Sign up to Miguel Delaney’s Reading the Game newsletter sent straight to your inbox for free Sign up to Miguel’s Delaney’s free weekly newsletter
Pundits usually choose their words carefully in the age of social media when five-second clips can spread like wildfire.
So when Alan Shearer was analysing Manchester United , he appeared to sum up a restless fanbase, seemingly forgetting he was live on air.
“That’s where Ole Gunnar Solskjaer wants to get to. At the minute, in terms of football teams, Man United are f***ed,” the former England striker appeared to conclude on Premier League Productions.
After a dismal run of seven defeats in 10 games, Shearer’s perceived words, while brutally honest, appeared accurate, if not a little too colourful for live television.
But Shearer denied making the expletive rant, stating: “Very clever and very funny whoever did this!! #fakenews”
Manchester United: Keep or sell?Show all 26 1 /26Manchester United: Keep or sell? Manchester United: Keep or sell? Who will Manchester United keep this summer? It has been a rollercoaster season for Manchester United leaving Ole Gunnar solskjaer with key decisions to make over who should stay and who should leave this summer
Man Utd via Getty Images
Manchester United: Keep or sell? David De Gea Form is temporary, class is permanent. Riddled with errors of late but remains United’s most important player, even when in the last year of his contract. Keep
Action Images via Reuters
Manchester United: Keep or sell? Sergio Romero A reserve goalkeeper yet says everything about United’s recruitment that he is one of the better signings of the post-Ferguson era. Keep
Getty
Manchester United: Keep or sell? Lee Grant Third-choice, veteran goalkeeper whose home-grown status means he helps to meet squad requirements for European competition. Keep
Getty Images
Manchester United: Keep or sell? Ashley Young Set to spend a third straight season at right-back, having signed a new contract, yet surely cannot be the automatic first-choice. Sell, yet likely to stay
Getty Images
Manchester United: Keep or sell? Diogo Dalot Some glimpses of promise but the jury’s still out. At 20-years-old, clearly still raw, though needs to perform more consistently when handed opportunities. Keep
Action Images via Reuters
Manchester United: Keep or sell? Antonio Valencia Solskjaer recently confirmed for the first time that club captain Valencia’s contract would not be renewed come the end of the season. Sell
Getty
Manchester United: Keep or sell? Luke Shaw After several years of treading water at Old Trafford, Shaw has been a quiet success story of an otherwise forgettable season. Keep
Getty
Manchester United: Keep or sell? Chris Smalling Will be United’s longest-serving player when Valencia departs. Signed a new contract. A new centre-back should make him compete for his place. Keep as cover, for now. Keep as cover, for now
AFP/Getty Images
Manchester United: Keep or sell? Phil Jones Another survivor of the Ferguson era. Comes in for an undue amount of criticism, but his longstanding injury problems and inconsistency undermine his case to stay. Sell, yet likely to stay
AFP/Getty Images
Manchester United: Keep or sell? Victor Lindelof A contender for United’s player of the year alongside Shaw, though form of autumn and winter has tailed off. Keep
REUTERS
Manchester United: Keep or sell? Eric Bailly A defender with raw gifts but a questionable injury record. Seemingly unfancied by Solskjaer. Close to outgoing Spanish-speakers like Herrera and Mata. Keep as cover, for now
EPA
Manchester United: Keep or sell? Marcos Rojo Has played a pitiful amount of football since renewing terms last year. Offers nothing while out for long periods of time for unspecified reasons. Sell
AP
Manchester United: Keep or sell? Matteo Darmian Surprise starter against City, United have attempted to offload Darmian for several windows now. Should finally cut ties this summer. Sell
EPA
Manchester United: Keep or sell? Nemanja Matic Increasingly appears as if holding midfielder’s best days are behind him. Currently first-choice in an area of the pitch where United must improve. Sell
Getty
Manchester United: Keep or sell? Fred United’s fourth-most expensive signing of all time has suffered a difficult first year. Questions remain over his ability, despite a handful of competent showings. Keep, for now
Action Images via Reuters
Manchester United: Keep or sell? Scott McTominay Recently emerged as a useful squad player in the mould of Darren Fletcher of late. Questions remain over long-term place but deserving of more opportunities. Keep
Getty Images
Manchester United: Keep or sell? Paul Pogba An enigma. Important commercially and has the natural ability to dominate on-the-pitch too but inconsistent. Real Madrid’s interest is no secret. Keep, only sell for record money
AFP/Getty
Manchester United: Keep or sell? Andreas Pereira Yet another to have signed new terms, yet has rarely taken opportunities granted to him. Sell, but likely to stay
Getty
Manchester United: Keep or sell? Ander Herrera Expected to join Paris Saint-Germain on a free transfer. A player who clearly ‘gets’ the club but fresh, younger alternatives would be welcome. Release
Getty
Manchester United: Keep or sell? Alexis Sanchez A symbol of the club’s poor decision-making and arguably its least successful transfer of the modern era. Astronomical wages may prohibit a sale. Sell, if possible
Getty Images
Manchester United: Keep or sell? Juan Mata Edging closer to the exit door, with no new contract signed. Perhaps too languid for Solskjaer's ideal style of play. Like Herrera, a young alternative would be preferable. Release
Manchester United: Keep or sell? Jesse Lingard A regular target for criticism but also an academy product who has earned his current status at Old Trafford. Needs to rediscover match-winning ability of last season. Keep
AP
Manchester United: Keep or sell? Anthony Martial Valid questions remain over whether he will reach his potential, though natural ability is clear. Having just signed until 2024, he is likely to stay around for a while yet. Keep
REUTERS
Manchester United: Keep or sell? Romelu Lukaku A better player than his time at United suggests. If Solskjaer can fit him into a coherent system, he should stay. If not, hard to see him as a substitute. Keep, but sell at right price
EPA
Manchester United: Keep or sell? Marcus Rashford One of the few players United fans would be disappointed to lose. Contract talks are ongoing, with current deal effectively set to expire in two years. Keep
Getty
And now an extended clip of his analysis has emerged, revealing his words in full.
Shearer can be heard saying: “At the minute, in terms of football teams, Man United are f... Sorry, Man City are far, far ahead of Manchester United.”
With Shearer’s full views coming to light, some may concur more with the interpreted views from the edited clip.
Quite whether United’s long-term prospects will prove to be better than the initial interpretation of Shearer’s views remains to be seen.
There remains an outside chance of a top four finish, but with Paul Pogba looking for a move and interest from Real Madrid, United face a long rebuild.
Join our commenting forum
Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies