DWP admits it hasn’t assessed impact of closing 78 local jobcentres despite announcing policy last month

Ministers have denied Google MPs was used to draw up a list of potential closures

Jon Stone
Political Correspondent
Monday 13 February 2017 12:19 GMT
Unemployed people may have to travel significantly further to claim benefits
Unemployed people may have to travel significantly further to claim benefits

The Department for Work and Pensions has been accused of taking a “cavalier attitude” to closing 78 local jobcentres across the country after it emerged it had not even conducted an impact assessment of the policy.

Ministers denied that the sites to be closed were chosen using Google Maps after many MPs, including a number of Conservatives, raised concerns about the plans in Parliament at the end of January.

Now Ministers have admitted that the key statutory exercise has not yet been conducted. The Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) said the buildings are not being used to their full capacity and that it can conduct impact assessments later.

Some jobseekers will have to travel significantly further to sign on every fortnight after the closures, as they are required to do so by law. Being late for a jobcentre appointment can cause a person to be stripped of their £73-a-week unemployment benefit.

Louise Haigh, the Labour MP for Sheffield Heeley, said the policy will hurt the most vulnerable, after being told by DWP minister Damian Hinds that the Government could not provide figures on how many people on Employment and Support Allowance – a key disability benefit – would be affected by the closer of a jobcentre in her constituency.

“To make a decision like this without even conducting an impact assessment demonstrates the cavalier attitude of this Government towards the most vulnerable,” she told The Independent.

“If they don’t even know who the closures will impact on, whether the disabled or those who are digitally excluded, how can they possibly say people will get the support they need?

“Yet again we are seeing this Government cutting corners in areas which can ill afford to be neglected.”

The jobcentre in Ms Haigh’s constituency, on Eastern Avenue, is set to be closed and her constituents will have to travel across town to sign on if the plans go ahead.

Another plan to close the jobcentre in Calder Valley was branded “a disaster” by the area’s Conservative MP, Craig Whittaker, in the Commons last month, while Jake Berry, MP for Rossendale and Darwen said the Government appeared to be in “la la land”.

Labour MP Louise Haigh asked the written questions

The Government previously said it wanted to limit closures if people had to travel an extra 20 minutes by public transport to sign on at a different job centre. This rule appears to have been broken in a significant number of cases, however.

The Public and Commercial Services Union (PCS) said the plan would make life harder for claimants and that the policy would undermine the support that jobcentres provided. The Government has admitted that compulsory redundancies could be unavoidable as part of the closures, though it says it will try to relocate some staff to other offices.

Mark Serwotka, general secretary of PCS, said: “After ramping up sanctions, and turning jobcentres from places to go for help into places of conflict and suspicion, the Tories now want to make life even harder for claimants.

“Jobcentres provide a lifeline for sick, disabled and unemployed people, and forcing them to travel further would undermine the support they need to get back to work or into training.”

A DWP spokesperson said: “We will be conducting a full impact assessment as part of our planning for a more efficient jobcentre network before any final decisions are made.”

Join our commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies


Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in