Stay up to date with notifications from The Independent

Notifications can be managed in browser preferences.

South Africa court overturns ban on rhino horn trade

'I would just hope that the world understands that if I don’t sell rhino, my whole rhino herd would be dead within the next ten years'

Thursday 26 November 2015 13:14 GMT

The ban was lifted at South Africa's High Court (ALEXANDER JOE/AFP/Getty Images)

Trading rhino horns domestically is now legal in South Africa after a judge overturned a ban first enforced in 2009.

Judge Francis Legodi lifted the moratorium at the High Court after saying the government had not followed the process of public consultation before imposing it.

According to news site The Citizen, Judge Francis Legodi said the moratorium was “set aside for substantial non-compliance with consultative and participatory process by the members of sections 99 and 100 of NEMBA (The National Environmental Management: Biodiversity Act)”.

Two of South Africa’s largest rhino farmers, John Hume and Johan Kruger, sought the application to legalise trading in order to cover the costs of protecting the animal.

Following the hearing, Mr Hume told The Citizen: “This is a momentous judgment. I would just hope that the world understands that if I don’t sell rhino, my whole rhino herd would be dead within the next ten years.”

During the hearing, Judge Legodi noted that poaching had soared since the ban was imposed.

Demand for rhino horn is high in both China and Vietnam. In 2009, 122 rhinos were poached in South Africa, but last year, the figure was 1,212.

Cathy Dean, director of Save the Rhino International, did not believe that poaching had increased as a direct response to the ban.

The last charge as western black rhino is declared extinct

Show all 12

1/12The last charge as western black rhino is declared extinct

The last charge as western black rhino is declared extinct

113809428.jpg

The International Union for Conservation of Nature says the Western Black Rhino (pictured) is extinct and two other species of rhino are "possibly" extinct.

Getty Images

The last charge as western black rhino is declared extinct

Reef Manta Ray_Manta alfredi_Andrea Marshall.JPG

The Reef Manta Ray is also on the conservation group's Red List of Threatened Species.

The last charge as western black rhino is declared extinct

Southern White Rhino subspecies _Ceratotherium simum simum_Dr Richard Emslie (2).JPG

The Southern White Rhino of central Africa is now "possibly extinct" in the wild and firmly placed on the Red List of Threatened Species.

The last charge as western black rhino is declared extinct

Summers Poison Frog_Ranitomeya summers_Jason Brown.jpg

The Blessed Poison Frog (Ranitomeya benedicta) is currently listed as Vulnerable and the Summers' Poison Frog (pictured) (Ranitomeya summersi) is Endangered.

The last charge as western black rhino is declared extinct

Tarzans Chameleon_ Calumma tarzan_Jörn Köhler.jpg

The current Red List reveals that an alarming 40% of Madagascar’s terrestrial reptiles are threatened. The 22 Madagascan species currently identified as Critically Endangered, which include chameleons, geckoes, skinks and snakes, are now a conservation challenge. Encouragingly, there are new conservation areas being designated in Madagascar that will help conserve a significant proportion of Critically Endangered species, such as Tarzan’s Chameleon (Calumma tarzan) (pictured), the Bizarre-nosed Chameleon (Calumma hafahafa) and the Limbless Skink (Paracontias fasika).

The last charge as western black rhino is declared extinct

Paroedura masobe_Franco Andreone.jpg

The Paroedura masobe gecko is classed as "endangered" by the IUCN.

The last charge as western black rhino is declared extinct

Giant Manta Ray_Manta birostris_Andrea Marshall.jpg

Giant Manta Ray (Manta birostris), the largest species of rays, is also on the conservation group's Red List of Threatened Species and classed as "vulnerable".

The last charge as western black rhino is declared extinct

Coco der Mer_Lodoicea maldivica_Jean-Christophe Vie (2).JPG

The majority of endemic flowering plants in the granitic Seychelles islands have been assessed and current studies show that of the 79 endemic species, 77% are at risk of extinction. Most of these are new assessments but one species, the infamous Coco de Mer (Lodoicea maldivica) has been uplisted from Vulnerable to Endangered. Known for its supposed aphrodisiac properties, the Coco de Mer faces threats from fires and illegal harvesting of its kernels.

The last charge as western black rhino is declared extinct

Chinese Water Fir_Glyptostrobus pensilis_Philip Thomas.jpg

The Chinese Water Fir (Glyptostrobus pensilis), which was formerly widespread throughout China and Viet Nam, has been upgraded from Endangered to Critically Endangered.

The last charge as western black rhino is declared extinct

Begonia seychellensis_Justin Gerlach.JPG

The Begonia seychellensis is one of the many tropical plant species at risk.

The last charge as western black rhino is declared extinct

The Blessed Poison Frog_Ranitomeya benedicta_Jason Brown (1).jpg

The Blessed Poison Frog (Ranitomeya benedicta) is currently listed as Vulnerable.

The last charge as western black rhino is declared extinct

Przewalski's Horse_ Equus ferus_Patricia D Moehlman.jpg

The Przewalski's Horse (Equus ferus) is another success story, improving its status from Critically Endangered to Endangered.

She told The Independent that the demand had always existed and needed to be tackled.

“If continued leakage from a legal domestic horn trade is still going to China and Vietnam, it will be coming from multiple sources [now that the ban has been lifted]… and it will continue to stoke demand in [those countries]."

“There will be more avenues of selling illegally into the user countries.”

It is not yet clear whether the government will appeal the decision.

Additional reporting by agencies

Join our commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies