Lansley tells BMA: stop spreading lies about my health reform Bill

Health Secretary attacks his critics – as opposition to plans among medical colleges begins to unravel

Jeremy Laurance
Friday 27 January 2012 01:00
Andrew Lansley accused the British Medical Association of having opposed 'every important reform' back to the founding of the NHS more than 60 years ago
Andrew Lansley accused the British Medical Association of having opposed 'every important reform' back to the founding of the NHS more than 60 years ago

Andrew Lansley upped the stakes in his increasingly acrimonious dispute with the medical profession over the Health and Social Care Bill yesterday, accusing the British Medical Association (BMA) of having opposed "every important reform" back to the founding of the NHS more than 60 years ago.

As support for the BMA's campaign against the Bill appeared to be crumbling among the royal medical colleges last night, the Health Secretary accused his critics of spreading "lies" about the reforms and suggested that change in the NHS had always been opposed because it was "hard".

"Look back to 1948 when the British Medical Association denounced Aneurin Bevan as 'a would-be Führer' for wanting them to join a National Health Service. And Bevan himself described the BMA as 'politically poisoned people'. A survey at the time showed only 10 per cent of doctors backed the plans ... but where would we be today if my predecessors had caved in," Mr Lansley said in a speech in Liverpool.

His remarks came ahead of last night's summit meeting of the Academy of Royal Medical Colleges, its second in 48 hours, requested by the BMA in an attempt to bolster support for its opposition to the Bill. But the meeting was boycotted by the Royal College of Surgeons and the Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists, which said they would not be joining the BMA in calling for the Bill to be scrapped.

Both colleges said they had "serious concerns" about the Bill but were prepared to work with the Government to resolve them. A spokesman for the Royal College of Surgeons said: "It has become too political.

"There is a polarisation of approaches to the situation – it has reached the point where the Academy is not going to be able to hold it together."

College presidents have been subject to intense lobbying by ministers following their first meeting on Tuesday at which widespread concern about the impact of the reforms was expressed. A leaked draft statement prepared following that meeting said the academy and the royal medical colleges were "not able to support the Bill as it currently stands".

But the statement was hurriedly discarded after several college presidents declined to sign it.

A source at the meeting said: "Ministers have been busy ringing college presidents – a lot of conversations have been had in the last 24 hours. It was felt that while those conversations were continuing it was not appropriate to say anything. These are shifting sands."

While it was "perfectly legitimate" for the BMA, as a trade union, to ask its members to withdraw co-operation over the Bill, it was not appropriate for the colleges to do so, which were professional organisations concerned with quality and standards, not terms and conditions of service, the source said.

Anxiety about the Bill extends across the medical and political spectrum and is focused on the impact of increased competition, privatisation and the ability of the NHS to make £20bn efficiency savings by 2014.

The Health Select Committee warned on Tuesday that the reforms were a "distraction" and the NHS Confederation, representing NHS trusts, said the NHS was "sleepwalking into serious difficulties." The BMA, RCN and RCM initially signalled their intention to work with ministers on the Bill, but last week switched to outright opposition.

Timeline: Health and Social Care Bill

12 July 2010

White Paper proposing reform of the NHS published

19 January 2011

Bill unveiled by Andrew Lansley, right

12 March 2011

Lib-Dem revolt led by Shirley Williams

6 April 2011

David Cameron announces Bill "paused". Launches listening exercise

13 June 2011

Future Forum calls for changes to bill – accepted by Government

5 July 2011

Heart czar, Roger Boyle, quits over Health Bill

13 October 2011

Lords approve amended Health Bill

12 January 2012

Survey of RCGP, led by Clare Gerada, shows 98 per cent of GPs oppose Bill

19 January 2012

RCN led by Peter Carter, joins BMA and RCM in calling for Bill to be scrapped

24 January 2012

Former Tory Health Secretary Stephen Dorrell, chair of Health Select Committee, warns NHS is being "salami sliced" and Bill is a "distraction"

Join our new commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies

View comments