My Brilliant Friend review, National Theatre: A lively, generous tale of femininity and violence

In this five-hour adaptation of Elena Ferrante’s Neapolitan novels, director Melly Still manages to avoid gratuity 

Alexandra Pollard
Wednesday 27 November 2019 17:53
Comments
Niamh Cusack and Catherine McCormack shine in this humane exploration of female friendship
Niamh Cusack and Catherine McCormack shine in this humane exploration of female friendship

Theories abound as to the identity of Elena Ferrante. Thanks to the Neapolitan novels author’s aversion to publicity, some believe her to be the alter-ego of male writer Domenico Starnone. April De Angelis – who has adapted Ferrante’s novels into a lively, generous four-part play – doesn’t buy it. “It’s so female,” she said of the story. “The passions, the menstruation, and f***ing from a woman’s point of view. Women live secret lives and they are never allowed into the big narrative of what it means to be human.”

This five-hour National Theatre production – which has transferred, with a few tweaks, from The Rose in Kingston – deftly brings those secret lives into the open. Growing up in 1950s Naples, Lila and Lenu start their friendship with a betrayal. Lila (Catherine McCormack), headstrong and fearless, persuades Lenu (Niamh Cusack) to trade dolls, and then coldly drops Lenu’s through a dark grate. When Lenu instinctively does the same, Lila leads her by the hand to retrieve them.

That formative meeting sets the tone for a tense, tentative friendship. Theirs is a potent melting pot of love, jealousy, loyalty and resentment, and so it remains for the next several decades, as Mafia mobs battle for control of the Naples neighbourhood, and fascism flourishes around them.

It all takes place on an imaginatively minimalist set: concrete, Penrose stairs are the centrepiece; cars are suggested by two large headlights or the carefully directed blast of a fan; the sea is several billowing cerulean sheets.

McCormack, Cusack and the rest of the cast play their characters from early childhood into old age. Adults as children can be distracting – even disturbing – but the performances here are subtle, their youth relayed through gutsiness and naivety, not through high-pitched voices or childish physicality.

The fiercely intelligent Lila rails against the constraints of her class and her gender, spitting in people’s faces and holding knives to older men’s throats. She is desperate to escape this “s*** hole”, plotting to write her way out just like her hero Louisa May Alcott (there’s a sweet, funny scene in which she and Lenu act out the emotional climax of Little Women). “From now on, whatever we do, we do together and on purpose,” she tells Lenu. “Because they’ll blame us anyway.”

But in the end, Lenu is the only one with the means to escape – her parents allow her to stay in school, while Lila, the brightest of the two with an original mind that Lenu often copies, must leave to work in her father’s shoe shop.

McCormack is magnificent at conveying Lila’s misdirected anger – a rage nurtured by years of disappointment, oppression and abuse. Her performance reminds me of what the musician Mitski once said about feminine art: “I mean feminine in the violent sense,” she explained. “Desiring, but not being able to define your desire, wanting power but being powerless and blaming it on yourself, or just hurting yourself as a way to let out the aggression in you. It’s a lot of pent-up anger or desire without a socially acceptable outlet.” My Brilliant Friend is a story of femininity, violence, and the unpalatable ways those two things collide.

McCormack and Ben Turner in ‘My Brilliant Friend’

During the most egregious acts of violence, though, director Melly Still manages to avoid gratuity. Twice, a replica of Lila’s dress is lifted above her head mid-scene. She steps back and watches on, as her disembodied outfit is first hurled down a flight of stairs and then later, sexually assaulted. It works well; not least because it mirrors the way women often dissociate from the atrocities done to them.

That Still has the actors using their own accents is also a wise decision. Cusack, who is remarkable as a woman grappling with being unremarkable, speaks in her gentle Irish burr; McCormack is from Surrey; there are Geordies, Scousers and Mancunians, too. Not once do I doubt that they all grew up in the same scrappy neighbourhood.

In the fourth part, the use of colourful, lycra puppets as Lila and Lenu’s two daughters doesn’t quite work, and the pace dips a little. Having zipped along with such spirit and verve, the production fizzles out just a little in its final part.

But for the most part, this is a humane exploration of female friendship, class, and social progress. “Until we write our own stories, women won’t know who we are,” says Lenu. This brings us a little closer.

To 22 February 2020

Register for free to continue reading

Registration is a free and easy way to support our truly independent journalism

By registering, you will also enjoy limited access to Premium articles, exclusive newsletters, commenting, and virtual events with our leading journalists

Already have an account? sign in

By clicking ‘Register’ you confirm that your data has been entered correctly and you have read and agree to our Terms of use, Cookie policy and Privacy notice.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy policy and Terms of service apply.

Join our new commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies

Comments

Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in