England are through to the quarter-finals of the World Cup after beating Colombia 4-3 on penalties, having drawn 1-1 in regular and extra time.
From there, England went on to dominate the game and looked set for a first knockout win at the World Cup since 2006.
But a late Yerry Mina header, struck in the dying minutes of injury time, forced the game to extra-time. A nervous 30 minutes ensued, with both sides unable to find a breakthrough.
The dreaded penalty shootout followed, but Southgate's men defied the ghosts of their past to claim a first knockout win at the World Cup since 2006.
So how did the two teams fare? See the gallery below for our player ratings.
Join our new commenting forum
Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies