Stay up to date with notifications from The Independent

Notifications can be managed in browser preferences.

UAE launches 'tolerance' ministry days before papal visit despite reports of widespread human rights abuse

Religious discrimination prohibited while political expression barred


Aya Batrawy
Saturday 02 February 2019 14:44 GMT
A man sells memorabilia for Pope Francis' upcoming trip to the UAE at St. Mary's Catholic Church, Dubai. A bridge, new ministry, family day at the park and the year 2019 are branded under the theme 'tolerance' as the country prepares to host Pope Francis from Sunday 3 February 2019.
A man sells memorabilia for Pope Francis' upcoming trip to the UAE at St. Mary's Catholic Church, Dubai. A bridge, new ministry, family day at the park and the year 2019 are branded under the theme 'tolerance' as the country prepares to host Pope Francis from Sunday 3 February 2019. (AP)

The United Arab Emirates has branded a bridge, a new ministry, a family day at the park and even the entire year of 2019 under the banner theme of “tolerance”, an elaborate effort that’s in overdrive as the country prepares to host Pope Francis starting Sunday in the first-ever papal visit to the Arabian Peninsula.

The state’s tolerance-themed project, however, has hard limits. While allowing churches and other places of worship to exist, and marking holidays such as Christmas, the Hindu Diwali and Chinese New Year with festivals and celebrations, the government has simultaneously stamped out critical political expression in the name of national security.

Human rights activists and Muslim Brotherhood sympathisers have been imprisoned, academic research deemed sensitive has been curtailed and human rights groups have been barred entry. Political parties are banned and local media are censored.

And while the law prohibits religious discrimination and guarantees the freedom to exercise religious worship, the state’s official religion of Islam is tightly monitored and controlled.

A permit is required to hold a Quran memorisation circle or lecture, collect donations or distribute books or audio in mosques. The law also prohibits mosque employees from preaching and teaching religious lessons outside of mosques.

Moreover, all imams receive their salaries from the government and – with the exception of the most senior imams – must follow official weekly guidance on the content of Friday sermons.

The UAE‘s Minister of Tolerance, Sheikh Nahyan bin Mubarak Al Nahyan, said the government is simply doing what “we think is right for our people and for the world”.

“We are trying to protect our religion,” he told the Associated Press in an interview last week. “We want to restore our real religion, which stems from our holy book the Quran, which believes in living together. It believes in the dignity of a human being.”

The UAE, a federation of seven constituent monarchies led by President Khalifa bin Zayed Al Nahyan, is known for its gleaming cities of Dubai and Abu Dhabi. Modern skylines draw tourists from around the world, bars exist next to mosques, men and women dressed in traditional garb brush past foreigners, and tight security and surveillance ensures high levels of safety.

UAE now has the most powerful passport in the world, according to Passport Index

Government bodies, public relations firms and even banks have been busy promoting the state’s version of tolerance in preparation for the pope’s visit, which includes a meeting on Monday with Sheikh Ahmed el-Tayeb, the grand imam of Al-Azhar, Sunni Islam’s foremost religious institution, and a mass on Tuesday before 135,000 people in Abu Dhabi.

In a video message translated into English and Arabic ahead of his arrival, Pope Francis described the UAE as “a country that strives to be a model for coexistence and human fraternity, a meeting point of different civilisations and cultures. A place where people find a safe place to work, live freely and where differences are respected.”

The UAE has a Hindu temple in Dubai and a large one being built in Abu Dhabi on land donated by the country’s rulers to help accommodate the roughly 3.3 million Indians who live in the country. It is also home to around 1 million Catholics, including a sizeable Filipino community. In addition to several Catholic churches, there are numerous churches in the UAE of other Christian denominations, a Sikh temple and a space for Jewish worship.

Still, the US-based Freedom House notes that more than 85 per cent of the UAE’s population consists of foreign residents who lack political rights and electoral opportunities, including tens of thousands of stateless residents – known as Bidoon.

Freedom House says that since 2011, when Arab Spring protests rocked countries throughout the Middle East, the UAE has aggressively cracked down on opposition activists, particularly if they are suspected of belonging to Al-Islah, an Islamist group perceived as an offshoot of the Muslim Brotherhood.

The UAE has branded the Muslim Brotherhood a terrorist organisation, viewing it as a threat to the country’s system of hereditary rule.

“They’re certainly not tolerant of any form of political dissent,” Devin Kenney, researcher on the UAE for Amnesty International, said.

“I mean OK, sure, like bars exist and people of multiple faiths are allowed to practise their faith, so it’s not culturally totalitarian, but it’s clearly not a really tolerant place,” he added. Kenney said the Pope’s visit “seems like a fairly straightforward PR gesture”.

In recent years, the UAE named dozens of individuals and some 80 groups as “terrorist” – many for their alleged ties with the Brotherhood, which is not deemed a terrorist group in Europe or the US.

The list includes political dissenters and opposition voices, but also groups like the Council on American-Islamic Relations, a Muslim advocacy and civil rights group in the US, as well as Islamic Relief Worldwide, a UK-based humanitarian aid organisation with operations around the world.

In a statement to the AP, Islamic Relief said it is not connected in any way to the Muslim Brotherhood and that the allegation has been “hugely damaging”. The group said it was never provided with any evidence by Emirati authorities to substantiate the assertion and has tried to contest it in UAE courts.

“All our attempts to get an open hearing in front of a judge have been rejected on procedural technicalities,” the group said.

The UAE is also one of four Arab countries that cut ties with Qatar in 2017, in part over its support of the Brotherhood throughout the region. The UAE banned the news operations of Al Jazeera inside the country, expelled Qatari residents, blocked websites affiliated with Qatar and warned residents that anyone who expressed sympathy for Qatar could face up to 15 years in prison.

“Nobody’s perfect in this world ... ,” Al Nahyan, the tolerance minister, said. “We’re proud of our acceptance, tolerance, respect for human dignity, having laws that protect everybody’s rights.”

Associated Press

Join our commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies


Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in