Stay up to date with notifications from The Independent

Notifications can be managed in browser preferences.

Domestic abuse victims are being silenced in the general election

The timing of the Bill's delay is especially painful as campaign groups argue that incidents of domestic violence traditionally rocket during the festive period, fuelled by alcohol, financial pressures and family tensions

Katy Ward
Friday 01 November 2019 13:43 GMT
Comments
Tearful MPs break into round of applause after Rosie Duffield gives powerful address on domestic violence

Boris Johnson can consider Tuesday 29 October a landmark day, with MPs voting to support his 12 December General Election. Not surprisingly, the news took centre stage. But amid the political noise, it looks likely that one often marginalised group may again be silenced.

Outside the third sector, there has been little mention of the one in four women and one in six men who, according to charity Living Without Abuse, will be the victims of domestic abuse during their lifetime.

Yet these are the very individuals whose safety could be in jeopardy if the election timing puts a halt to desperately needed legislation.

The government had been on the verge of passing what had been described as the "landmark" domestic abuse bill. It was intended to clarify the law surrounding domestic violence and provide additional funding to support victims of physical, emotional and financial abuse, and other forms of controlling behaviour. With violence-related homicides at a high, the legislation seemed overdue.

Yet, in a sign of things to come, the bill was a casualty of Johnson's unlawful decision to prorogue the Commons in September, which essentially sent the bill to political purgatory.

And just as 29 October was a turning point for Boris Johnson (whether in a positive or negative fashion remains to be seen), the date also looks set to be a defining moment for the fate of the beleaguered bill, which made major headway and was potentially paralysed on the same day and in chambers meters apart.

If the Lords approves the election date (as it certainly will), parliament will be dissolved at one minute after midnight on 6 November, which would leave little over a week for the domestic violence bill to be ushered through.

Such a timeline makes this unlikely, given this administration's already colourful record where issues of intimidation are concerned. It was just five weeks ago that Johnson caused outrage with a rallying cry “to get Brexit done” in the name of murdered MP and ardent Remainer Jo Cox, while seemingly dismissing threats against MPs as "humbug".

The timing of the delay is especially painful as campaign groups such as Women's Aid and Refuge argue that incidents of domestic violence traditionally rocket during the festive period, fuelled by alcohol, financial pressures and family tensions.

It's no surprise then that legal process servers Diem Legal report a 30 per cent increase in non-molestation orders resulting from incidents over the festive period.

So what next? The worst-case scenario would be for the bill to fail when parliament enters "purdah" – the 25-day period before an election in which MPs abstain from passing major legislation.

Another possibility has been ventured by campaign organisations such as Safelives, which argue that the domestic abuse bill ought to be written into the election manifestos of all parties.

Even if the bill does go ahead, another question needs to be asked. Does the bill, in its current incarnation, go far enough to protect the vulnerable?

Any legislation to increase protection for victims is certainly welcome and there has been widespread praise for moves such as banning abusers from cross-examining victims in court.

Yet other campaign groups highlighted missed opportunities. For instance, as charity Surviving Economic Abuse points out, the draft bill could offer greater protection to individuals with an uncertain immigration status and make financial abuse a standalone crime.

Scrutinising the fine print of the bill reveals further shortcomings. Under current proposals, some £47,000 will be set aside towards police training to recognise and deal with financial abuse. This figure would equate to pennies for each of the 202,023 police workers employed in England and Wales as of March 2019.

Whether the bill passes, or is modified, is yet to be seen.

Support free-thinking journalism and attend Independent events

For the campaigners who had worked tirelessly to bring the bill to this stage, their efforts may perhaps feel as though they have died in a ditch.

Since the announcement of the general election, a number of campaigners who had been due to give further evidence to parliament on Halloween tweeted their frustration that the session had been cancelled.

Safelives is among those keen to keep focus on the victims, expressing its gratitude to "the survivors and pioneers who have shared their stories with us, and trusted us to help them make the case for change and to improve things for others who might find themselves in the same situation."

Now, victims of domestic violence are not only at the mercy of their partners’ violent moods – their futures will also be determined by the equally volatile mood of our politicians, many of whom are sure to preoccupied by thoughts of hitting the campaign trail, rather than how we can truly protect the most vulnerable people in our society.

Join our commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies

Comments

Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in