Stay up to date with notifications from The Independent

Notifications can be managed in browser preferences.

Good People, theatre review: Imelda Staunton magnificent as tough single mother

Hampstead Theatre, London

Paul Taylor
Thursday 06 March 2014 12:38 GMT
Imelda Staunton and June Watson in 'Good People'
Imelda Staunton and June Watson in 'Good People' (Johan Persson)

American dramatist David Lindsay-Abaire first sprang to our attention on this side of the Atlantic when, in 2004, Sam Mendes chose to launch a new production company with Fuddy Meers, a relentlessly wacky but soft-centred farce about an amnesiac stroke-victim. Unimpressed by that, I approached Good People with fairly low expectations, figuring that it would be another of those US hits that are untransportable to these shores.

But the piece, receiving its UK premiere in a superlatively cast production that's directed with mordant aplomb by Jonathan Kent, is a reproof to my pessimism. True, in the final analysis, I think the play is flawed by sentimentality and an over-loading of the dice. But it asks provocative questions about the American class system and about the role that luck plays in separating the haves from the have-nots and it does so through the kind of artfully mortifying social comedy we associate with the author's compatriots: Bruce (Clybourne Park) Norris and Neil LaBute.

The setting is “Southie”, a downtrodden, blue-collar neighbourhood in South Boston which Lindsay-Abaire himself partly escaped by winning a day-boy scholarship to a prestigious private school. Imelda Staunton is magnificent as Margie, a tough, sharp-tongued single-mother with a severely handicapped adult daughter whom we first see begging to keep her dead-end job as a cashier at a dollar-store. She's chronically late not because she's feckless but because of the unreliability of the baby-sitter. Desperate for work, she hears that Mikey, a high-school boyfriend who has made good as a fertility doctor, is back in town and decides to appeal to him.

He is not overjoyed to see her. The moneyed medic's smugness and defensiveness (beautifully caught by Lloyd Owen) rile her into taunting him that he's “lace curtain Irish”. Stung by this, he invites her to party which is then genuinely cancelled. Offended at what she perceives to be a slight, Margie crashes his sleek Chestnut Hill home where she's initially mistaken for a caterer by Mikey's glamorous, upper-middle-class African-American spouse (excellent Angel Coulby). The resulting scene is excruciatingly funny (“How's the wine?” asks the rigidly reluctant host; “How the fuck would I know?” she quips) with the maritally disaffected wife falling over herself to be gracious and egging Margie on to tell stories about Mikey's past that cast doubt on his determined belief that he rose by sheer desert that she is wretched because of bad choices.

The eloquent expression “making your luck” nicely captures both the unfairness of life's lottery and the necessity of creative effort. Good People is in danger of simplifying this through polarisation – revealing the doctor to be an ungrateful comprehensive shit and positing in Margie a salt-of-the-earth heroine whose problems stem from misplaced self-sacrifice and whose belated surge of vindictive resentment is not as ugly as it seems. The latter's pluck, combative humour, mischief and those moments when the resilience falters and the desolation throws through are communicated with a lovely unsentimental warmth, though, in Staunton's richly convincing and rounded portrayal.

To April 5; 0207 722 9301

Join our commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies


Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in