World Cup 2018: How cerebral Senegal are helping to dispel some of football’s laziest stereotypes

Senegal’s comprehensive win over Poland was a controlled performance, cerebral even, a victory from clearer heads rather than particularly any significant physical advantage

Nick Miller
Saturday 23 June 2018 16:15
Senegal fan critises Alan Sugar's racist tweet

At the start of this World Cup, Aliou Cisse and his Senegal players probably didn’t think they would have to deal with questions about a racist tweet from the presenter of the Apprentice. Or, if they did, probably not the UK Apprentice.

Alan Sugar’s apology for his suggestion that the Senegalese players sold sunglasses on the beach even reached the upper-echelons of the country’s government, quite satisfyingly given short shrift by an advisor to the Senegalese president - which frankly is a curious sentence to write.

Not that Senegal’s players themselves will have bothered about the whole thing too much. They’re presumably too busy being delighted at their start to the World Cup, having beaten Poland 2-1 in their first game. Of course, they were fortunate to a point with their goals, one a colossal deflection the other a smart finish after jumping on an accumulator of bone-headed errors.

But the scoreline flattered the Poles, who lost partly because they were limp, lifeless and as Robert Lewandowski admitted afterwards, didn’t really seem to be talking to each other. But they also lost because Senegal didn’t allow them to be anything else.

Cisse’s men outclassed and out-thought Poland. They were smarter in midfield, where Idrissa Gueye and Alfred N’Diaye gave Grzegorz Krychowiak the sort of afternoon that would make many a man jack this football caper in for something less stressful. They were sharper in attack, where M’Baye Niang’s nimble thinking to score the second goal contrasted starkly with the lumbering Lewandowski.

In short, it was a controlled performance, cerebral even, a victory from clearer heads rather than particularly any significant physical advantage.

And it was the sort of game that you might hope will dispel the standard stereotypes about African teams. You’ll be familiar with the language generally used as a default when discussing black players: primarily defined by strength, pace, power, general athleticism etc, rarely their skill or mental processes. If you’re somehow not cognisant of this sort of thing, on SB Nation Zito Madu gave a quick rundown of the sort of words deployed, including a bingo card of key phrases to watch out for.

At the absolute best it’s reductive, a lazy way of referring to a set of players you don’t know much about, at worst something far more sinister. Ideally these ideas and words should have been phased out long ago, but alas they remain. Hopefully though, particularly if they continue this way as they move through the tournament, Senegal’s performance might go some way to dispelling these stereotypes.

Perhaps that’s being too optimistic, but we’re often told that football can be a catalyst for wider things, that it can change society. Maybe it can alter this too. Particularly if they play in a similar fashion against Japan.

Where Senegal have been calm and controlled, Japan’s path to the World Cup has been a little more chaotic. Two months before the tournament began, manager Vahid Halilhodzic was ruthlessly dismissed, replaced by Akira Nishino as an “emergency measure”, an emphasis on attacking, rapid football apparently the motivation.

Senegal were superb against Poland and will fancy their chances of topping Group H

Halilhodzic steered Japan through a rather rocky qualification campaign, illustrated by fact the national FA assigned him a “go-between” when, following a defeat to the UAE, he banned the squad from smiling. Nevertheless, it was decided that relative chaos was preferable to him continuing, a move that looked from the outside at least like minor madness.

But after Japan beat Colombia in their opener, it perhaps indicates that serenity and steady planning is overrated. Spain haven’t seemed overly perturbed by their late coaching switch, and should Japan cause an upset by progressing it may prove that, in the World Cup, chaos is king and logic has no place here.

Register for free to continue reading

Registration is a free and easy way to support our truly independent journalism

By registering, you will also enjoy limited access to Premium articles, exclusive newsletters, commenting, and virtual events with our leading journalists

Already have an account? sign in

By clicking ‘Register’ you confirm that your data has been entered correctly and you have read and agree to our Terms of use, Cookie policy and Privacy notice.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy policy and Terms of service apply.

Join our new commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies


Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in