James Comey: The head of the FBI is in the spotlight once again

'The director of the FBI is a hard job, even when it's an easy day or nothing's in the newspaper'

Eric Tucker
Saturday 25 February 2017 10:50
FBI Director James Comey testifies before the Senate (Select) Intelligence Committee in the Dirksen Senate Office Building on Capitol Hill January 10, 2017 in Washington, DC.
FBI Director James Comey testifies before the Senate (Select) Intelligence Committee in the Dirksen Senate Office Building on Capitol Hill January 10, 2017 in Washington, DC.

FBI Director James Comey is again in a familiar spot these days - the middle of political tumult.

As a high-ranking Justice Department official in the George W Bush administration, he clashed with the White House over a secret surveillance program.

Years later as head of the FBI, he incurred the ire of Hillary Clinton supporters for public statements on an investigation into her emails.

Now, Mr Comey is facing new political pressure as White House officials are encouraging him to follow their lead by publicly recounting private FBI conversations in an attempt to dispute reports about connections between the Trump administration and Russia.

It's an unusual position for a crime-fighting organisation with a vaunted reputation for independence and political neutrality. Yet Mr Comey, the former top federal prosecutor in Manhattan who later became deputy attorney general of the United States, is known for an unshaking faith in his own moral compass.

"I'm not detecting a loss of confidence in him, a loss of confidence in him by him," said retired FBI assistant director Ron Hosko, noting the broad recognition that "these are very tumultuous, polarised, angry, angry times."

The latest flare up occurred this week, when White House officials told reporters that chief of staff Reince Priebus had asked top FBI officials to dispute media reports that Donald Trump's campaign advisers were frequently in touch with Russian intelligence agents during the election.

The officials said the FBI first raised concerns about The New York Times reporting but told Mr Priebus the bureau could not weigh in publicly on the matter.

The officials said Deputy Director Andrew McCabe and Mr Comey instead gave Mr Priebus the go-ahead to discredit the story publicly, something the FBI has not confirmed.

As the FBI declined to discuss the matter, pressure mounted on Mr Comey to either counter or affirm the White House's account. Even the Trump administration urged him to come forward. He has yet to surface.

"Politicised assertions by White House chief of staff Priebus about what may or may not be the findings of an FBI investigation are exactly the wrong way for the public to hear about an issue that is of grave consequence to our democracy," Oregon Senator Ron Wyden, a member of the Senate Intelligence Committee, said in a statement. "The American people deserve real transparency, which means Director Comey needs to come forward, in an open hearing, and answer questions."

Comey shakes hands with Vice President Pence during a law enforcement Inaugural reception

The push on Mr Comey to publicly discuss the bureau's investigation of Russian interference in the 2016 presidential election is especially acute. Many Democrats believe his statements in the run-up to the election cost Ms Clinton a victory. He detailed the results of the FBI's investigation at an unusual July news conference, testified on it for hours on Capitol Hill and alerted Congress less than two weeks before Election Day that the FBI would be reviewing new emails potentially connected to the case.

But it's not clear that Mr Comey, now in the fourth year of a 10-year term, will be swayed by any public hand-wringing. People who have worked with the FBI director describe him as holding strong personal convictions.

As deputy attorney general, he confronted White House officials in the hospital room of then-Attorney General John Ashcroft in an effort to quash the reauthorisation of a counterterrorism surveillance program.

When nominating Mr Comey for FBI director in 2013, President Barack Obama praised him for his "fierce independence and deep integrity."

Mr Comey stood apart from the administration on a few occasions after that, including when he floated the possibility that police concerns over being recorded on video were causing officers to pull back and contributing to an uptick in homicides, a viewpoint the White House refused to endorse.

His decision to announce the FBI's recommendation against criminal charges in the Clinton email case was made without any notice to the Justice Department, and his notification to Congress about the new emails was not supported by department leaders, including Attorney General Loretta Lynch.

Decisions that reach the desk of the top leadership of the FBI are generally not easy, said Robert Anderson, a retired FBI executive assistant director.

"The director of the FBI is a hard job, even when it's an easy day or nothing's in the newspaper," Mr Anderson said. "By the time it makes it up to Jim, it's all hard at that point."

Join our new commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies

View comments