Sign up to the Independent's betting newsletter for the latest tips and offers Sign up to the Independent's betting newsletter
Referees’ chief Mike Riley has admitted that VAR has made four mistakes in the Premier League so far this season.
Former referee Riley, who is managing director of the officials body Professional Game Match Officials Limited (PGMOL) and responsible for the use of VAR in England, was speaking at the Premier League shareholders’ meeting in London on Thursday when he identified the incidents.
Riley highlighted two penalties that should have been awarded to Manchester City and West Ham respectively, and acknowledged that a Newcastle goal should have been given offside. He also told Premier League chairmen that a red card should have been shown during Bournemouth's match against Leicester .
The decision not to award City a penalty when David Silva was tripped in the box by Bournemouth midfielder Jefferson Lerma on August 25th was judged to be an error, as was the failure to give a spot-kick to Hammers forward Sebastien Haller after he was fouled by Norwich ’s Tom Trybull on August 31st.
On the same day, Fabian Schar ’s goal for Newcastle against Watford should have been ruled out for a handball by Isaac Hayden in the build-up, and Leicester midfielder Youri Tielemans should have been sent off after a challenge on Bournemouth’s Callum Wilson .
English football's most popular kitsShow all 92 1 /92English football's most popular kits English football's most popular kits English football's most popular kits The Love The Sales data have team have calculated the popularity of all 368 kits that have been released by the 91 English Football League clubs this season. Here are those 91 teams in order of popularity – with some surprising results. Which League Two team has released a set of kits even more popular than a high-flying Premier League club?
Getty
English football's most popular kits 91. Forest Green Rovers
Getty Images
English football's most popular kits 90. Bristol Rovers Lowest League One team.
Getty Images
English football's most popular kits 89. Peterborough United
CameraSport via Getty Images
English football's most popular kits 88. Morecambe
Getty
English football's most popular kits 87. Rochdale
Sunderland AFC via Getty Images
English football's most popular kits 86. Gillingham
Getty Images
English football's most popular kits 85. Crewe Alexander
Getty Images
English football's most popular kits 84. Plymouth Argyle
Getty Images
English football's most popular kits 83. Cheltenham Town
Getty Images
English football's most popular kits 82. Macclesfield Town
Getty Images
English football's most popular kits 81. Crawley Town
Action Images via Reuters
English football's most popular kits 80. Fleetwood Town
CameraSport via Getty Images
English football's most popular kits 79. Scunthorpe
Getty
English football's most popular kits 78. Shrewsbury Town
Getty Images
English football's most popular kits 77. Northampton Town
Arsenal FC via Getty Images
English football's most popular kits 76. Swindon Town
Getty Images
English football's most popular kits 75. Exeter City
Getty
English football's most popular kits 74. Oldham Athletic
CameraSport via Getty Images
English football's most popular kits 73. Walsall
Getty
English football's most popular kits 72. Rotherham United
Getty Images
English football's most popular kits 71. Southend United
CameraSport via Getty Images
English football's most popular kits 70. Mansfield Town
Getty
English football's most popular kits 69. Blackpool
CameraSport via Getty Images
English football's most popular kits 68. Wycombe Wanderers
CameraSport via Getty Images
English football's most popular kits 67. Carlisle United
Getty Images
English football's most popular kits 66. Grimsby Town
PA
English football's most popular kits 65. Barnsley Lowest Championship team.
