Dinosaurs, the giraffes of their day

Science Editor,Steve Connor
Sunday 23 October 2011 08:42

Ever since palaeontologists pieced together the many bones of lumbering sauropods they have argued about how these largest of dinosaurs would have held their immensely long necks.

Now the debate has taken another turn with a study suggesting that museums have got it wrong when they depict sauropods extending their long necks out in front of their huge bodies. New research suggests that sauropods held their necks in an upright posture like a swan or giraffe, rather than in the near-horizontal position depicted by the famous diplodocus in the Great Hall of the Natural History Museum in London.

"We have now discovered that the way the dinosaur is depicted in the iconic model at the Natural History Museum is not how it would have habitually held its neck," said Mike Taylor of Portsmouth University. After studying living animals and comparing their necks to those of the sauropods, Dr Taylor and his colleagues concluded that the dinosaurs could have held their heads high. "We can't just study fossil bones," he said. "Dinosaurs were living animals and... We need to look at animals that are alive today. Unless sauropods carried their heads and necks differently from every living vertebrate, we have to assume that the base of their neck was curved strongly upwards."

But Paul Barrett, an expert at the Natural History Museum, dismissed the suggestion that exhibits will have to be changed. He said the upright necks theory "is not a new idea".

Join our new commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies

View comments