Surrogacy mother wins maternity leave ruling in EU court

Decision could pave way for others to get same benefits as birth and adoptive parents

Charlotte McDonald-Gibson
Thursday 26 September 2013 23:23 BST
Parents choosing surrogacy should be permitted the same rights as birth and adoptive parents
Parents choosing surrogacy should be permitted the same rights as birth and adoptive parents (Rex)

A British woman who had a child through a surrogate mother was entitled to paid maternity leave, the European Court of Justice has advised, in a legal opinion that could open the doors for other parents in the UK to get the same benefits. Women who adopt a child in Britain are entitled to the same statutory maternity leave as birth parents, but families who choose to use a surrogate mother to carry their baby are not covered by current legislation.

The woman, who is from Newcastle and is referred to in court proceedings as CD, had a baby through a surrogate mother last year using sperm from her partner. She took over care of the baby and began breastfeeding within an hour of the birth.

When she discovered that her employer was not obliged to give her paid maternity leave, she took them to court, which asked the Court of Justice of the European Union in Luxembourg to decide whether she was entitled to maternity rights under EU law.

Juliane Kokott, the court’s Advocate General, wrote that as surrogacy is legal in Britain, people who choose to go down that path should be permitted the same rights as birth and adoptive parents.

Even if the mother does not breastfeed the child, she “has the right to receive maternity leave provided for under EU law after the birth of the child in any event where she takes the child into her care following birth”.

However, Ms Kokott added that if the woman who gives birth to the child also takes maternity leave, that must be deducted from the total leave taken by the mother who is assuming legal guardianship of the child. Under EU law, new mothers are entitled to 14 weeks’ paid leave.

Ms Kokott’s opinion will now be forwarded for approval by the court, which usually follows the recommendations of its Advocate Generals.

Harriet Bowtell, an employment lawyer from Slater & Gordon, said it was “fantastic news” for new mothers of surrogate babies. If the EU court accepted the recommendation, she said, amendments would have to be made to the UK’s equality act.

In a similar case, however, another Advocate General with the EU court advised that an Irish woman who had had a child through a surrogate in the US was not entitled to maternity leave.

That case was being brought on the grounds of gender and disability discrimination, while CD’s case was challenged under the EU Pregnant Workers’ Directive.

Join our commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies


Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in