Patients accessing the site were sent adverts and malware
Patients accessing the site were sent adverts and malware

Thousands of visitors the the NHS Choices site bombarded with malware after a coding error let a Czech hacker in by the back door


Andrew Johnson
Monday 03 February 2014 17:22

Thousands of patients trying to access health advice on the NHS Choices website were bombarded with adverts and malware – potentially stealing personal information from their computers – due to a coding error yesterday.

Users of the site posted links to hundreds of pages which had caused the problems over Sunday night and Monday morning - although the issue is now fixed.

One user, called Muzzers, wrote on the social website Reddit: “While attempting to access flu shot information I stumbled upon a page which redirected me to an advertisement. Digging a bit deeper I found hundreds more pages which redirect to either an advertisement or malware infested page.”

About 800 pages were thought to be affected.

The Health and Social Care Information Centre, which runs the site, was quick to downplay the damage, claiming that the site had not been compromised by a hacker.

A spokeswoman said a simple misplaced letter s in a domain name embedded in the code was responsible. A developer had typed instead of

The spokeswoman added that on Sunday night someone in the Czech Republic registered the misspelled domain name meaning patients were redirected to a rogue site from which the adverts and malware were sent.

In a statement the HSCIC said: “An internal coding error has caused an incorrect re-direct on some pages on NHS Choices since Sunday evening. Routine security checks alerted us to this problem on Monday morning at which point we identified the problem and corrected the code.

“We are now ‘flushing through’ this correction to ensure that the code on all affected pages is amended and expect this to be completed this afternoon.

“We can confirm that this problem has arisen due to an internal coding error and that NHS Choices has not been maliciously attacked.

The spokeswoman also stressed that no patient data was at risk and that they were carrying out a “thorough and detailed analysis to ensure that a full code review is undertaken and steps put in place to ensure no reoccurrence".

The HSCIC spokeswoman added: "NHS Choices has conducted an investigation of the adverts that some users were taken to and found nothing malicious on the initial adverts that came up. However, as an additional precaution we intend to supplement our usage information with 'cyber smart' guidelines."

Internet security expert Graham Cluley cast doubt on the official explanation however, and said that anyone who had inadvertently downloaded malware could be at risk from viruses or having the personal information stored on their hard drives accessed.

“I’m surprised by that explanation,” he said. “What often happens is that a hacker will find a weak point and inject a piece of code to exploit it, and set up a domain name. If the explanation is correct then whoever registered the domain name in the Czech Republic must have scanned the code, which few do, or registered numerous sites in the hope of getting lucky. Also, programmers tend to cut and paste domain names rather than type them out, which is laborious. Either way, there is a normally a through audit to spot these things and make sure links work before going live.

He added: “More importantly, what has been compromised is people’s computers. Anyone who used that site may have had malware injected on to their home computers that is able to access their personal information. So there should be warnings that anyone who accessed the rogue site could have problems. Today the NHS should be about computer health and that computers could be compromised.”

Mr Cluley also said that any crime committed would be an offence against the home user by the person in the Czech Republic.

Join our new commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies

View comments