Italian health chief quit over government’s 'anti-scientific' vaccination stance

'It reminds me of Donald Trump’s recommendation to no longer use the term ‘evidence-based' says Walter Ricciardi of populist claims which led to his resignation before Christmas

Alex Matthews-King
Health Correspondent
Saturday 05 January 2019 16:45 GMT
Deputy prime minister Matteo Salvini singled out for particular criticism over comments about excessive vaccines harming children
Deputy prime minister Matteo Salvini singled out for particular criticism over comments about excessive vaccines harming children (Rex Features)

The former head of Italy’s top medical research board has said he left over the government’s “anti-scientific” stance on vital issues like vaccination.

Walter Ricciardi likened some Italian ministers' views to Donald Trump's populist disdain for evidence when he quit as directory of the National Institute of Health (ISS) last month.

Elections in March 2018 brought spurious health claims to the fore, with officials at the top of government claiming vaccines are harming children and that migrants are spreading disease.

Italy’s populist Five Star Movement came out on top in last year’s elections and went into coalition with the far-right Northern League.

Professor Ricciardi reserved particular scorn for deputy prime minister and head of the League, Matteo Salvini, in a scathing interview with Italian newspaper Corriere della Sera.

“It’s clear that when the deputy prime minister says that he, as a father, believes there are too many vaccines, and that they are useless and dangerous, that it’s not just an unscientific approach – it’s anti-scientific,” he said.

In 2017 Professor Ricciardi had been among the senior advocates of legislation under the previous centre-left government which made child vaccinations for conditions like measles compulsory.

But the new government overturned the measure in August, despite Italy being one of the hotspots of a record-breaking European measles outbreak which saw 60,000 cases of the life-threatening condition last year – double rates in 2017.

The charged issue of migration and refugees fleeing to Europe across the Mediterranean Sea has also emboldened the populist rhetoric on immigration.

Officials recently seized a rescue ship working to prevent migrant vessels from drowning on the grounds that it had not disclosed migrant clothing which posed a health risk – something charities called “ridiculous”.

Professor Ricciardi said he had a good working relationship with the government’s minister for health, Giulia Grillo, no relation to the movement’s founder Beppe Grillo, and confirmed her position that the government had not sought to influence the scientific direction of the ISS.

He added that in four and a half years ha had achieved many of the goals he had first set in the role, but warned the populist shift was endangering public health.

Andrew Wakefield describes his relationship with Donald Trump

“Saying repeatedly that migrants carry diseases is groundless and it forces self-censorship in order not to contradict the political line," Professor Ricciardi said. “Yet these are key issues for health prevention and public health.”

“All this reminds me of Donald Trump’s recommendation to the National Institutes of Health Institute to no longer use the term ‘evidence-based’,” he said. “It’s an approach taken by populists, who have great difficulty in interacting with science.”

The US president has repeatedly tweeted about a link between vaccines and autism and met with the father of the modern anti-vaccination movement, discredited doctor Andrew Wakefield.

Join our commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies


Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in