The Architect's Apprentice by Elif Shafak, book review: The domes of discovery

Elif Shafak's ambitious novel illuminates the scale and style of 16th-century Istanbul

James Runcie
Thursday 30 October 2014 15:30 GMT
Entirely his own vault: Selimiye Mosque, in Turkey, built by Mimar Sinan, 1575
Entirely his own vault: Selimiye Mosque, in Turkey, built by Mimar Sinan, 1575 (Alamy)

The fact that the great Turkish architect Mimar Sinan is not as widely known as Michelangelo says much about the bias of art history; it is a prejudice this novel attempts to redress. Some of his most glorious creations (more than 90 mosques, 50 schools, 20 mausoleums, six aqueducts, 10 bridges, 36 palaces and 48 hamams, or Turkish baths) are constructed in the course of an impressively ambitious story, giving it scale, style and silhouette.

Sinan is the historical architect of the title. His fictional apprentice is a 12-year old Indian boy who has arrived at the Topkapi Palace with a white elephant as a gift for the sultan. Through chance (and necessary fictional twists), the boy and the animal become indispensable, and these three characters are employed to tell not only the tale of their own lives but the story of Istanbul as it grows to become the dominant showcase of the Ottoman Empire.

As in Elif Shafak's previous work, traditional historical methods are upended. The writer is concerned not so much with the political machinations in the higher echelons of the sultanate, as with the sprawling world of its support system: those who have been left out of the official record. Istanbul, that great "honeysuckle of a city" with its "serpentine alleys, underground passages and closed bazaars" becomes, in many ways, the central character as labourers, prisoners, eunuchs, exiles, chancers, gypsies, drunks and whores struggle to survive its chaos.

Set between 1546 and 1632, the novel spans a period almost as long as Sinan's life (he died at the age of 99). The fact that people could live to such a great age seems miraculous in such a precarious and emotionally volatile place. Watching a procession making its way through the city, with his elephant at its decorative centre, the boy Jahan "could not believe how suddenly the public mood changed from sorrow to rejoicing, how quickly the river of their tears ran dry. If they moved between gloom and glee with such ease, did this mean they could pass from love to hatred just as effortlessly?"

There is, as one might expect, a love story, but Jahan's longing for the Sultan's daughter Mihrimah is appropriately forbidden, impossible, and of course doomed, despite moments of stolen tenderness. There are touching loyalties between master and pupil, the boy and his elephant, and a surprising level of affectionate support from a group of gypsies, but Shafak is no sentimentalist and any tendency towards the exotic is cut off with the same ruthlessness the sultan employs to dispatch his rivalrous brothers.

As a result, the body count is kept bracingly high and Shafak's success as a popular novelist gives her the confidence to pepper the narrative with frequent cliff-hangers to keep everything on the move. At its heart lie a boy, an elephant and an architect negotiating their survival as each building is constructed: the Shehzade, Mihrimah and Suleimaniye mosques; a bridge of the river Pruth; a restored Aqueduct. The raising of these structures, in which Jahan's elephant is continuously employed for both loading and transportation, gives the novel its shape and destiny; and the idea of the architect's dome becomes its central metaphor as the characters move under the vault of their creator's benevolent eye: "Alone in the mosque, only a dot in this vast expanse, Jahan could think only of the world as an enormous building site. While the master and the apprentices had been raising this mosque, the universe had been constructing their fate. Never before had he thought of God as an architect. Christians, Jews Muslims, Zoroastrians and people of myriad faiths and creeds lived under the same invisible dome. For the eye that could see, architecture was everywhere."

This is Shafak's most ambitious novel yet, and it is her best – told with a generous humanity that will surely realign attitudes both to the imaginative possibilities of fiction and to the constructed reality of the world around us.

Join our commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies


Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in