Who said it: Joseph Stalin or Oliver Cromwell?


Felicity Morse
Friday 20 December 2013 10:54 GMT
Do you think there is 'no real difference' between the leaders?
Do you think there is 'no real difference' between the leaders?

Vladimir Putin has compared Joseph Stalin with 17th century Roundhead leader Oliver Cromwell, saying there was no difference between the two men.

“What’s the real difference between Cromwell and Stalin? None whatsoever,” Mr Putin said on Thursday after he was asked about a monument to Stalin being put up in Moscow.

Stalin was one of the most brutal and murderous dictators in history. He was responsible for the deaths of millions of people and the suffering of many more whilst leader of the Soviet Union. As many as 20 million people are estimated to have died as a direct result of his policies: that’s on top of the 20 million Soviet troops and civilians who died in the second world war.

Oliver Cromwell is a divisive figure mainly due to his Irish campaign, in which his troops massacred hundreds of thousands of Catholic soldiers and civilians. As part of this brutal campaign, men, women and children were deported to the West Indies and sold into slavery. However historians debate over whether Cromwell ordered such atrocities. He was back in England when many of the Irish Catholics were deported and some historians argue that the slaughter of civilians occurred under the command of other generals and not at Cromwell’s behest.

There is no argument that the scale of the carnage differs completely. “One death is a tragedy; one million is a statistic” is one of Stalin’s most famous quotes. Can you tell who said what?

Join our commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies


Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in