Getty Images
English football's most popular kits 64. Colchester United
Action Images via Reuters
English football's most popular kits 63. Preston North End
CameraSport via Getty Images
English football's most popular kits 62. Doncaster Rovers
CameraSport via Getty Images
English football's most popular kits 61. Milton Keynes Dons
CameraSport via Getty Images
English football's most popular kits 60. Reading
Getty Images
English football's most popular kits 59. Bolton Wanderers
Action Images via Reuters
English football's most popular kits 58. Lincoln City
CameraSport via Getty Images
English football's most popular kits 57. Oxford United
Action Images via Reuters
English football's most popular kits 56. Brentford
PA
English football's most popular kits 55. AFC Wimbledon
Sunderland AFC via Getty Images
English football's most popular kits 54. Accrington Stanley
CameraSport via Getty Images
English football's most popular kits 53. Port Vale
Getty Images
English football's most popular kits 52. Wigan Athletic
CameraSport via Getty Images
English football's most popular kits 51. Tranmere Rovers
PA
English football's most popular kits 50. Ipswich Town
Sunderland AFC via Getty Images
English football's most popular kits 49. Newport County
Action Images via Reuters
English football's most popular kits 48. Luton Town
Getty Images
English football's most popular kits 47. Cambridge United
Getty Images
English football's most popular kits 46. Bradford City
PA
English football's most popular kits 45. Leyton Orient
PA
English football's most popular kits 44. Burton Albion
Action Images
English football's most popular kits 43. Fulham
Getty Images
English football's most popular kits 42. Coventry City
Getty Images
English football's most popular kits 41. Portsmouth
Getty Images
English football's most popular kits 40. Stevenage
Naomi Baker/Getty Images
English football's most popular kits 39. Swansea City
Getty Images
English football's most popular kits 38. Bournemouth Lowest Premier League team.
AFC Bournemouth via Getty Images
English football's most popular kits 37. Salford City Highest League Two team.
Getty Images
English football's most popular kits 36. West Bromwich Albion
PA
English football's most popular kits 35. Millwall
Action Images via Reuters
English football's most popular kits 34. Birmingham City
Getty Images
English football's most popular kits 33. Sheffield Wednesday
Getty Images
English football's most popular kits 32. Hull City
Getty Images
English football's most popular kits 31. Blackburn Rovers
CameraSport via Getty Images
English football's most popular kits 30. Queens Park Rangers
Getty Images
English football's most popular kits 29. Middlesbrough
Getty Images
English football's most popular kits 28. Brighton & Hove Albion
Getty Images
English football's most popular kits 27. Charlton Athletic
Getty
English football's most popular kits 26. Bristol City
Getty Images
English football's most popular kits 25. Burnley
CameraSport via Getty Images
English football's most popular kits 24. Cardiff City
Getty Images
English football's most popular kits 23. Southampton
Getty Images
English football's most popular kits 22. Watford
Action Images via Reuters
English football's most popular kits 21. Sheffield United
Getty Images
English football's most popular kits 20. Stoke City
CameraSport via Getty Images
English football's most popular kits 19. Sunderland Highest League One team.
Sunderland AFC via Getty Images
English football's most popular kits 18. Norwich City
EPA
English football's most popular kits 17. Crystal Palace
Getty Images
English football's most popular kits 16. Nottingham Forest
Getty Images
English football's most popular kits 15. Derby County
Getty Images
English football's most popular kits 14, Leicester City
PA
English football's most popular kits 13. Wolverhampton Wanderers
Getty Images
English football's most popular kits 12. Everton
Everton FC via Getty Images
English football's most popular kits 11. Leeds United
Getty Images
English football's most popular kits 10. West Ham United
Getty Images
English football's most popular kits 9. Newcastle United
PA
English football's most popular kits 8. Aston Villa
Aston Villa FC via Getty Images
English football's most popular kits 7. Tottenham Hotspur
Getty
English football's most popular kits 6. Huddersfield Town Highest Championship team.
Getty Images
English football's most popular kits 5. Chelsea
Chelsea FC via Getty Images
English football's most popular kits 4. Manchester City
REUTERS
English football's most popular kits 3. Manchester United
Getty Images
English football's most popular kits 2. Arsenal
Getty Images
English football's most popular kits 1. Liverpool The most popular set of kits in the country.
Liverpool FC via Getty Images
Riley told Sky Sports News that in the Silva, Haller and Tielemans incidents, it was indicative of the high bar the Premier League has set for overturning the decisions of on-field referees, but that he felt the “clear and obvious” bar had been reached in each of these cases.
“If you look at the four match rounds, 227 incidents have been checked,” he said.
“Out of that we’ve changed six decisions – we think we should have changed 10 in total.
“That gives you the scale of where VAR can help and add value to the game, but it also demonstrates that this is still about refereeing a game of Premier League football on the pitch.”
Additional reporting by PA
Join our commenting forum
Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies