to impose on the other regarding internal issues."

Mr Netanyahu had several public spats with then-President Barack Obama over Israel's policies toward the Palestinians and the Iranian nuclear issue. In 2015, he went behind the White House's back to address Congress and rail against a nuclear deal between world powers and Iran that was in the offing.

Nimrod Goren, senior fellow at the Middle East Institute think tank, noted that the U.-Israel relationship has had previous points of crisis — over, for example, the now-defunct agreement to limit Iran's nuclear capabilities. In contrast, he said, now the White House appeared to be "questioning Netanyahu's competence as prime minister, and whether he's reliable or responsible."

Mr Netanyahu and his religious and ultranationalist allies announced the judicial overhaul in January just days after forming their government, the most right-wing in Israel's history.

The proposal has plunged Israel into its worst domestic crisis in decades. Business leaders, top economists and former security chiefs have all come out against the plan, saying it is pushing the country toward dictatorship.

The plan would give Mr Netanyahu, who is on trial on corruption charges (he denies the allegations), and his allies the final say in appointing the nation's judges. It would also give parliament, which is controlled by his allies, authority to overturn Supreme Court decisions and limit the court's ability to review laws.

Critics say the legislation would concentrate power in the hands of Mr Netanyahu’s coalition in parliament and upset the balance of checks and balances between branches of government.

Mr Netanyahu said he was "striving to achieve (it) via a broad consensus" in talks with opposition leaders that began Tuesday.

Yair Lapid, the opposition leader in Israel's parliament, wrote on Twitter that Israel was one of the closest US allies for decades but "the most radical government in the country's history ruined that in three months."

Associated Press

Join our commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies


Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in