Sign up to Miguel Delaney’s Reading the Game newsletter sent straight to your inbox for free Sign up to Miguel’s Delaney’s free weekly newsletter
As it ended, so it begins again in earnest. Everton were the team who brought the curtain down on David Moyes, on that desperate day just under six months ago when the fool in a Grim Reaper costume waved an imitation scythe behind Moyes’ head. And Everton are the team whose arrival at Old Trafford on Sunday presages the real test of what Louis van Gaal has created from the Manchester United ruins his predecessor bequeathed him.
Though an international break punctures the next two weeks, the fixtures beginning on Sunday, which take in Chelsea and Manchester City with the relative sanctuary of West Bromwich Albion tucked in between, represent the first proper measure of whether United are ready to challenge the best again.
The extent of the upheaval has been astonishing for a club which was built by Sir Alex Ferguson on a creed of constancy and incremental change. If, as we might expect, Juan Mata resumes the No 10 role a suspended Wayne Rooney has vacated, only two of the players whom Moyes selected as he ran the gauntlet during the 2-0 defeat at Goodison 167 days ago will start on Sunday. Six of the 18 he selected that day are no longer with United.
Van Gaal was reminded on Friday that his own philosophy and that of the Everton manager, Roberto Martinez, are rather similar. He was asked when we might see a full 90 minutes of the kind of “total football” British football was given to expect from him. Van Gaal could give no indication. “A total 90 minutes you never know because it’s a question of time,” he said, confusingly, before returning to his recurrent theme: that it is United’s lack of discipline in possession, more than the state of their defence, which concerns him most. “The [opposition don’t make their goals] like we do out of building up, first, second, third and fourth phase,” he said. “That’s the difference.” Discipline is needed if United want to be “a big team,” he added.
It was not one of the great football press conferences. Van Gaal’s eccentric English is not helping us appreciate what he is setting out achieve. But the complexity is not limited to the sentence structure. It extends to what he wants the players to do: coaching them “not in their legs but in their brain; in brain power,” as he is wont to describe it.
Manchester United - the latest match in picturesShow all 124 1 /124Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Everton 3 Manchester United 0 Kevin Mirallas celebrates his match-winning goal with his team-mates.
Getty Images
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Everton 3 Manchester United 0 John Stones scored his first Everton goal as Manchester United were swept aside.
GETTY IMAGES
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Everton 3 Manchester United 0 James McCarthy puts the Toffees into an early lead.
Getty
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Manchester United 1 Arsenal 2 Nacho Monreal celebrates scoring the opening goal with Arsenal's English midfielder Alex Oxlade-Chamberlain
GETTY IMAGES
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Manchester United 1 Arsenal 2 Wayne Rooney equalises for Manchester United
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Manchester United 1 Arsenal 2 Wayne Rooney celebrates after making it 1-1
GETTY IMAGES
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Manchester United 1 Arsenal 2 Danny Welbeck celebrates after making it 2-1
GETTY IMAGES
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Manchester United 1 Arsenal 2 Angel Di Maria is shown a red card late in the FA Cup quarter-final tie
GETTY IMAGES
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Newcastle 0 Manchester United 1 Johnny Evans and Papiss Cisse come together
GETTY IMAGES
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Newcastle 0 Manchester United 1 De Gea makes a save
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Newcastle 0 Manchester United 1 Ashley Young scores the winner for Manchester United against Newcastle
GETTY IMAGES
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Newcastle 0 Manchester United 1 Ashley Young celebrates the winner for Manchester United against Newcastle
GETTY IMAGES
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Manchester United 2 Sunderland 0 Wayne Rooney scored again with a header - he hadn't scored in his previous eight Premier League matches.
Getty Images
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Manchester United 2 Sunderland 0 Wayne Rooney converts the penalty to put United in the lead.
Getty Images
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Manchester United 2 Sunderland 0 Wes Brown is sent-off to the protestations of the Sunderland players.
Getty Images
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Manchester United 2 Sunderland 0 John O'Shea fouls Radamel Falcao to give away a penalty - but Roger East believed Wes Brown had fouled him.
Getty Images
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Manchester United 2 Sunderland 0 British record signing Angel Di Maria was so bad he was substituted at half-time.
Getty Images
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Preston 1 Manchester United 3 Wayne Rooney wins a penalty after going down under the challenge of Thorsten Stuckmann
Getty Images
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Preston 1 Manchester United 3 Wayne Rooney goes down after being challenged by goalkeeper Thorsten Stuckmann
Getty Images
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Preston 1 Manchester United 3 Marouane Fellaini put the visitors back into the lead with a stabbed effort from inside the box
EPA
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Preston 1 Manchester United 3 Marouane Fellaini scores to put Manchester United 2-1 up
Getty Images
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Preston 1 Manchester United 3 Utd's Spanish midfielder Ander Herrera scored the equaliser
AP
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Preston 1 Manchester United 3 Scott Laird fired Preston into the lead with a deflected effort off David de Gea
EPA
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Manchester United 3 Burnley 1 United manager Louis van Gaal leaves the field - despite the win he was not impressed with the performance
GETTY IMAGES
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Manchester United 3 Burnley 1 Chris Smalling heads in his second goal of the game
GETTY IMAGES
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Manchester United 3 Burnley 1 Smalling opens the scoring
GETTY IMAGES
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures West Ham 1 Manchester United 1 Cheikhou Kouyate scores the opening goal
GETTY IMAGES
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures West Ham 1 Manchester United 1 Cheikhou Kouyate celebrates the opening goal
GETTY IMAGES
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures West Ham 1 Manchester United 1 Wayne Rooney during Manchester United's draw with West Ham
GETTY IMAGES
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures West Ham 1 Manchester United 1 Robin van Persie fails to score
GETTY IMAGES
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures West Ham 1 Manchester United 1 Daley Blind celebrates his late equaliser
GETTY IMAGES
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures QPR 0 Manchester United 2 James Wilson scored United's second to seal the win
Getty Images
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures QPR 0 Manchester United 2 Marouane Fellaini celebrates with his Manchester United team-mates
Getty Images
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures QPR 0 Manchester United 2 Marouane Fellaini scores to put United ahead
Getty Images
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures QPR 0 Manchester United 2 Rob Green keeps out an effort by Radamel Falcao
Getty Images
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Manchester United 0 Southampton 1 Juan Mata challenges for the ball with Fraser Forster during the Premier League match at Old Trafford
GETTY IMAGES
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Manchester United 0 Southampton 1 Manchester United defender Tyler Blackett can't reach the shot from Southampton's Serbian midfielder Dusan Tadic
GETTY IMAGES
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Manchester United 0 Southampton 1 Dusan Tadic celebrates the only goal at Old Trafford
GETTY IMAGES
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Stoke 1 Manchester United 1 Ryan Shawcross puts Stoke ahead
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Stoke 1 Manchester United 1 A close up of Van Gaal's notes during the match appeared to show the words 'stupid free-kick'
GETTY IMAGES
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Stoke 1 Manchester United 1 Radamel Falcao equalises for Manchester United
GETTY IMAGES
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Stoke 1 Manchester United 1 Falcao celebrates his goal
GETTY IMAGES
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Tottenham 0 Manchester United 0 Neither Manchester United or Tottenham could break the deadlock
GETTY IMAGES
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Tottenham 0 Manchester United 0 Hugo Lloris was in inspired form, denying a host of chances for Manchester United in the first half
GETTY IMAGES
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Tottenham 0 Manchester United 0 Spurs threatened to steal all three points late in the game but it ended goalless at White Hart Lane
GETTY IMAGES
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Manchester United 3 Newcastle 1 Papiss Cisse scores a consolation for Newcastle form the penalty spot
Getty Images
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Manchester United 3 Newcastle 1 Robin van Persie scores the third for Manchester United with a perfectly-guided header
Getty Images
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Manchester United 3 Newcastle 1 Wayne Rooney scores his and United's second of the game
Getty Images
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Manchester United 3 Newcastle 1 Rooney celebrates with striker-partner Radamel Falcao after the pair combine to put United ahead
Getty Images
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Manchester United 3 Newcastle 1 Wayne Rooney opens the scoring after turning in a Radamel Falcao cross
Getty Images
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Aston Villa 1 Manchester United 1 Manchester United players embrace striker Radamel Falcao after his goal
Getty Images
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Aston Villa 1 Manchester United 1 Radamel Falcao celebrates scoring the equaliser against Aston Villa
Getty Images
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Aston Villa 1 Manchester United 1 Christian Benteke celebrates scoring the opening goal against Manchester United
Getty Images
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Aston Villa 1 Manchester United 1 Christian Benteke scores a beautiful curling effort to put Aston Villa ahead
