Joe Joyce is the juggernaut who lost his way – an inquest is needed

It was supposed to be an audition to face Tyson Fury for a title shot – instead, the big Brit must begin over again

Joe Joyce lost for the first time on Saturday night at the CopperBox in east London and it was painful to watch.

Joyce was rescued from a lost cause in round six by the referee, Howard Foster. His 12-round fight with China’s Zhilei Zhang was officially finished after 1.23 of the sixth and it was a real upset.

The fight’s savagery would be devalued by talking about the trinkets won and lost – the gaudy prizes are currency, but this fight was about survival and not retaining a belt studded with fake diamonds. Zhang and Joyce are better than the sham belts that slippery salesmen are desperate to hand out in the ring.

It was called off when Joyce’s right eye had closed shut. It was lumpy, swollen with darkening bruises and he had lost his ability to see the punches that Zhang was landing. Joyce was still coming forward, blind on that right side and somehow determined to salvage the fight. The damage was to his eye, not his heart. Zhang just stuck to his plan, no panic, tucked up and let his fists fly when there was an opening.

Joyce twice had his swollen and closed right eye examined by the ringside doctor in the sixth; Joyce had no vision in the eye, was vulnerable to Zhang’s best punch and was fighting on instinct. It was ugly for two or three rounds, a real drama. Even the iconic Jimmy Tibbs, working in silence in the corner with an Enswell, could not reduce the bruising to the damaged eye.

Boxers are brave, not stupid, and the shocking and brutal finish was the only way, from about round four, that the fight could end. Zhang, the firm underdog, had been magnificent; Joyce, the big favourite, had been hit far too often and far too easily from the opening bell. The healing of the eye is not the only concern for Joyce; he was too light on the scales and fought at times like he had never faced a southpaw. There will need to be an inquest of hard truths – Joyce is honest and will know his mistakes.

It is far too simplistic to claim that Joyce with two eyes would have beaten – as he was expected to do – Zhang. The harsh truth on Saturday night is that Joyce was far too static, for far too long and was, oddly, repeatedly caught and hurt by Zhang before the eye started to shut. Zhang had a magnificent plan to counter and move, which on paper had no chance of working. On Saturday night in the opening rounds, Zhang seldom missed.

The fight was called off when Joyce’s right eye closed shut (Getty)

Joyce, you see, is the big juggernaut, capable of withstanding the most destructive of the division’s feared men and he had walked through the punches of his 15 opponents. Joyce had been a heartbreaker in his previous fights, taking the spirits of his victims before knocking them out. It seems bizarre now, but Joyce was becoming the heavyweight division’s most avoided fighter. Zhang has not inherited that title.

Zhang, who is six foot six, just under 20 stone, a southpaw and an Olympic silver medalist, was never hurt and used every bit of his obvious class to hurt and outbox Joyce. The win ended a week when Zhang, who turns 40 in a few days, was sold cheaply as a novelty act, a giant of a man willing to laugh at his own dimensions, but far too old at 39 and slow to bother Joyce. It is one of boxing’s oldest and greatest myths.

China’s Zhilei Zhang caused an upset with his accuracy and southpaw style (Getty)

It was clear from the first exchanges in the opening round that Joyce was struggling with Zhang’s accuracy and southpaw style. It was reported that Joyce would move his feet for a round or three, pick his way carefully into the fight and take the speed and danger out of Zhang’s punches. It was a sensible plan, but it was ruined by Zhang’s boxing brain; Joyce was being countered, picked off and hurt. In round two, Joyce staggered back, his right eye starting to close, his nightmare in east London firmly underway.

Joyce never hid behind the purple, swollen and damaged eye. “He beat me, that’s it - I will get him next time,” he said. There is a rematch clause, which Joyce can activate. He will, make no mistake. The next time, a different Joyce will enter the ring and perhaps, just perhaps, we will get the fight we expected on Saturday night. Zhang, meanwhile, will also be smarter and more confident.

The sensible thinking before the fight was that Joyce would stop Zhang in about nine rounds and then try and force either Oleksandr Usyk or Tyson Fury, who has vanished, to accept his challenge.

Instead, Zhang ruined the heavyweight party and the plans of Joe Joyce with a smart performance that nobody expected. It was an upset to enjoy for all the wrong reasons. Joyce will be back, Zhang will be waiting.