There is also a recall for fit-again bowling all-rounder Chris Woakes, who comes into the 13-man squad for Ben Stokes, who is unavailable for Lord’s as it clashes with his trial on a charge of affray in Bristol that starts on Monday.
Moeen Ali and Jamie Porter, who did not play but were in the squad for England’s 31-run win in the series opener at Edgbaston, are also retained.
However, it the decision to replace the out-of-form Malan, who made just 28 runs in the first Test and dropped three catches, with Pope that is the most eye-catching selection.
The youngster only made his first-class debut in March of last year but has been in sensational form for Surrey this summer, averaging 85 in the County Championship and also hitting a match-winning unbeaten half-century for England Lions against India A at Worcester last month.
Pope saw off the challenge of Worcestershire’s Joe Clarke, who had trained with England at Edgbaston last week.
It the latest bold pick by new national selector Ed Smith, whose decisions to call on Jos Buttler, Adil Rashid and Sam Curran, also 20 and a team-mate of Pope’s at Surrey, have all proved inspired.
Malan had an encouraging Ashes series in Australia last winter, where he hit his maiden century and averaged 42. But his predominantly back-foot technique has been exposed in English conditions, in which he averages just 20 in Tests, and Smith has inferred he is likely only to now be considered for overseas tours if at all. “Dawid Malan drops out of the squad for Lord’s,” said Smith. “Dawid has not found his best rhythm this season, and it may be that his game is better suited to overseas conditions.”
On Pope, Smith added: “Ollie has made an exceptional start to his first-class career. He has reached a 1,000 first class runs in just 15 matches and is the first division’s stand-out batsman this season with 684 runs at 85. The selection panel believe that Ollie’s performances and character suggest he is well suited to international cricket.
“Ben Stokes is unavailable, but Chris Woakes, with some extra matches and practices under his belt, can now return to the England squad after injury.”
Join our new commenting forum
Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies