Manchester United vs Arsenal match report: Olivier Giroud saves below-par Gunners to share the points

Manchester United 1 Arsenal 1: The Frenchman rose at the far post to cancel out Juan Mata's opener and deny a dominant home side three points

Ian Herbert
at Old Trafford
Saturday 19 November 2016 15:48
Sanchez congratulates Giroud on his header to rescue a draw
Sanchez congratulates Giroud on his header to rescue a draw

As he clambered to his feet to leave the press conference room, Jose Mourinho came up with a spontaneous joke which amused him so much that he repeated it twice more before actually leaving the room. “So, finally I lost against Arsenal!”

But Mourinho doesn’t go in for humour when he feels the desolation of defeat. He wore the demeanour of a contended man because there was substantially enough in this performance to suggest that the horrors of September – when his players were overwhelmed by Manchester City for 45 minutes and embarrassed at Watford – are over and that there is some equilibrium. These are febrile and uncertain times at Old Trafford and if someone on Saturday morning had offered Mourinho a 1-1 draw in which Arsenal’s only effort on target was their late equalising goal, then he would have certainly have taken it.

The defence was – and certainly is – the problem, even though Manchester United were depleted by injury. The central pairing was makeshift to its bootstraps, with Phil Jones, who has played three games all calendar year, and Marcos Rojo, of whom Mourinho memorably declared after the match: “No-one knows what he is.”

But with Luke Shaw frozen out of this squad and Chris Smalling in a state of even chillier relations with the manager, judging by Friday’s press conference, there will be more goals like the Arsenal equaliser. Alex Oxlade-Chamberlain’s run down the right was unchecked by Marcus Rashford and Olivier Giroud’s resulting header unchallenged by Jones. “We don’t have very strong people in the air to cope with the cross,” Mourinho admitted. He didn’t bother pointing out that there'd been an infringement on Jones, who was half way to the ground after a nudge by Laurent Koscielny when Giroud leapt.

Sparks did not fly between Wenger and Mourinho on the touchline

This feels like a component part of United which will need attention in the January transfer window and certainly next summer. United have lacked a commanding central defender since Nemanja Vidic left, when Sir Alex Ferguson took his leave. Goals will be leaked. Mouriunho’s United trajectory is unlikely to be linear.

But though they have won only two in nine games in the Premier League, there are certainly consolations here. Overall, the afternoon was an emphatic demonstration of Mancunian superiority, with a goal which summed up all that had been the best in the team: a thrust down the right flank which was United’s main route of entry and a first-time, left-footed finish of supreme technical skill by Juan Mata, who’d been outstanding all afternoon.

Mata’s emergence as a player of attacking and creative menace in Mourinho’s United is one of the many unexpected aspects of these past three months, and testament to the maturity of the Spaniard, who had reason to fear the arrival of a manager who sold him to Old Trafford in the first place. He took a monumental ovation when leaving five minutes from time and a warm embrace from Mourinho.

The strength Paul Pogba displayed in setting the match-winning move in train, supplying a ball which Ander Herrara cut back for Mata, carried a significance too. Pogba did not propel the United engine but did enough in moments to suggest that he is developing into what United paid £89m for. Antonio Valencia was the surprise component, though, and at the hub of much that United offered in the first half.

Mata broke the deadlock mid-way through the second half

Few of the Arsenal performances will live in the memory. Alexis Sanchez's was the best from them, spinning off Valencia beautifully on one first half occasion, advancing towards goal and drawing a foul, but Mesut Ozil added little to a promising early attacking thrust and Theo Walcott exerted barely any influence whatsoever. “Maybe it’s a mental block here because for a while it didn’t go well for us,” Wenger said later, which was highly unconvincing as assessments of aspiring champions go.

He looked extremely relieved as he made his own appearance in the press room, happily declaring it would be “pretentious” to claim that the equaliser – created and scored by substitutes was planned. United were actually architects of their own fate, by lacking ruthlessness. Rojo’s headed miss from a Daley Blind cross in the game’s closing stages was fairly criminal. It required two excellent saves from Petr Cech to divert a Mata shot and arced Anthony Martial effort wide of the same right upright.

Giroud rises to equalise late on, beating Jones in the air

It was Valencia, in a surprise first start since breaking an arm against Manchester City in the EFL Cup last month, who created the game’s moment of controversy, rolling around the outside of Nacho Monreal in the 35th minuteand going down as the Spaniard reached across him. There were grounds for a penalty - Monreal had his arm on Valencia – but the player just went to earth too easily and Andre Marriner’s decision not to penalise was fair.

Mourinho’s reflections on all of this included a long list of why other teams have it easier than United, including the time “Maurice” Pochettino has had to assemble a Spurs side. (After Mourinho's talk of “Gary” Southgate on Friday, this is becoming a comedy sideshow.) When you're on the defensive, a convincing performance against Arsenal is triumph, whatever the final score.

Manchester United (4-2-3-1): De Gea; Valencia, Rojo, Jones, Darmian (Blind 64) ; Carrick, Herrera; Mata (Schneiderlin 85), Pogba, Martial (Rooney 53); Rashford.

Substitutes: Romero, Memphis, Rooney, Blind, Young.

Arsenal (4-2-3-1): Cech; Jenkinson (Oxlade-Chamberlain 84), Mustafi, Koscielny, Monreal; Coquelin (Xhaka 80), Ramsey; Walcott, Ozil, Mustafi; Sanchez.

Substitutes: Ospina, Gibbs, Paulista, Giroud, Iwobi.

Referee: A. Marriner

Join our new commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies

View comments