Stay up to date with notifications from The Independent

Notifications can be managed in browser preferences.

Netanyahu's tactical fear-mongering campaign against Israeli opposition draws incitement accusations

Israeli leader is allegedly using tried and tested strategy to boost nationalist support

Aron Heller
Saturday 09 March 2019 20:08 GMT
Comments
Ahmad Tibi speaks with AP at his home in Jerusalem, 6 March 2019: "It's possible Benjamin Netanyahu is leading us toward a binational state, and then it will either be an apartheid state in which only the Jews can vote, or a democratic country in which there is one person, one vote. If that happens, tomorrow I will run against Bibi. Then it will really be Bibi or Tibi."
Ahmad Tibi speaks with AP at his home in Jerusalem, 6 March 2019: "It's possible Benjamin Netanyahu is leading us toward a binational state, and then it will either be an apartheid state in which only the Jews can vote, or a democratic country in which there is one person, one vote. If that happens, tomorrow I will run against Bibi. Then it will really be Bibi or Tibi." ((Sebastian Scheiner/AP))

When prime minister Benjamin Netanyahu has run into political trouble in the past, he has lashed out at the media, the political opposition and Israel's Arab minority with incendiary and divisive language to galvanize his nationalist base.

Ahead of 9 April elections, Mr Netanyahu has zoned in on prominent Arab lawmaker Ahmad Tibi.

The Israeli leader, slumping in the polls after the dramatic announcement of his pending corruption indictment, is portraying Tibi as a threat to national security in a charged campaign that critics say questions the loyalty of the country's Arab citizens.

Using his own nickname, Mr Netanyahu has been repeating a campaign mantra: "Bibi or Tibi." The snappy slogan, eagerly parroted by his hard-line allies, highlights Mr Netanyahu's efforts to paint his challengers as weak "leftists" conspiring with Arab Israelis and a hostile media to oust him.

It also shines a spotlight on Mr Tibi — an affable, media-savvy political veteran who speaks fluent Hebrew. Mr Tibi is known for his harsh criticism of government policies towards the country's Arab citizens and towards Palestinians who live under Israeli control in territories Israel captured in 1967.

"Until this week, I didn't know that against my will I was a leading candidate for prime minister," he said with a smile from his home in an Arab neighbourhood of Jerusalem.

Despite the humour, Mr Tibi said he is concerned about what he views as Mr Netanyahu's attempt to demonize Israel's Arab minority.

"He is delegitimising the Arab parties, the Arab lawmakers and the Arab public in general," he said. "He's trying to transmit that it is either me, the supposed patriotic Jewish leader, or the Arabs will take over the country and decide who will be the prime minister. And he portrays this as a nightmare."

Arabs make up about 20 percent of Israel's 9 million residents. They hold full citizenship rights but have faced decades of discrimination.

The outgoing Netanyahu-led government further stoked tensions by passing a controversial law that defines Israel as the nation-state of the Jewish people. A parliamentary panel recently recommended banning an Arab party from running in the election, while Mr Netanyahu has courted anti-Arab extremists in hopes of improving his re-election chances.

Marc Lamont Hill calls for a 'free Palestine from the river to the sea' during UN speech

Part of Mr Netanyahu's typical stump speech these days alleges that his prime challenger, ex-military chief Benny Gantz, will be unable to build a ruling coalition without the backing of Arab parties. Arab parties never sat in an Israeli coalition government, and they say they have no interest in doing so now.

Mr Gantz has been quick to reject the association, flaunting his tough military record of pounding Gaza militants and saying he would not rely on the Arab bloc in parliament to stabilise a future government.

The charge nonetheless is part of the Mr Netanyahu campaign playbook that has worked before.

Fearing a possible loss on election day in 2015, Mr Netanyahu mobilised his supporters by releasing a frantic midday video in which he warned that Arab voters were heading "in droves" to the polls. The move, for which he later apologised, appeared to help turn the tide and secure another term for him.

If he wins again, he's expected to walk back his rhetoric once more, said Yohanan Plesner, president of the non-partisan Israel Democracy Institute.

Mr Plesner said Mr Netanyahu tends to speak in two voices about the Arab minority.

He said Mr Netanyahu has earmarked unprecedented budgets to Arab communities to try to close the wide economic gaps between Arabs and Jews.

But during election campaigns, Mr Netanyahu attempts to mobilise his base, Mr Plesner said. Mr Netanyahu "recruits the ultimate 'other' of Israeli life, which is the Arab minority," he said. "It is cynical, and it is effective."

Such rhetoric will encourage more Arab voters to sit out the election, said Thabet Abu Rass, co-director of the Abraham Fund Initiatives, a non-profit dedicated to promoting equality in Israel.

"A lot of people are now saying we cannot continue to play the game and pretend Israel is a state for all its citizens," he said. "And they'll say we have to highlight this by boycotting the election."

At the same time, many Israeli Jews, especially among Mr Netanyahu's right-wing base, consider the Arab minority disloyal for sympathising with the Palestinians and other Arab adversaries. A decade ago, Arab lawmaker Azmi Bishara fled into exile after he was accused of spying for Hezbollah — a charge he denied.

The 60-year-old Mr Tibi illustrates many of the contradictions faced by Israel's Arabs. He's worked as a gynaecologist in Israeli hospitals and served for years as a member of parliament, but also advised Yasser Arafat, the late Palestinian leader.

For the past two decades, Tibi has advocated for Arab rights in Israel and for a Palestinian state. Hard-line lawmakers frequently brand him a fifth-column in the Israeli legislature.

Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez sparks controversy after referring to the 'occupation' of Palestine

But he is also considered the most popular Arab lawmaker, even among Israeli Jews. He is a regular on their television screens, known for his witty quips.

In parliament, he's earned praise for his environmental and consumer legislation and for his promotion of Holocaust commemoration that touched many Jews.

In the current election campaign, he has refrained from endorsing any of Mr Netanyahu's challengers, wary of playing into the prime minister's hands. Tibi said he is ill at ease with the leadership of the Blue-and-White party, which includes Mr Gantz and two other former chiefs of what he calls the "occupation army."

But he makes no qualms about wanting to unseat Mr Netanyahu, whom he accuses of "Arab hatred" and of leading Israel down a dangerous path by deepening control over the occupied West Bank and its millions of Palestinians.

"It's possible that Benjamin Mr Netanyahu is leading us towards a binational state, and then it will either be an apartheid state in which only the Jews can vote or a democratic country in which there is one person, one vote," he said. "If that happens, tomorrow I will run against Bibi. Then it will really be Bibi or Tibi."

Associated Press

Join our commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies

Comments

Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in