Manchester United vs West Ham reaction: Once again Wayne Rooney is forgiven his reckless folly

The United captain was sent off in the victory at Old Trafford

Michael Calvin
Sunday 28 September 2014 18:25
Wayne Rooney is shown a red card by Lee Mason
Wayne Rooney is shown a red card by Lee Mason

What strange alchemy is at work when sane, sensible men continue to excuse Wayne Rooney from responsibility for his folly?

Roy Hodgson might have shifted uneasily in his seat in the Old Trafford directors’ box when Rooney was sent off for the sixth time in a turbulent career, an hour into a fortunate 2-1 win over West Ham, but he will continue to rely on his supposedly emblematic England captain.

Ed Woodward, Manchester United’s executive vice-chairman, will continue to consider Rooney’s £300,000 weekly wage fair recompense for his ability to shift shirts in Asia and other emerging markets.

Even Louis van Gaal, whose management style at United is proving to be an intriguing combination of pragmatism, intelligence, rigour and haughtiness, is prepared to place inordinate faith in the personal and professional qualities of his captain.

Rooney is likely to miss forthcoming matches against Everton, West Bromwich and Chelsea. His crude hack at Stewart Downing, which connected above the knee as he sprinted away from him midway in the West Ham half, was the instinctive act of a player who realises the pace of his youth is fading.

Van Gaal refused to countenance debate about whether Rooney has the temperament for leadership. He then reinforced his belief in him during a more measured analysis of a player he has elevated to the point of infallibility.

Rooney was the game’s most vibrant force while he remained on the pitch. He relished the freedom to operate behind the front two, and gave United a fifth-minute lead with a scooped volley, his 176th Premier League goal. Only Alan Shearer, with 260 and Andy Cole, with 187, have scored more since Sky invented football in 1992.

Van Gaal acknowledged: “Wayne will be a big miss, especially as he is playing at a good standard in his new role. He is a very important person, my captain. He is an example for the squad.”

Though Rooney’s most recent dismissal in the Premier League was against Fulham in March 2009, Saturday’s had echoes of the petulance which led to his dismissal for England in Montenegro in 2011.

He seems occasionally overwrought with the responsibilities of captaincy, and visibly channels the frustrations of a transitional team as neurotic at the back as it is dynamic going forward.

Set pieces continue to trigger mass panic, though Paddy McNair, the sixth Academy product given his debut by Van Gaal, acquitted himself excellently. The United manager confirmed Phil Jones, Chris Smalling and Jonny Evans will miss next Sunday’s home game against Everton.

Sam Allardyce’s frustration was rooted in the self-inflicted handicap of falling two goals behind to Robin van Persie’s 50th goal for United. West Ham exploited United’s inability to defend corners with Diafra Sakho’s fourth goal in as many games, but their anger at an offside call which prevented a late Kevin Nolan equaliser was misplaced.

Allardyce admitted a big chance had been wasted. “You can have a go at United because of their defence,” he said. “It was probably better for them to play with 10 men, because they covered their weaknesses up.

“Wayne’s red card was crazy. It was irresponsible. We all know lads trip up players. Normally there’s a little tap, a yellow card, and everyone gets on with it, but he gave him [Downing] a good boot. It was reckless, dangerous.”

The controversy was hardly the backcloth United expected to the 10th anniversary celebrations of Rooney’s move from Everton. The applause which greeted him as he walked prematurely to the dressing room was an illogical signal of his popularity.

He is likely to become the club’s all-time leading scorer, having scored 218 goals in 446 games for United. That leaves him 19 goals behind Denis Law and 31 from Sir Bobby Charlton’s record total. He is in the land of living legends.

Yet he is 28 and has not lost the truculence which defined his emergence as one of the last street footballers. He will always be one red mist away from a red card, no matter how hard his hagiographers try to convince us otherwise.

Register for free to continue reading

Registration is a free and easy way to support our truly independent journalism

By registering, you will also enjoy limited access to Premium articles, exclusive newsletters, commenting, and virtual events with our leading journalists

Already have an account? sign in

By clicking ‘Register’ you confirm that your data has been entered correctly and you have read and agree to our Terms of use, Cookie policy and Privacy notice.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy policy and Terms of service apply.

Join our new commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies


Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in