Liverpool's lack of spark against dogged Southampton sees them fail to consolidate their place in the top-four

Liverpool 0 Southampton 0: Shorn of Sadio Mane and Adam Lallana, Liverpool lacked a creative spark and failed to break down a stubbornly defensive Southampton side

Ian Herbert
Sunday 07 May 2017 15:28 BST
Liverpool once again failed to score against Southampton this season
Liverpool once again failed to score against Southampton this season (Getty)

Jurgen Klopp offered a miscellany of reasons for the stalemate which means the Champions League spot which seemed so likely when Liverpool reached late December in second place, with seven more goals than anyone else, will now go to the wire.

The pitch was too dry, slowing the speed of the ball, he said. The Southampton goalkeeper Fraser Foster did not behave “as a sportsman should” with an elaborate act of gamesmanship before making his first Premier League penalty save against James Milner, who had not missed one for eight years.

In the final reckoning, though, Liverpool simply lacked the creative spark to break through the unambitious drudgery of a Southampton side against whom they have failed to muster a single goal in 360 minutes of football this season. There was something deeply unattractive about Claude Puel’s side, whose campaign was effectively over, providing such meagre ambition as this, though teams with Champions League pretensions cut through. The muscularity Klopp has added since the turn of the year has been to the detriment of the creativity.

It can only have compounded the private agony for the manager that Daniel Sturridge, still only fit for a cameo role, offered a fleeting reminder of what he might have brought to the team’s game all these months. His sublime spin around his marker into the six-yard box and rapier shot into the side-netting were the closest to electricity Liverpool got, when he arrived in the last 20 minutes, Yet the Englishman’s days in this city surely seem over this summer. The Sturridge medical drama has been too long-running for any other outcome.

The contribution both he and Adam Lallana made in Klopp’s dual substitution after the penalty controversy – which saw Forster put a divot of turf on the penalty spot, stand over Milner and whisper sweet nothings in his ear – left you wondering where the pair had been for the previous 70 minutes. It was self-evident that unlocking the door was going to be the problem. Klopp might have shown more creative ambition by starting the game with Lallana, at least.

There was little ingenuity to surprise the men Puel banked behind the goal: too much sideways movement and very little of the lateral variety. Liverpool were awarded their ‘advanced level quality standard’ by the Premier League at half time and they certainly did not earn it on the pitch.

Milner failed to convert his spot-kick
Milner failed to convert his spot-kick (Getty)

Klopp has introduced a durability to the side which makes them far more utilitarian than the fast flowing side who flourished in the season’s early months but there are times when they seem side lack enough belief in their rear-guard to burst forward in numbers. They miss the injured Sadio Mane. Though Forster also saved sharply from third substitute Marko Grujic at the death, Klopp’s players were generally limited to shooting from range.

Southampton brought physicality. Romeu took Firmino out in the first half’s closing moments and Manolo Gabbiadini sent Joel Matip tumbling over the Liverpool by-line. The game was bad tempered at times. Klopp sent a water bottle flying after Emre Can and Lucas Leiva had been penalised for dispossessing Dusan Tadic together.

Forster has struggled for form of late but was superb against Liverpool
Forster has struggled for form of late but was superb against Liverpool (Getty)

The gift-wrapped opportunity arrived just beyond the hour when a smartly arced ball into the area from Lucas was elbowed away by Jack Stephens and the penalty was awarded – justifiably, despite the Southampton protestations which saw Cedric booked for dissent and James Ward-Prowse booked for time-wasting, after collecting a water bottle from the net.

​“You saw what they did. Why do you need my say on it?” Klopp observed. “Two yellow cards for them and with the time delay, I don’t know how long Forster needed for his kicks, four minutes, that is ambitious. But I have nothing to do with it….”

It was a committed defensive display from Southampton
It was a committed defensive display from Southampton (Getty)

He said the Anfield pitch mystified him. “We gave all the water we had and after 15 minutes it was really dry, the wind and a little bit… It was difficult,” he observed. “You could see it – a lot passes you thought ‘why are they playing this?’ but it was difficult.”

Only the points matter now, though. Liverpool have 70 – which would earned them a Champions League place in all but two previous years – yet are left to wonder and worry whether a place at Europe’s high table will really be theirs.

The Kop revealed a pro-Jeremy Corbyn banner ahead of the game
The Kop revealed a pro-Jeremy Corbyn banner ahead of the game (Getty)


Mignolet; Clyne, Matip, Lovren, Milner; Lucas (Lallana 69), Can, Wijnaldum (Guijic 87); Origi (Sturridge 69), Firmino. Coutinho.

Substitutes: Karius, , Klavan, Moreno, Alexander-Armold.


Forster; Cedric, Stephens, Yoshiba, Bertand; Romeu, Davis; Tadic, Ward-Prowse, Boufal (Redmond 61). Gabbiadini.

Substitutes: Hassen, Long, Rodriguez, Caceres, Hojbjerg, Pied

Referee: B. Madley (West Yorkshire)

Attendance: 53,151

Star man: Forster

Match rating: 6

Join our commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies


Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in