Getty Images
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Southampton 1 Manchester United 2 Robin van Persie put Manchester United ahead after capitalising on Jose Fonte's poor back pass
GETTY IMAGES
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Southampton 1 Manchester United 2 Pelle drew Saints level before the end of the first half
GETTY IMAGES
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Southampton 1 Manchester United 2 Van Persie celebrates his second goal of the match that turned out to be the winner
GETTY IMAGES
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Manchester United 2 Stoke 1 Juan Mata and Marcos Rojo celebrate United's second
GETTY IMAGES
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Manchester United 2 Stoke 1 Steven Nzonzi fires in the equaliser
GETTY IMAGES
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Manchester United 2 Stoke 1 Marouane Fellaini scores United's first goal of the game
GETTY IMAGES
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Manchester United 3 Hull 0 Chris Smalling scores United's opener after a goalmouth scramble
Getty Images
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Manchester United 3 Hull 0 Maroune Fellaini controls the ball as Curtis Davies looks on
Getty Images
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Manchester United 3 Hull 0 Juan Mata attempts to close down Ahmed Elmohamady as he passes
Getty Images
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Manchester United 3 Hull 0 The United players congratulate Robin van Persie after he scores a much-needed goal
Getty Images
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Manchester United 3 Hull 0 Wayne Rooney scored again, netting United's second
Getty Images
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Manchester United 3 Hull 0 Ashley Young stretches to control a high ball
Getty Images
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Manchester United 1 Crystal Palace 0 Michael Carrick started a game for the first time this season, in centre-midfield
Getty Images
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Manchester United 1 Crystal Palace 0 Robin van Persie again went scoreless - he has just three goals in 10 matches
Getty Images
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Manchester United 1 Crystal Palace 0 Angel Di Maria is crowded out by Yannick Bolasie and Adrian Mariappa
Getty Images
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Manchester United 1 Crystal Palace 0 Marouane Fellaini tries to win a header from a corner
Getty Images
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Manchester United 1 Crystal Palace 0 Substitute Juan Mata fires in a 25-yard strike, that took a deflection, to score the only goal of the game
Getty Images
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Manchester United 1 Crystal Palace 0 Mata and United players celebrate the goal
Getty Images
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Manchester City 1 Manchester United 0 Chris Smalling picks up a booking for blocking Joe Hart
Getty
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Manchester City 1 Manchester United 0 Later in the first half, Smalling was shown another and then sent off
Getty
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Manchester City 1 Manchester United 0 Kompany tackles Di Maria
Getty
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Manchester City 1 Manchester United 0 Sergio Aguero celebrates the only goal of the game
Getty
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Manchester United 1 Chelsea 1 Robin van Persie celebrates his late goal
GETTY IMAGES
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Manchester United 1 Chelsea 1 Robin van Persie scores the equalising goal in the final minute
GETTY IMAGES
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Manchester United 1 Chelsea 1 Referee Phil Dowd shows a red card to Chelsea's Branislav Ivanovic
GETTY IMAGES
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Manchester United 1 Chelsea 1 Didier Drogba celebrates his goal
GETTY IMAGES
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Manchester United 1 Chelsea 1 Didier Drogba heads in to give Chelsea the lead
GETTY IMAGES
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Manchester United 1 Chelsea 1 Thibaut Courtois saves an effort from Robin van Persie
GETTY IMAGES
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Manchester United 1 Chelsea 1 Didier Drogba shields the ball under pressure from United players
GETTY IMAGES
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Manchester United 1 Chelsea 1 The players make their way out onto the pitch at Old Trafford
GETTY IMAGES
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures West Brom 2 Manchester United 2 David De Gea could do nothing to stop Stephane Sessegnon's opener
GETTY IMAGES
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures West Brom 2 Manchester United 2 Sessegnon celebrates his early goal
GETTY IMAGES
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures West Brom 2 Manchester United 2 Marouane Fellaini celebrates bringing the scores level after his introduction at the break
GETTY IMAGES
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures West Brom 2 Manchester United 2 Berahino (right) put West Brom back in front. Picture left is Marcos Rojo, who was terrible throughout
GETTY IMAGES
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures West Brom 2 Manchester United 2 Daley Blind rescued a late point for Manchester United with a sweet finish
GETTY IMAGES
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Manchester United 2 Everton 1 Radamel Falcao celebrates scoring the winner
Getty Images
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Manchester United 2 Everton 1 Steven Naismith equalises for Everton
Getty Images
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Manchester United 2 Everton 1 Leighton Baines has his penalty saved
Getty Images
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Manchester United 2 Everton 1 Angel Di Maria celebrates opening the scoring
Getty Images
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Manchester United 2 West Ham 1 Wayne Rooney is shown a red card by Lee Mason
Getty Images
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Manchester United 2 West Ham 1 Wayne Rooney kicks out at Stewart Downing
Twitter
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Manchester United 2 West Ham 1 Diafra Sakho scores for West Ham as his header loops over Robin van Persie
Getty Images
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Manchester United 2 West Ham 1 Radamel Falcao has an effort on goal
Getty Images
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Manchester United 2 West Ham 1 Robin van Persie and Luke Shaw go for the double-high-five after the striker scores for United
Getty Images
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Manchester United 2 West Ham 1 Robin van Persie doubles United's lead against the Hammers
Getty Images
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Manchester United 2 West Ham 1 Wayne Rooney opens the scoring for United
Getty Images
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Leicester City 5 Manchester United 3 The remarkable comeback was complete after Leonardo Ulloa tucked in a penalty to make it 5-3. After Tyler Blackett had fouled Jamie Vardy in the box, getting sent off for his troubles, United's afternoon went from bad to worse.
Getty
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Leicester City 5 Manchester United 3 Livewire striker Jamie Vardy, who only broke into the Stocksbridge first team at the age of 21, put Leicester ahead late on.
Getty
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Leicester City 5 Manchester United 3 Despite Ander Herrera restoring United's three goal lead, Leicester just would not lie down. Following David Nugent's penalty, Esteban Cambiasso blasted City level.
GETTY IMAGES
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Leicester City 5 Manchester United 3 Leonardo Ulloa, a sensation since joining the Foxes, got his side back in the clash almost straight away.
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Leicester City 5 Manchester United 3 Angel di Maria, following Robin van Persie's opener, appeared to have put the game beyond Leicester. Stunning, outrageous chip over Kasper Schmeichel.
Getty
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Manchester United 4 QPR 0 Radamel Falcao makes his United debut
GETTY IMAGES
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Manchester United 4 QPR 0 Juan Mata completes the rout at Old Trafford
GETTY IMAGES
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Manchester United 4 QPR 0 Wayne Rooney celebrates the third
GETTY IMAGES
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Manchester United 4 QPR 0 Daley Blind and Sandro in action
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Manchester United 4 QPR 0 Angel Di Maria celebrates his first goal for United against QPR
GETTY IMAGES
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Burnley 0 Manchester United 0 Juan Mata is crowded out by Burnley defenders - indicative of the home side's effort and work rate for the full 90 minutes
Getty Images
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Burnley 0 Manchester United 0 Angel Di Maria made his United debut but couldn't influence the side and eventually limped off with an injury after 70 minutes
Getty Images
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Burnley 0 Manchester United 0 Manchester United players react after referee Chris Foy waved away what looked like a handball that would have been a penalty
Getty Images
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Burnley 0 Manchester United 0 Former United boss Sir Alex Ferguson looks on in anguish at Turf Moor as United failed to win again
Getty Images
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Burnley 0 Manchester United 0 Sean Dyche's team picked up their first point of the season with an excellent performance
Getty Images
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Burnley 0 Manchester United 0 Louis van Gaal is still winless as Manchester United manager after three matches in charge of the club
Getty Images
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Manchester United 1 Swansea 2 Louis van Gaal was not too disheartened at the full-time whistle, but he will know how much work lies ahead following his first defeat as United manager
Getty IMages
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Manchester United 1 Swansea 2 The two goalscorers Ki and Sigurdsson were left to celebrate at the end after inflicting United's first opening day defeat since 1972
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Manchester United 1 Swansea 2 Gylfi Sigurdsson stunned Old Trafford for a second time in the same afternoon as he restored Swansea's lead following a goal-mouth scramble
Getty Images
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Manchester United 1 Swansea 2 Gylfi Sigurdsson fires home the winner to secure Swansea a 2-1 win over Manchester United
Getty Images
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Manchester United 1 Swansea 2 Wayne Rooney managed to drag United level after he took advantage of a loose ball to smash home a close-range bicycle kick
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Manchester United 1 Swansea 2 Wayne Rooney acrobatically scores a bicycle kick to level the scores
Getty Images
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Manchester United 1 Swansea 2 Ki-Sung-Yeung celebrates after making it 1-0 to the visitors Swansea
Getty Images
Manchester United - the latest match in pictures Manchester United 1 Swansea 2 Tyler Blackett was handed a shock call-up by Louis van Gaal to start United's opening match against Swansea.
Getty Images
The players have talked in individual interviews about the challenges of performing this way. “He is saying, ‘You should be five yards to the right’,” Jonny Evans, one of the defensive absentees on Sunday, related in the summer. “We went through a video last night and I was 10 yards out. There are things you are doing on the pitch, and the whole team will be feeling the same, and you are thinking: ‘Am I in the right position?’ Then he will show you the video and you will know. It was certainly never like this with Sir Alex Ferguson…”
This is a philosophy which has brought phenomenal success across the continent. But somewhere amid the complexity it feels like United require some simplicity. To read Rio Ferdinand’s new autobiography this week was to take a step back into a more elementary – and rather divine – philosophy, when a manager’s simple, calculated pre-match gesture was enough to affect the course of a player’s afternoon.
“Coaches like Louis van Gaal talk about their ‘philosophy,’ “ Ferdinand writes. “Ferguson didn’t make such grand declarations, but under him we played fantastic attacking, winning football. He finished most of his team talks with: ‘Now go out and enjoy yourselves.’ It was never ‘Do this; do that’ because that can take away a player’s flair and imagination. He gave people the confidence to try things and didn’t mind if you made mistakes if you were trying the right things.”
Ferdinand’s appreciation of everything but England and Moyes creates some contradictions in his testimony. He seems equally to love the idea of Van Gaal’s complex Netherlands team talks in which, as Robin van Persie relates it to him, the manager reveals before the game: “This is how the game is going to play out … and everything happens exactly as he predicts...”
Yet it is the simple anecdotes of the Ferguson era which lights up the #2sides book. Ferguson evidently barely bothered with the opposition in team talks, Ferdinand relates. He concentrated on the psychological ruses which provide some of the gems. The defender tells a team bus story; of heading up to Newcastle when Craig Bellamy was playing well, when Ferguson walked past. “He flicked the top of my head, and went, ‘That Bellamy has been telling Mark Hughes that he’s going to destroy you. He reckons he’s quicker than you, that you’re not good enough to stop him any more,’” Ferdinand relates. “I sat there and thought ‘that cheeky little bastard.’ So I went out and played Bellamy off the pitch – he didn’t get a sniff all game.” It was Ferdinand walking past Ferguson when he boarded the coach for home. “Go and ask Mark Hughes what he’s got to say now,” he told him. Ferdinand reflects that was “all he needed to do: he’d press your buttons like that….”
Those who have played for Van Gaal elsewhere attest to his own powers of motivation, too, and there have been glimpses of the breakthrough that he warned would take three months. But they have just never lasted long. The rapid dip from cruise control to crisis has been a feature of the past month – most starkly in the 5-3 defeat at Leicester but also in the struggle to hold on to the 2-1 lead against West Ham, albeit with 10 men.
While Van Persie this week described “a bit of the Dutch thing” about everybody having input and “getting involved in the project” to ensure that “we are all pulling on the same rope,” Ferdinand reflected affectionately on what he described as the “wildebeest” culture among footballers – of everyone simply following the manager’s lead. Football is less complicated than it sounds. United look like they need some of the simple things back.
Join our commenting forum
Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies