The popularisation of the umbrella genre “world music” since the 1980s has been problematic, to say the least.
On the plus side, it has brought much little-known music to international attention. On the other hand, its commercial pressures have had a homogenising effect on indigenous music, often ironing out its unique qualities to please the Western ear.
More seriously, although the term is logically meaningless – all music is “world music” – it has ironically helped to perpetuate the old fallacy that while Europe has “classical” music, everywhere else – with the exception perhaps of north India – has only “folk” music.
The myriad forms and styles of what marketing people call “world music” are lumped together in an undifferentiated mass, reflecting a mind-set which is still essentially colonial. We should simply drop this injurious and misleading term.
But since it still has credence in the higher echelons of Britain’s classical-music establishment, we need to combat its effects there too.
Look, for example, at the Proms programme: for several years there was a token “world music Prom” – usually consisting of rough stuff crudely amplified – but last year there wasn’t even that.
The days when Ravi Shankar could play a full-length raga Prom are long gone: throughout the summer the Royal Albert Hall becomes a bastion of European culture and its offshoots from around the world, and other cultures can go hang.
Yet Britain is a multi-ethnic country, with a multi-ethnic cultural mix: I have higher hopes of the new Proms director, David Pickard, but the last three all defended their policy by saying that their duty was to honour “our” classical music, which begs the question of who that cosy little “our” might refer to. If there were other classical musics out there, it was their implication that they were axiomatically inferior, and most definitely none of “our” business.
It was frustration with this insularity which drove me to devise a book to skewer it.
In The Other Classical Musics: Fifteen Great Traditions, published last year, I invited 15 leading authorities each to contribute a chapter celebrating the unique character of his or her classical form, and we included the music of Europe so that the playing-field could be kept level.
Nobody could deny that the Western tradition is by far the most multifarious and sophisticated of all – we have notation to thank for that – but, one message which came through loud and clear in the book was that Europe had absolutely no monopoly on sophistication.
Indeed, it was humbling to learn what dizzy intellectual feats are expected of classical musicians in Turkey, Thailand, and Java.
What has also come across, and with some poignancy, is that music with its roots deep in the past can wither and die. Think of Baghdad, which until the Bush-Blair invasion, had been home to the world’s most sophisticated artistry on the oud (the Middle Eastern lute).
Think of Aleppo: until revolution erupted in 2011, this great Syrian city had been the home of a refined classical song-form which had continued there in an unbroken tradition for eight hundred years. Aleppo now signifies nothing more than bombs, bloodshed, and destruction. These musics are under threat.
On Thursday, the Wigmore Hall in London will launch a new concert series – co-produced by the Aga Khan Music Initiative – which is also entitled “The Other Classical Musics”, and which will celebrate the music of the Muslim world.
The Qur’an may be ambiguous on the question of whether music should be permitted in Islam, but the fact is that music has blossomed in a thousand wonderful ways in Muslim societies, in an unbroken swathe of the globe stretching from Morocco to Indonesia.
And in the first concert, a group of string virtuosi from Afghanistan and north India will present the music of a region of Central Asia where styles and sounds from medieval Persia and the Mughal Empire blended in the 17th and 18th centuries, and are blending anew today.
Musicians in Afghanistan suffered terrible oppression in recent decades, as mujahideen rule gave way to that of the Taliban who burned instruments and persecuted their owners, to a point where almost all had to flee the country.
So it’s no surprise that of the five musicians performing at this Wigmore concert, three should be based in America, where they routinely collaborate with Western musicians, although their artistic orientation remains firmly in their native tradition.
Homayun Sakhi, the world’s leading exponent of the rubab – the lute which is Afghanistan’s national instrument – studied with his father to imbibe both the classical Hindustani raga tradition and also Afghan popular music; Rahul Sharma, who plays the santur hammered zither, studied with his father in Mumbai, and the meld between these players exactly mirrors the musical meld between their countries two centuries ago.
The players from Tajikistan – Mukhtor Muborakqadomov on the soothing setar lute, and Sirojiddin Juraev on the more abrasive dutar lute – still live in their remote mountain region, and span the folk-classical divide as all Tajik musicians do.
Salar Nader, whose tabla underscores the Central Asian instruments with a quintessentially Indian sound, is a busy collaborator in world percussion and jazz-fusion groups, and recently starred in an American theatrical adaptation of Khaled Hosseini’s novel The Kite Runner.
All these players are embracing the new with open arms. Sharma, who studied economics at university and came late to the santur, had composed on the Casio synthesiser as a child and absorbed influences from the Beatles, Pink Floyd, Sting, and John McLaughlin as well as from Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan, and he is now pushing his instrument in directions never before envisaged for it. “I’m still experimenting,” he says.
All of which helps to make this concert – and indeed this series, which later in the year will include the barnstorming Azerbaijani praise-singer Alim Qasimov, the Chinese pipa player Wu Man with Central Asian Uighur singer Sanubar Tursun, and musicians from Syria – a ground-breaking affair.
‘The Other Classical Musics’ at the Wigmore Hall: 10 March. ‘The Other Classical Musics: Fifteen Great Traditions’, edited by Michael Church, is published by the Boydell Press at £25.
Register for free to continue reading
Registration is a free and easy way to support our truly independent journalism
By registering, you will also enjoy limited access to Premium articles, exclusive newsletters, commenting, and virtual events with our leading journalists
Already have an account? sign in
Join our new commenting forum
Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies