Michael Gove sparks anger after appearing to backtrack over post-Brexit live animal export ban

Caroline Lucas accuses government of delivering Brexit 'built on lies' 

Tom Embury-Dennis
Wednesday 12 September 2018 16:58 BST
The Government votes against incorporating animal welfare laws from the EU into British law

The government has appeared to backtrack on a key post-Brexit suggestion to ban the export of live animals for slaughter, angering politicians and animal rights campaigners.

Michael Gove launched a consultation into a ban earlier this year, promising to deliver policies that “respect and care” animals and raising the prospect of ending the export of thousands of live farm animals to mainland Europe.

But on Wednesday the environment secretary would only commit to “restrictions” on the practice.

“I am minded to restrict them yes, and I’m looking at the evidence to see how we can make appropriate, or take appropriate steps,” Mr Gove told BBC Radio 4’s Today programme.

Asked directly whether he was still minded to ban it, he said: “I’m minded to take every step we can in order to ensure that we restrict animal exports and that we safeguard animal welfare.”

Pressed on the issue, the environment secretary insisted “all options are on the table”, without ever using the word “ban”.

Sheep forced into dire conditions aboard transit ship to Middle East

Caroline Lucas, MP and former leader of the Green Party, accused the Tories of delivering a Brexit “built on lies”.

“Brexiteers promised a ban on live animal exports,” she wrote on Twitter. “Now Michael Gove says it won’t happen.

“This Tory Brexit is built on lies.”

James West, senior policy manager at Compassion in World Farming, said he was “concerned” Mr Gove appeared to be “backtracking on his live export commitment”.

“On numerous occasions, Michael Gove has spoken about how the government are considering stopping live exports for slaughter,” he said. ”This morning, when pressed, he repeatedly used the word ‘restrict’. The campaign to stop live exports is one that has run for many years, and an issue people feel very strongly about.

“It will be a major disappointment to the majority of British citizens if the government abandon their plans.”

Labour's shadow environment minister, David Drew, said: “Michael Gove is back pedalling on his promise to ban live exports. We are demanding that Michael Gove now clarifies the government’s position on banning live exports.”

A Conservative Party spokesperson told The Independent it had "consistently" said it will control live animal experts after Brexit.

“Earlier this year we called for evidence on restricting and potentially banning live exports. As the environment secretary said, all options are on the table and a ban remains a possibility," the spokesperson added.

“Labour’s hypocrisy is breathtaking. Unlike the Conservatives, their manifesto had nothing to say on this vital issue and now they are desperately playing catch-up.”

Official figures show that each year at least 4,000 sheep are transported from the UK to Europe for slaughter, with an estimated 6,000 calves exported from Northern Ireland, despite government documents admitting “all forms of transport may have negative effects on the animal’s welfare”.

Current European single market rules currently prevent the UK from banning the live export of animals, which accounts for only a small proportion of Britain’s £2.4bn trade in meat and livestock with the EU.

Campaigners celebrated when in April, Mr Gove held a public consultation on the proposed live export ban. They had battled for years to highlight the cramped, unnatural conditions on export trucks during long journeys with insufficient water in often sweltering temperatures.

Mr Gove’s about-turn came after environment and food officials asked advisers on the Farm Animal Welfare Committee (FAWC) to review the conditions animals are subjected to during long-distance live transport and to make recommendations on improving them.

Campaigners said this raised suspicions the government may be backing away from a ban on the “cruel and completely unnecessary” practice.

Ministers are also facing pressure from the Scottish government, which opposes a ban. Scottish farmers regularly send young, unweaned calves to countries such as Spain on journeys lasting 100 hours or more, and Scotland’s rural economy secretary Fergus Ewing says a ban would cause “substantial harm” to the nation’s livestock sector.

Join our commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies


Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in