Stay up to date with notifications from The Independent

Notifications can be managed in browser preferences.

David Beckham kissing his daughter on the lips isn't ‘creepy’ – it's progressive. More fathers should be that affectionate

By pushing adult hangups and paranoia on children we are in fact making our kids less safe and less confident in their own bodily autonomy

Lucy Dixon
Wednesday 28 November 2018 16:45 GMT
Comments
Piers Morgan brands David Beckham 'weird' for kissing daughter Harper on the lips in photo

Piers Morgan has called David Beckham “weird” and “creepy” for kissing his seven-year-old daughter, Harper, on the lips – and he’s not the only one to think so. Social media is full commenters trying to make a parent feel guilty for the simple act of showing their child affection.

Having my six-year-old son George kiss me on the lips is one of the uncomplicated joys of life, and I plan to carry on doing it several times a day for as long as he wants to. Obviously the moment George decides he doesn’t want to smooch his mum on the lips then I will, reluctantly, stop. Because to me, George feeling comfortable expressing his feelings in this way is a sign of a healthy, loved little boy.

And it’s not just because I am a woman – we should be equally relaxed about dads showing physical affection towards their children too. Again, with the disclaimer that it is something the child wants to do. For decades we have wanted dads to loosen up and feel comfortable expressing their feelings. There’s clear evidence that our failure to accept male emotion leads to a culture of toxic masculinity which can in the most extreme circumstances cause an increase in mental health issues and even suicide. It can only be beneficial for men to be open and expressive about their feelings in this way. And when they do, and figures like Piers try to make it into something to feel ashamed of, we should remember that kissing is just a sign of a completely normal bond between father and child, something to be cherished and celebrated.

George has been enthusiastically kissing family members – male and female – on the lips since he was a toddler and I would hate to think of the message it gave him if any of us suddenly said we didn’t want him to. It’s how we greet each other after a long day at school and work, it’s how we say good morning and goodnight. These daily routines are made all the more precious with the addition of a kiss. Yes, I could just kiss him on the forehead or the cheek, but as long as he wants to plant a kiss firmly on my lips, then I’m all for it.

It’s worth examining what exactly these critics are alluding to by claiming this behaviour is “weird” and “creepy”. The implication is that there’s somehow a sexual undertone to a parent’s physical contact with their child, which is not just offensive but also damaging to children, whose behaviour should not be sexualised. What exactly do those who are against kissing suggest parents do instead? A nice, firm handshake? A fist bump? How much contact is too much? Maybe I should just start waving at George from across the other side of the room?

The age of the child seems to matter to most people who are shocked by this – they think that at seven years old, Harper Beckham is too old to engage in this behaviour. One arbitrary line seems to be that when a child starts school such contact should be stopped. No one seems to suggest that there’s anything wrong with kissing a baby or toddler on the lips – so exactly at what age should we start viewing parental contact as potentially sexualised?

Support free-thinking journalism and attend Independent events

A similar argument erupts every so often when a woman comes into public consciousness for breastfeeding a child for longer than society deems “acceptable”. Suddenly what used to be considered a laudable act of parenting becomes something worthy of criticism, and once again both the child and the mother are implicitly sexualised by the public in ways they never consented to. This needs to stop. By pushing adult hangups and paranoia on children we are in fact making our kids less safe and less confident in their own bodily autonomy.

I truly hope these ignorant and unfounded comments towards Beckham’s affection for his daughter does not make any parents – particularly dads – back off when their kids approach for a kiss for fear of judgement. A child growing up thinking it’s wrong to kiss a parent would be the real tragedy.

Join our commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies

Comments

Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in