Stay up to date with notifications from The Independent

Notifications can be managed in browser preferences.

Germany vs England player ratings: Dele Alli, Adam Lallana and Jake Livermore impress in defeat

Who impressed as Gareth Southgate's new-look side were defeated in Dortmund?

Wednesday 22 March 2017 22:55 GMT

Germany 1 England 0 player ratings

Show all 22

1/22Germany 1 England 0 player ratings

Germany 1 England 0 player ratings

Marc-Andre ter Stegen – 6 out of 10

Rash when coming out to challenge Vardy early on, but stood firm to block Alli’s decent chance towards the end of the first half.

Germany 1 England 0 player ratings

Joshua Kimmich – 7 out of 10

One of the few young German players to have a decent evening and potentially sent a message to Carlo Ancelotti, who has not offered him much playing time this season.

Germany 1 England 0 player ratings

Mats Hummels – 7 out of 10

Germany’s best all-round performer, rarely looked troubled by England’s attacking talents.

Germany 1 England 0 player ratings

Antonio Rudiger – 6 out of 10

A solid display, if unspectacular. Did well on the rare occasions when England went aerial.

Germany 1 England 0 player ratings

Jonas Hector – 7 out of 10

Impressed after taking his time to grow into the game. His link-up play with Sane in the second-half was at the root of all England’s problems.

Germany 1 England 0 player ratings

Julian Weigl – 5 out of 10

The main culprit in Germany’s surprising struggle to who Hauled off for Liverpool’s Emre Can midway through the second half.

Germany 1 England 0 player ratings

Toni Kroos – 5 out of 10

Surprisingly poor when it came to the simple stuff, misplaced several passes when not under pressure. Struggled to win his battle against the lesser light of Livermore.

Germany 1 England 0 player ratings

Leroy Sane – 6 out of 10

Did not crackle like we know he can from his recent Manchester City form, but another who improved as the evening went on. Perhaps should’ve doubled Germany’s lead.

Germany 1 England 0 player ratings

Julian Brandt – 4 out of 10

Another player reportedly attracting Premier League interest, he did not show why here. Switched for Andre Schurrle.

Germany 1 England 0 player ratings

Lukas Podolski – 6 out of 10

The equivalent of a testimonial for the veteran and you could tell from his first-half performance. Then came Der Hammer, as Germany’s support calls his left peg. A stunning winner.

Germany 1 England 0 player ratings

Timo Werner – 4 out of 10

The RB Leipzig frontman, a reported target for Liverpool, failed to translate his exciting form at club level to the international stage. Disappointing, but it was only his debut.

Germany 1 England 0 player ratings

Joe Hart – 7 out of 10

Could do little for Podolski’s goal, but did well shortly after to deny Sane with an excellent stop down low to his left.

Germany 1 England 0 player ratings

Gary Cahill – 4 out of 10

Lucky not to concede a penalty for needlessly leaning into a cross in the first-half and could have done better to stop Podolski’s screamer.

Germany 1 England 0 player ratings

Michael Keane – 6 out of 10

Asked to play in a back three on his debut after excelling in a rigid four at Turf Moor all season, but coped admirably. One lapse in concentration was almost punished by Sane.

Germany 1 England 0 player ratings

Chris Smalling – 5 out of 10

An indifferent night from the centre-half. Unlike Cahill, he was rarely called into question, but still did not convince.

Germany 1 England 0 player ratings

Kyle Walker – 6 out of 10

Showed why he will be integral to Southgate’s England in his forays down the right flank, but only did so in glimpses. Hector and Sane began to cause him problems has the game went on.

Germany 1 England 0 player ratings

Eric Dier – 6 out of 10

A lucky boy not to be severely punished for a late, robust tackle on Weigl. That aside, he helped to stifle Germany’s midfield.

Germany 1 England 0 player ratings

Jake Livermore – 7 out of 10

Not everyone’s idea of a no 7, but combined well with Dier in the centre of the park to disrupt Germany’s passing, particularly in the first half.

Germany 1 England 0 player ratings

Ryan Bertrand – 6 out of 10

Not as threatening as Walker was in moments, but defensively solid and frustrated Brandt in the first-half. Schurrle gave him a few more problems after the break.

Germany 1 England 0 player ratings

Dele Alli – 7 out of 10

England’s main creative outlet, but also found himself on the end of several chances. Should have opened the scoring with the first-half’s best chance but hit it straight at Ter Stegen.

Germany 1 England 0 player ratings

Adam Lallana – 7 out of 10

Came close to scoring in his fourth straight England appearance, but thwacked the post after an impressive burst forward.

Germany 1 England 0 player ratings

Jamie Vardy – 5 out of 10

Aggrieved to have not won a penalty early on, but you could tell he was looking for it. Too deep at times too, despite Germany’s defensive line offering him space in behind.

Germany's Lukas Podolski made a fairytale farewell from international football, condemning Gareth Southgate to his first defeat as England manager with a stunning winner in Dortmund.

Podolski was making his 130th and final appearance for Germany and marked an emotional friendly with his 49th goal, a belter from 25 yards to seal a 1-0 win in the latest instalment of his storied fixture.

It was tough luck on England, who had controlled proceedings up to his 69th-minute strike, but Adam Lallana's solo effort against the post and a one-on-one miss from Dele Alli were as close as they came to beating Marc-Andre ter Stegen.

Who impressed in an eventful encounter at Signal Iduna Park? Take a look at the gallery above to find out how we rated the players.

Do you agree with our ratings? Who was your man of the match?Let us know in the comments.

Additional reporting by PA

Join our commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies