Sign up to the Independent's betting newsletter for the latest tips and offers Sign up to the Independent's betting newsletter
There was a long-absent sense of anticipation at Villa Park as Tim Sherwood strolled down the touchline wearing his trademark black gilet beneath a dark suit jacket and took the applause of the home fans before kick-off.
By the end, though, a familiar gloom had descended. Victor Moses’s 93rd-minute penalty had inflicted a sixth straight League loss on Villa and the new manager, standing glumly with folded arms in the technical area, had seen for himself the massive size of his task ahead.
Ron Vlaar’s rash challenge on Moses earned the Dutchman a second yellow card and led to this damaging debut defeat for Sherwood, whose team slipped below Burnley into 19th place as a consequence. Sherwood, after a week of positive soundbites, admitted he was “devastated”. “No-one feels as down as I am,” he said. “We have to put this behind us now and not dwell on it. Games are running out.”
Aston Villa - the latest match in picturesShow all 108 1 /108Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Southampton 6 Aston Villa 1 Shane Long curls in Southampton's fifth goal
Getty Images
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Southampton 6 Aston Villa 1 Shane Long added a fourth for Southampton
Getty Images
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Southampton 6 Aston Villa 1 Mane scores his third to net the fastest ever Premier League hat-trick
Getty Images
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Southampton 6 Aston Villa 1 Mane scores his second to double Southampton's lead
Getty Images
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Southampton 6 Aston Villa 1 Sadio Mane celebrates netting the fastest hat-trick in Premier League history
Getty Images
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Aston Villa 3 Everton 2 Romelu Lukaku challenges for the ball with Ron Vlaar
Getty Images
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Aston Villa 3 Everton 2 Christian Benteke scores for Aston Villa
Getty Images
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Aston Villa 3 Everton 2 Jores Okore and Steven Naismith challenge for the ball
Getty Images
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Aston Villa 3 Everton 2 Tom Cleverley scores for Aston Villa
Getty Images
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Sunderland 0 Aston Villa 4 Christian Benteke celebrates after opening the scoring
GETTY IMAGES
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Sunderland 0 Aston Villa 4 Gabriel Agbonlahor of Aston Villa scores their second goal
GETTY IMAGES
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Sunderland 0 Aston Villa 4 Agbonlahor scores the third goal for Villa
GETTY IMAGES
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Sunderland 0 Aston Villa 4 Christian Benteke of Aston Villa celebrates scoring their fourth goal
GETTY IMAGES
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Sunderland 0 Aston Villa 4 Tim Sherwood celebrates after seeing his side score four goals in the first half
GETTY IMAGES
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Aston Villa 2 West Brom 1 Gabriel Agbonlahor celebrates opening the scoring for Aston Villa
GETTY IMAGES
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Aston Villa 2 West Brom 1 Tim Sherwood celebrates after Aston Villa open the scoring against West Brom
GETTY IMAGES
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Aston Villa 2 West Brom 1 Saido Berahino celebrates scoring the equaliser for West Brom against Aston Villa
GETTY IMAGES
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Aston Villa 2 West Brom 1 Christian Benteke of Aston Villa celebrates scoring the winner for Aston Villa
GETTY IMAGES
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Aston Villa 1 Stoke 2 Victor Moses broke Tom Sherwood's heart with a late winner from the spot.
Getty
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Aston Villa 1 Stoke 2 Mame Biram Diouf dragged Stoke back into the game with a well-taken equaliser.
Getty
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Aston Villa 1 Stoke 2 Scott Sinclair put Tim Sherwood's men in front in the first half.
Getty
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Aston Villa 1 Stoke 2 Tim Sherwood was making his Aston Villa debut in the Villa Park dugout against Stoke.
Getty
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Hull 2 Aston Villa 0 Dame N'Doye celebrates his goal for Hull
GETTY IMAGES
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Arsenal 5 Aston Villa 0 Theo Walcott strikes Arsenal's third
GETTY IMAGES
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Arsenal 5 Aston Villa 0 Mesut Ozil celebrates his goal, Arsenal's second
GETTY IMAGES
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Arsenal 5 Aston Villa 0 Mesut Ozil gets on the scoresheet for the Gunners
GETTY IMAGES
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Aston Villa 2 Bournemouth 1 Carles Gil celebrates his first goal for Aston Villa
GETTY IMAGES
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Aston Villa 0 Liverpool 2 Rickie Lambert celebrates his goal against Villa
Getty Images
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Aston Villa 0 Liverpool 2 Paul Lambert reacts after his Aston Villa side miss an effort on goal
Getty Images
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Aston Villa 0 Liverpool 2 Liverpool celebrates after Fabio Borini puts them ahead early on
Getty Images
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Aston Villa 0 Liverpool 2 Fabio Borini taps the ball into the net to put Liverpool ahead
Getty Images
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Leicester 1 Aston Villa 0 Ciaran Clark is shown a red card after picking up his second booking
Getty Images
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Leicester 1 Aston Villa 0 Matty James is shown a red card for his part in the fracas between the two teams
Getty Images
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Leicester 1 Aston Villa 0 The incident quickly becomes a shoving match between all players from both teams
Getty Images
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Leicester 1 Aston Villa 0 Matty James and Ciaran Clark square up after the latters rash challenge on Jores Akore
Getty Images
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Leicester 1 Aston Villa 0 Leonardo Ulloa slides in on Ashley Westwood
Getty Images
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Leicester 1 Aston Villa 0 Marcin Wasilewski catches Gabriel Agbonlahor with a challenge
Getty Images
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Aston Villa 1 Blackpool 0 Christian Benteke of Aston Villa scores the opening goal
Getty Images
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Aston Villa 1 Blackpool 0 Joe Cole of Aston Villa is tackled by David Perkins of Blackpool
Getty Images
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Aston Villa 0 Crystal Palace 0 Alan Pardew watches Crystal Palace from the stands against Aston Villa
GETTY IMAGES
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Aston Villa 0 Crystal Palace 0 Christian Benteke of Aston Villa and Adrian Mariappa of Crystal Palace battle for the ball during the goalless draw
GETTY IMAGES
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Aston Villa 0 Sunderland 0 Fabian Delph of Aston Villa was shown a red card by referee Martin Atkinson
GETTY IMAGES
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Aston Villa 0 Sunderland 0 Despite the Aston Villa midfielder's early dismissal, Sunderland were unable to take advantage
GETTY IMAGES
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Swansea 1 Aston Villa 0 Wilfried Bony leaps highest to meet a cross, but his header is off-target
Getty Images
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Swansea 1 Aston Villa 0 Jefferson Montero is forced off with injury
Getty Images
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Swansea 1 Aston Villa 0 Brad Guzan is unable to stop Gylfi Sigurdsson's free-kick going in the back of the net
Getty Images
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Aston Villa 1 Manchester United 1 Manchester United players embrace striker Radamel Falcao after his goal
Getty Images
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Aston Villa 1 Manchester United 1 Radamel Falcao celebrates scoring the equaliser against Aston Villa
Getty Images
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Aston Villa 1 Manchester United 1 Christian Benteke celebrates scoring the opening goal against Manchester United
Getty Images
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Aston Villa 1 Manchester United 1 Christian Benteke scores a beautiful curling effort to put Aston Villa ahead
Getty Images
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Aston Villa 2 Leicester 1 Leonardo Ulloa put Leicester in front after Brad Guzan spilled a shot
Getty Images
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Aston Villa 2 Leicester 1 Ciaran Clark headed home the equaliser from a free-kick
Getty Images
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Aston Villa 2 Leicester 1 Ashley Westwood is carried off on a stretcher after picking up a first-half injury
Getty Images
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Aston Villa 2 Leicester 1 Alan Hutton fires home his first goal for Aston Villa and what would turn out to be the match-winner
Getty Images
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Aston Villa 2 Leicester 1 Leicester left-back Paul Konchesky was sent off after clashing with Hutton
Getty Images
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Aston Villa 2 Leicester 1 Paul Lambert's team are now unbeaten in five but Nigel Pearson has not won in 10
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Crystal Palace 0 Aston Villa 1 Christian Benteke wheels away in celebration
GETTY IMAGES
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Burnley 1 Aston Villa 1 Paul Lambert on the bench without the now-departed Roy Keane
Getty Images
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Burnley 1 Aston Villa 1 Joe Cole celebrates scoring on his first start for the club
Getty Images
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Burnley 1 Aston Villa 1 Gabby Agbonlahor challenges Tom Heaton in the Burnley goal
Getty Images
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Burnley 1 Aston Villa 1 Ashley Barnes holds off Carlos Sanchez
Getty Images
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Burnley 1 Aston Villa 1 Aly Cissokho holds of Burnley winger Michael Kightly
Getty Images
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Burnley 1 Aston Villa 1 Danny Ings scored an 87th-minute penalty to earn Burnley a vital point
Getty Images
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures West Ham 0 Aston Villa 0 James Collins leaps to clear a corner
Getty Images
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures West Ham 0 Aston Villa 0 Nathan Baker stretches out a leg to stop West Ham striker Diafra Sakho
Getty Images
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures West Ham 0 Aston Villa 0 Collins tussles with Gabriel Agbonlahor at Upton Park
Getty Images
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures West Ham 0 Aston Villa 0 Alex Song wins the ball in midfield ahead of Charles N'Zogbia
Getty Images
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures West Ham 0 Aston Villa 0 Enner Valencia sees a late strike saved by Villa goalkeeper Brad Guzan
Getty Images
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures West Ham 0 Aston Villa 0 The point ended a run of six straight defeats by Aston Villa
Getty Images
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Aston Villa 1 Tottenham 2 Andreas Weimann celebrates after ending Villa's long wait for a goal to put the home side in front
Getty
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Aston Villa 1 Tottenham 2 Nacer Chadli pulls Tottenham level in the 84 minute
Getty
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Aston Villa 1 Tottenham 2 Harry Kane celebrates scoring Spurs' winning goal with Andros Townsend
Getty
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures QPR 2 Aston Villa 0 QPR celebrate the opening goal against Aston Villa
GETTY IMAGES
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures QPR 2 Aston Villa 0 Zamora and Lowton in action
GETTY IMAGES
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures QPR 2 Aston Villa 0 Rob Green makes a useful intervention
GETTY IMAGES
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures QPR 2 Aston Villa 0 Yoon Suk Young makes a tackle
GETTY IMAGES
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures QPR 2 Aston Villa 0 Charlie Austin celebrates his second goal of the game
GETTY IMAGES
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Everton 3 Aston Villa 0 Seamus Coleman taps in the home side's third goal
GETTY IMAGES
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Everton 3 Aston Villa 0 Romelu Lukaku celebrates his goal which doubles Everton's lead
GETTY IMAGES
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Everton 3 Aston Villa 0 Ross Barkley in action for Everton on his comeback from injury
GETTY IMAGES
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Everton 3 Aston Villa 0 Phil Jagielka opens the scoring for the Toffees
GETTY IMAGES
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Chelsea 3 Aston Villa 0 Willian tapped in from just a yard out to make sure of the three points for the Blues
Getty Images
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Chelsea 3 Aston Villa 0 Diego Costa powered a header past Brad Guzan to score an eighth Premier League goal in only six matches this season
Getty Images
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Chelsea 3 Aston Villa 0 Fabian Delph moves out of the clutches of Chelsea forward Eden Hazard
Getty Images
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Chelsea 3 Aston Villa 0 Jose Mourinho celebrated his 250th match as Chelsea manager with another victory
Getty Images
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Chelsea 3 Aston Villa 0 Restored back into the starting line-up, Brazilian Oscar slotted home to give the Blues the lead
AFP/Getty Images
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Aston Villa 0 Arsenal 3 Aly Cissokho rues his mistake
GETTY IMAGES
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Aston Villa 0 Arsenal 3 Kieran Gibbs puts a cross into the box which leads to Aly Cissokho scoring an own-goal
GETTY IMAGES
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Aston Villa 0 Arsenal 3 Danny Welbeck celebrates his goal
GETTY IMAGES
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Aston Villa 0 Arsenal 3 Danny Welbeck makes it two for the Gunners with his first for the club
GETTY IMAGES
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Aston Villa 0 Arsenal 3 Mesut Ozil opens the scoring for Arsenal with a calmly slotted finish
GETTY IMAGES
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Aston Villa 0 Arsenal 3 Ex-Gunner Phillippe Senderos clears the ball
GETTY IMAGES
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Aston Villa 0 Arsenal 3 Santi Cazorla is tackled
GETTY IMAGES
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Liverpool 0 Aston Villa 1 Gabby Agbonlahor wheels away after putting the visitors ahead.
Getty
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Liverpool 0 Aston Villa 1 Tom Cleverley was making his first start for Aston Villa while Mario Balotelli made his home debut.
Getty
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Liverpool 0 Aston Villa 1 Steven Gerrard gives Mario Balotelli a pep-talk before the Premier League clash with Aston Villa.
Getty
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Aston Villa 0-0 Newcastle Daryl Janmaat prevails in a tussle with Aston Villa left-back Aly Cissokho. The summer signing from Feyenoord has impressed Newcastle United supporters so far.
Getty Images
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Aston Villa 0-0 Newcastle Paul Lambert and Aston Villa assistant manager Roy Keane look on during the match. Keane was characteristically active on the sidelines
Getty Images
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Aston Villa 0-0 Newcastle New Aston Villa signing Carlos Sanchez was named on the bench and replaced Charles N'Zogbia in the 62nd minute.
Getty Images
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Aston Villa 0-0 Newcastle The Villa Park faithful were enthusiastic about the first use of the 'vanishing spray' during the match with Newcastle United. It produced possibly the loudest cheer of the match.
Getty Images
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Aston Villa 0-0 Newcastle Roy Keane exchanges words with Daryl Janmaat during the goalless draw between Aston Villa and Newcastle United.
Getty Images
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Aston Villa 0-0 Newcastle Newcastle United defender Mike Williamson saw red in the second half in a fiery affair at Villa Park.
Getty Images
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Stoke City 0 Aston Villa 1 Gabby Agbonlahor flies in to make a tackle on Erik Pieters during the first half of the contest
Getty Images
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Stoke City 0 Aston Villa 1 Stoke City skipper Ryan Shawcross shields the ball from Charles N'Zogbia, allowing Asmir Begovic to safely collect
Getty Images
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Stoke City 0 Aston Villa 1 Andreas Weimann celebrates the goal that put Aston Villa into the lead at the Britannia, he fired home from a narrow angle
Getty Images
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Stoke City 0 Aston Villa 1 One Aston Villa fan got a bit over-excited when Weimann scored, running onto the field to celebrate with the players
Getty Images
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Stoke City 0 Aston Villa 1 Glenn Whelan tackles Aston Villa new boy Kieran Richardson, signed from Fulham this summer, in the middle of the park
Getty Images
Aston Villa - the latest match in pictures Stoke City 0 Aston Villa 1 Stoke's Marko Arnautovic evades Charles N'Zogbia to put the home side on the attack
Getty Images
They certainly are. Sherwood, who won five of his first six games as Tottenham manager, has 12 left this season, starting at Newcastle next weekend, to preserve the Premier League status of a team who, despite the lift of an early Scott Sinclair goal – their first in a first half since December – could not prevent the old failings and anxieties.
Sherwood had made an immediate impact with his energising half-time talk during Villa’s FA Cup fifth-round victory over Leicester last Sunday. Yesterday he underlined his desire to get his goal-shy side playing on the front foot by dropping both Tom Cleverley and Ashley Westwood, neat footballers but representative perhaps of the over-safe sideways passing that had become Villa’s staple under Paul Lambert.
There was an encouraging sign during one early Christian Benteke break, when three team-mates raced into the box in anticipation of the cross and, by the 20th minute, Villa had the first goal of the new era when Fabian Delph picked up an overhit corner and whipped a brilliant cross back into the box for Sinclair to head in at the far post. Sherwood clenched his fists and Sinclair almost broke through again moments later.
Scott Sinclair put Aston Villa head in the first half (Getty) “I was encouraged with some performances,” Sherwood reflected. “Scott Sinclair was very good, the two centre backs, Kieran Richardson was very lively, Alan Hutton gave us a threat. I am sure we have the quality in the squad, it is going to be about putting the right jigsaw together.”
If the sight of Kevin Richardson’s name on the team sheet – it should have said Kieran, rather than Villa’s 1994 League Cup-winning captain – was a reminder of more successful days, the 10,000 empty seats underlined the level of disaffection among the fanbase. Those who did turn up to greet the new manager saw their team’s fragile confidence vanish after Stoke equalised on the stroke of half-time. Steven Ireland swung in a cross and Mame Biram Diouf got up between Vlaar and Hutton to plant a header home. Sherwood said: “We switched off just before half time from a throw-in and conceded and it knocks the stuffing out of you.”
He has spoken of his wish to get the best out of Benteke but Diouf, Stoke’s Senegal forward, was twice as influential at the other end as the visitors controlled the second half. Although Benteke and Ciaran Clark threatened with headers in the final 10 minutes, the late drama arrived at the other end, Moses sending Brad Guzan the wrong way from the spot following Vlaar’s trip on him.
Stoke manager Mark Hughes said: “A lot of people were saying we’d get beaten today but we didn’t allow Villa to get any momentum.”
For a deflated Sherwood, the feeling was different. “It was a cruel way to lose,” he said, that pre-match optimism long since vanished.
Aston Villa: (4-2-3-1) Guzan; Hutton, Vlaar, Clark, Richardson (Cissokho, 42); Sanchez, Delph; Gil (Weimann, 58), Agbonlahor, Sinclair; Benteke.
Stoke City: (4-2-3-1) Begovic; Bardsley, Wollscheid, Wilson, Pieters (Teixeira, 86); Nzonzi, Whelan; Diouf, Ireland (Sidwell, 85), Moses; Walters.
Referee: Roger East
Man of the match: Diouf (Stoke)
Match rating: 6/10
Join our commenting forum
Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies