Stay up to date with notifications from The Independent

Notifications can be managed in browser preferences.

Star Wars: The Force Awakens fan theory might make you look at it in a different light

Kylo and Rey's lightsaber fight feels very Sword in the Stone

Christopher Hooton
Monday 21 December 2015 09:56 GMT

Star Wars: The Force Awakens may have only been in cinemas a few days, but the fan theories have already begun.

There is a huge amount left unsaid and unexplained in the movie, and a lot for people to chew over in the many months before we get the next installment.

One proving particularly popular on Reddit this week though isn't about a specific character's motives or origin, but the film's echoing of a very classic story (no, not Star Wars Episode IV: A New Hope, though it definitely does ape that one too).

The theory from user Fantoman explains how the movie managed a more old-fashioned feel despite being set in a futuristic universe, and imagines the shape of Rey's story arc.

Here it is in full with their linked out pictures (spoilers, obviously):

"I believe the real purpose of Kylo's saber is for the medieval imagery to subconsciously remind us of Arthurian tales. The tri-sword obviously resembles a medieval broadsword.

On top of that, Kylo also wears more of a tunic than robes like we've seen in the past, his cape on one shoulder is also reminiscent of what we see in some medieval movies. He even has long curly hair like Jon Snow. Kylo is basically a Mordred/Sherriff of Nottingham type character.

His helmet is much like that of a black knight...

Maz Kanata is in a castle...

...Which is decorated with banners much like in medieval times...

...and we see lots of huge stone blocks...

The appearance is very simlar to something we would see in England.

Stormtroopers have shields. Kylo has his own Knights (like an evil Knights of the Round Table)...

...Which wear medieval-style armor and helmets.

Phasma has metallic armor like a knight.

The sword fighting is now more medieval style, with large swings and heavy hits. Even most of the places they go are like European settings, with normal forests and lakes. You could imagine a LOTR or Game of Thrones battle happening in front of Maz's castle, in the snowy woods, or Luke's island. Luke of course, would be Merlin.

So then we have Rey, who is basically a poor peasant. She comes along and basically takes what Kylo believes is his birthright...

He thinks his bloodline grants him the right to rule the galaxy like Vader because he is Vader's grandson. He probably had Snoke filling him with ideas of grandeur throughout his youth... an evil Morgana/Morgan le Fay (Snoke was even supposed to be a woman at one point).

But Rey is the true heir to Skywalker's legacy, like Arthur (even with a British accent!). She was hidden when the Empire/Kingdom fell apart, but now has returned from obscurity to take her place.

Maz tells her the sword belonged to Vader and Luke, and now it calls to her - Maz bestows the sword that she has been saving all this time to Rey like the Lady of the Lake.

Kylo sees the sword later and says it belongs to him. But then they have a sword in the stone moment and he can't pull it to himself. We are surprised when it suddenly flies out past him and to Rey instead. The sword chose her.

The sword is much like Excalibur, a legendary sword with great importance and symbolizes Rey as the true successor."

Join our commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies


Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in