Stay up to date with notifications from The Independent

Notifications can be managed in browser preferences.

Why Antoine Griezmann, Kylian Mbappe and Paulo Dybala may usher in a new generation of superstars

The trio of young stars have helped to light up this year's Champions League. If they all decide to remain at their current clubs, they'll continue to do so for many years to come

Miguel Delaney
Chief Football Writer
Friday 14 April 2017 15:56 BST
Comments

One of the big questions with Atletico Madrid’s Antoine Griezmann right now is where he will play next season, but one big reason for that - and one big problem the Leicester City defenders found on Wednesday - is that it’s impossible to know where he’s going to be on the pitch in the next second of play.

Beyond his obvious ability and pace, the Atletico Madrid number-seven's instinct and sense of timing are beyond most players in the world. As many at the Vicente Calderon said in either awe and exasperation, he was “everywhere”.

The 26-year-old only scored a penalty, but still gave a master-class in performing as a modern forward, using one position to almost operate in four.

Griezmann excelled in the trequartista role against Leicester (Getty)

“He’s a complete player,” his Atletico Madrid manager Diego Simeone enthused.

“You don’t even know what position he plays in any more. He would work as a midfielder if needed, he can complete passes like a second striker, he can play like a proper striker and he’s still growing.”

Teammate Filipe Luis even praised his defensive work while describing him as a “phenomenon”.

Similar words were obviously used in the last few days about JuventusPaulo Dybala after his destruction of Barcelona, and Monaco’s Kylian Mbappe following his exhilarating display away to Borussia Dortmund.

Mbappe scored a brace against Dortmund (Getty ) (Getty)

It was a telling and thrilling Champions League week in that sense. Griezmann, Dybala and Mbappe might have already gone a long way to deciding this season’s competition, but they also gave a huge glimpse of its future.

Those three players - along of course with Bernardo Silva, Neymar, Thiago Alcantara and a series of other young sensations - look set to enliven the coming post-Cristiano Ronaldo/Leo Messi era in such an encouraging and exciting way.

Both Ronaldo and Messi of course showed they are a long way from finished, one with his brilliantly decisive goals for Real Madrid against Bayern Munich and the other with some moments of typically higher-level excellence even in a bad Barcelona defeat at Juventus.

It was still so pointed that they were only parts in the show rather than the two billboard stars and, depending on how this Champions League season goes, we could finally see someone else win the Ballon D’Or for the first time in a decade. That should arguably already be the case.

Either way, it further fosters a greater sense of democracy about this Champions League season, to go with the fact that only one of Bayern Munich, Barcelona and Real Madrid is likely to be in the semi-finals for the first time since 2009.

It is little wonder that all of these super-clubs along with the super-wealthy English are looking to these players as their next big-name signings, but it feeds into a debate about that very democracy, and the development of these very players.dyba

Dybala recently signed a new contract at Juventus (Getty)

As regards the development of those three players to this point, they clearly show the influence of Messi and Ronaldo too. Griezmann, Mbappe and Dybala are all-round forwards in the way those two legends both first fully exemplified at their peak.

They may never get to the levels of perfection that Ronaldo or Messi did, but they are still near-perfect modern strikers. That is what was so particularly relevant and revelatory about Griezmann’s display against Leicester, one where Atletico Madrid admitted they changed their game to be more proactive. It reflected how this trio are attackers who can hurt you from anywhere.

They are mobile and versatile with such a level of game intelligence, and exemplify what City coach Rodolfo Borrell describes as the players who were “kids who slept with the ball in their beds”. There is such a joy to their game. They have also been greatly nurtured by their current clubs.

Ballon d'Or: Cristiano Ronaldo's career in numbers

Griezmann was already considered one of the game’s accelerating stars - in every sense - at Real Sociedad, but it would be impossible to deny that working with someone like Simeone from the age of just 23 has enhanced him even more.

The Atletico coach has imbued him with a sophisticated tactical awareness as well as his own ruthlessness, and that is why Griezmann sees his future as so connected to his manager’s.

What high-level Italian sources say is remarkable about Dybala meanwhile is that, as impressive as he had been for Palermo, he still looked a little physically unprepared for the very top level of Serie A and Europe. Juventus did more than show faith in him. They really showed how much they appreciated him, and valued him.

Dybala has improved immeasurably since his time at Palermo (Getty)

Having signed the 23-year-old early - just before the 2015 Champions League final defeat to Barcelona - they paid for him to fly in and watch the game in Berlin, to emphasise to him what the growing club were going to be about.

He travelled back with the squad, whereupon Claudio Marchisio came up to him and asked - or, rather, demanded: “you ready to win with us?”

He was. Dybala now looks capable of lifting them to a greater level of winning. Those who know him say he has that special winner’s temperament, decisive and assured, but without the damaging arrogance. He is said to be “great from a coach’s perspective”, with all of the talent and match-winning abilities without any of the ego or neediness.

Mbappe is a quiet character away from the field (Getty)

Then there’s Mbappe, a player whose rise to this level has been so rousing and rapid that it is almost impossible to put into any context beyond sensational natural talent.

It would be a mistake to say he is not benefitting from his environment, though, or careful decisions like that of Leonardo Jardim to spare the 18-year-old from the weekend’s essential Ligue 1 win over Angers.

Having drawn fair comparisons with Ajax 1995, Monaco look like a group of special young players aware they are sharing a great moment, and also aware that very youth frees them from that extra stifling pressure. Again, there is just that joy to their game.

That also raises a key point about where they go next, however, especially for the younger two of Dybala and Mbappe.

Real Madrid have expressed an interest in signing both players (Getty)

Given that they are almost destined to go to the very top clubs, they would all be walking into very different environments, with very different expectations from supporters.

The first teams of Real Madrid, Manchester United and even now Barcelona are no longer necessarily the best environments to maximise young talent. It’s all too short-term, with too many immediate demands, and too many stars almost crowding them out.

Every mistake in that context would be used as evidence they’re overrated, as has arguably happened with James Rodriguez and Paul Pogba.

The top level of football has almost flipped in that way. Whereas history used to dictate that young stars must go to the biggest clubs to reach the top level, the economics of those big clubs arguably mean you should only go there when you're already at the top level, to guarantee football and avoid the usual hysteria.

Even if they did that, though, this season has emphasised it would be something of a shame for the Champions League.

None of these players might reach the level of Messi or Ronaldo, but their performances this season for the second level of clubs, have made the competition the liveliest and most unpredictable it has been for arguably 15 years, with a true vitality and variety to it.

The trio have some way to go before they emulate Ronaldo and Messi (Getty)

For them to go to the big clubs too soon would be to begin removing that sense of excitement too soon. That is why the announcement of Dybala’s new contract was someway encouraging, even if it also looks like Juve are well on the way to becoming that level of club.

Mbappe could maybe do with similar and stay at Monaco without the extra pressure for at least two more years. It is just as encouraging as Dybala’s new contract that he has already talked in December about how he didn’t want to leave for somewhere like Real Madrid too early, as is Griezmann’s loyalty to Simeone.

What a shame it would be if the older French star didn’t show the same loyalty to Atletico and ended up at Real Madrid, or Mbappe just rushed to the Bernabeu. The big clubs would just be accumulating the world’s next big stars even earlier than before.

It is better for the Champions League if they stay, and maybe better for their careers right now too.

Join our commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies

Comments

Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in