Rohingya migrant boat crisis: Who is to blame for thousands of people stranded at sea?

Indonesia and Malaysia today offered to give 'temporary shelter' to them

Lizzie Dearden
Wednesday 20 May 2015 12:21 BST
Rohingya migrants in a boat adrift in the Andaman Sea last week
Rohingya migrants in a boat adrift in the Andaman Sea last week (AFP)

More than 430 migrants were rescued by Indonesian fishermen today after weeks stranded at sea as ministers met to address the boat crisis in Southeast Asia.

After years of refusing shelter to desperate people trying to reach their shores, Indonesia and Malaysia have offered to provide temporary refuge to thousands of men, women and children currently stuck on boats.

Thailand, Malaysia and Indonesia estimated 7,000 people were stranded at today’s meeting but the UN refugee agency believes there are 4,000 at sea and activists had initially put the number at 6,000.

Food shortages has driven migrants to fighting over aid supplies, survivors have said, and around 100 people are reported to have died on one boat after being stabbed, hanged and thrown overboard during a scramble for the final scraps of food.

Anifah Aman, the Malaysian Foreign Minister, said his country would provide humanitarian aid and “temporary shelter provided that the resettlement and repatriation process will be done in one year by the international community”.

“This is not an Asean problem,” he added, referring to the 10-nation group of Southeast Asian countries. “This is a problem for the international community. We are talking about a humanitarian crisis.”

Thailand did not extend the offer of shelter but is giving aid after previously claiming it cannot afford to take any more migrants after the arrival of tens of thousands of refugees from Burma.

So who is to blame for the crisis?


Most of those leaving the country are ethnic Rohingya people fleeing systematic religious and ethnic discrimination, as well as violence from Buddhist extremists.

As well as fleeing Burma by land to Thailand, they are one of the largest groups among boat migrants, alongside poverty-stricken Bangladeshis.

Rohingya are a Muslim ethnic minority who claim to be indigenous to Burma but the predominantly Buddhist nation denies them citizenship, as does Bangladesh.

They have faced decades of state-sanctioned discrimination and the UN has named them as one of the most persecuted groups in the world.

A migrant Rohingya woman from Myanmar breaks down while holding her son at the new confinement area in the fishing town of Kuala Langsa in Aceh province

Burma’s co-operation is seen as vital to solving the crisis but its government has already cast doubt on whether it will attend a conference to be hosted by Thailand on 29 May alongside 15 nations affected by the emergency.

Officials have vowed not to attend if the word “Rohingya” is mentioned on the invitation or if their country is going to be blamed as “the source of the problem.”

In the past three years, Rohingya people have been targeted by violent mobs of Buddhist extremists, leaving hundreds dead and sparking an exodus of more than 120,000 people, according to the UNHCR.

Even the name Rohingya is taboo in the country, where they are widely called “Bengalis” and alleged to be illegal immigrants from Bangladesh, even though Rohingya have lived in the country for generations.

Genocide Watch, a group monitoring atrocities around the world, has declared an emergency in the state of Rakhine where around one million members of the minority are believed to live.

The UN has urged the Burmese government to give Rohingya equal access to citizenship and to crack down on Buddhist violence against them and other Muslims.

Rohingya Muslims displaced from their homes by communal violence (Getty Images)

Countries turning them away

The International Organisation for Migration has said countries including Indonesia, Thailand and Burma are plying “a game of maritime ping-pong” with people's lives while refusing to allow migrant boats to land.

Authorities have delivered aid and food to the migrants while at sea but claim bringing them to shore would constitute illegal entry into the countries that they will not allow.

Last week, the Indonesian navy turned away a boat crowded with thousands of trafficked refugees, sending it on to Malaysia and the next day, the Malaysian authorities rejected two boats carrying at least 800 people between them after blockading its north-western sea border.

Thailand has hurriedly repaired boats' engines and shooed them out of its waters.

The mass trafficking has been going on for many years but no co-ordinated strategy has been drawn up to deal with the influx of boat people.

Rohingya migrants bring back food supplies dropped by a Thai army helicopter after jumping to collect them at sea from a boat drifting in Thai waters off the southern island of Koh Lipe in the Andaman sea

Human traffickers

Most of the migrants are believed to be victims of human traffickers, who recruit them in Burma’s Sittwe province and in Bangladesh with promises to give them safe passage to Malaysia and jobs once they land there.

Traffickers have been abandoning boats before reaching shore, fearing arrest by governments cracking down on their trade in a similar pattern as seen on migrant boats from North Africa to Italy and Greece.

Thai authorities have discovered a mass grave at an abandoned trafficking camp in the far south of the country, close to the Malaysian border, containing the corpses of more than 30 Rohingya who had died from disease or starvation while traffickers awaited further payment before smuggling them into Malaysia.

Migration on steady rise

The 430 migrants rescued by a flotilla of Indonesian fishermen today included Rohingya, and 3,000 more have already landed in the three countries in recent weeks.

“They were suffering from dehydration, they are weak and starving,” Khairul Nove, head of Langsa Search and Rescue Agency, saying there were many women and children among the passengers.

One of the migrants, Ubaydul Haque, 30, said the ship's engine had failed and the captain fled, and that they were at sea for four months before Indonesian fishermen found them.

“We ran out of food, we wanted to enter Malaysia but we were not allowed,” he added.

Bangladeshi migrants walk toward a temporary shelter al at Kuala Langsa Port in Langsa

The world

Malaysian Foreign Minister, Anifah Aman, said the crisis was a global issue and said Asean countries needed help to settle refugees.

“This is a problem for the international community," he added. "We are talking about a humanitarian crisis.”

Like the boat crisis in the Mediterranean, the myriad crises and conflicts driving people to flee their countries have been ongoing for some time.

The UN General Assembly passed a resolution urging Burma to provide full citizenship to Rohingyas and allow them free movement last year but it was swiftly rejected by the government.

A UN resolution was completely ignored (Getty Images)

Asean also has a strict policy of non-interference in member countries' internal affairs, meaning neighbouring states affected by the Rohingya exodus are powerless to influence Burma's policies.

Migrants have been making the journey across the Andaman Sea for years but their plight has only recently made international headlines and earned public condemnation from UN agencies and foreign governments.

The UNHCR has offered Malaysia medical and other aid to process migrants arriving on boats but the other countries facing an influx claim they need help and money to handle them.

Additional reporting by AP

Join our commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies


Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in