Sign up to Miguel Delaney’s Reading the Game newsletter sent straight to your inbox for free Sign up to Miguel’s Delaney’s free weekly newsletter
Liverpool have been worse under Jurgen Klopp than his predecessor Brendan Rodgers.
The enigmatic German watched his side lose 3-0 to newly-promoted Watford on Sunday, the third Premier League defeat his side have suffered since his arrival which was supposed to signal the return of the good times at Anfield.
Instead, Klopp has overseen a worse set of results that those that led to Rodgers being given the sack.
In Rodgers' eight Premier League games in charge this season, he won three, drew three and lost two - a win percentage of 37.5 per cent. In contrast, Klopp has overseen nine games, winning and drawing the same number as Rodgers, but losing an extra game. It means he has a win percentage of 33.3 per cent.
In terms of points, they have both added 12 points to Liverpool's tally of 24 for the season. However, Klopp has had an extra game. That equates to 1.5 points per game under Rodgers, but 1.33 under Klopp.
Show all 22 1 /22Watford 3 Liverpool 0 player ratings Watford 3 Liverpool 0 player ratings Watford: Heurelho Gomes 7 out of 10 Generally had little to do against Liverpool’s anaemic attack but stayed alert enough to tip over Jordan Henderson’s strike midway through the second half.
Watford 3 Liverpool 0 player ratings Allan Nyom 7 out of 10 Clashed with Alberto Moreno in the first half and had his work cut out dealing with the Liverpool man’s frequent bursts forward from left-back.
2015 Liverpool FC
Watford 3 Liverpool 0 player ratings Miguel Britos 7 out of 10 Had little to do in the first half but at the start of the second, he made a crucial block to cut out Adam Lallana’s close-range volley.
2015 Getty Images
Watford 3 Liverpool 0 player ratings Craig Cathcart 7 out of 10 Had to work harder in the second half against Divock Origi but he cannot have imagined he would have such a straightforward afternoon at the back.
2015 Liverpool FC
Watford 3 Liverpool 0 player ratings Nathan Ake 7 out of 10 Quick reactions brought the Chelsea loanee the opening goal and he was often a threat going forward, though Gomes had to bail him out after a weak challenge on Jordan Henderson in the second half.
2015 Getty Images
Watford 3 Liverpool 0 player ratings Almen Abdi 7 out of 10 He was busy throughout but would have been relieved to see Moreno shoot wide from close range when his poor positioning let in the Spaniard.
2015 Getty Images
Watford 3 Liverpool 0 player ratings Ben Watson 7 out of 10 Forms a highly effective pairing with Capoue. His corner led to the first goal and he was intelligent with the ball, diligent without it.
2015 Getty Images
Watford 3 Liverpool 0 player ratings Etienne Capoue 8 out of 10 Renewed since his time at Tottenham, the Frenchman was influential throughout in central midfield. He will have his sights on a place in France’s Euro 2016 squad.
2015 Getty Images
Watford 3 Liverpool 0 player ratings Jose Manuel Jurado 7 out of 10 Extremely smart at drifting in from the left into good positions, he caused problems all afternoon and twice went close to scoring.
2015 Getty Images
Watford 3 Liverpool 0 player ratings Odion Ighalo 9 out of 10 Showed strength to hold off Skrtel for his first goal, produced a superb finish and scored his second late on. The league’s elite will be watching this mobile, imaginative striker very closely.
Watford 3 Liverpool 0 player ratings Troy Deeney 8 out of 10 All muscle and hustle and he was too much for Liverpool to handle. The Reds’ centre-backs will not forget about him in a hurry.
2015 Liverpool FC
Watford 3 Liverpool 0 player ratings Liverpool: Adam Bogdan 5 out of 10 Starting in place of the injured Simon Mignolet, Bogdan was at fault for Nathan Ake’s opener and though his display improved, the damage was done.
2015 Getty Images
Watford 3 Liverpool 0 player ratings Nathaniel Clyne 6 out of 10 The least worst of the Liverpool back four but he still had a day to forget, though he was not always well protected when Jose Manuel Jurado and Ake attacked down Liverpool’s right.
Watford 3 Liverpool 0 player ratings Martin Skrtel 4 out of 10 Held off far too easily by Ighalo for Watford’s second goal and despite his height and strength, never looked comfortable against Watford’s direct style.
2015 Liverpool FC
Watford 3 Liverpool 0 player ratings Mamadou Sakho 3 out of 10 Both Troy Deeney and Odion Ighalo ran rings around him. You suspect that if Liverpool are to challenge for the title under Jurgen Klopp, they will need better defenders.
2015 Getty Images
Watford 3 Liverpool 0 player ratings Alberto Moreno 5 out of 10 Always available going forward but desperately untidy in defence. Missed a great chance at the start of the second half.
2015 Liverpool FC
Watford 3 Liverpool 0 player ratings Jordan Henderson 6 out of 10 Enjoyed himself more in the second half when Liverpool switched to a midfield diamond and he made some strong forward runs – but by then it was too late.
2015 Liverpool FC
Watford 3 Liverpool 0 player ratings Lucas Leiva 5 out of 10 Started in the holding midfield role before dropping into central defence when Skrtel went off. He didn’t impress at either discipline.
2015 Getty Images
Watford 3 Liverpool 0 player ratings Emre Can 5 out of 10 One of Liverpool’s better players this season, he had no answer to the energy of Ben Watson and Etienne Capoue. Played in front of the back four in the second half.
2015 Liverpool FC
Watford 3 Liverpool 0 player ratings Adam Lallana 5 out of 10 Didn’t do enough in attack or defence. Started in a three-man attack before operating in a midfield diamond; he did little in either role.
2015 Liverpool FC
Watford 3 Liverpool 0 player ratings Roberto Firmino 4 out of 10 Used as a ‘false’ nine, it was easy to forget the Brazilian was on the pitch. Indeed, his most noteworthy contribution was to leave it in the 74th minute.
2015 Liverpool FC
Watford 3 Liverpool 0 player ratings Philippe Coutinho 5 out of 10 Coutinho was bright on occasions but for a player of his quality and reputation, he did not have enough of an influence on this game.
2015 Liverpool FC
Speaking after the defeat at Watford, Klopp said: "It was a bad start to the game. It was 1-0 and our reaction was really bad
"We didn't play well in the first half. The start of the second half was absolutely OK. If we scored one goal everybody knows the game is open again, but we couldn't do that and we have to accept this high, high defeat."
Liverpool's next match is against top of the table Leicester
Join our commenting forum
Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies