Stay up to date with notifications from The Independent

Notifications can be managed in browser preferences.

Premier League transfers: The 10 best buys and 10 questionable signings featuring David Luiz and Granit Xhaka

A look at the candidates for the best and worst moves of the summer

Jack Pitt-Brooke

Friday 02 September 2016 15:18 BST

Transfer window: Good and bad signings

Show all 20

1/20Transfer window: Good and bad signings

Transfer window: Good and bad signings

Granit Xhaka – Borussia Monchengldbach to Arsenal

Good signing: Arsenal have needed presence and power in midfield for years and now they have it again through Granit Xhaka. The Swiss international is an imposing athlete and an astute passer, the perfect partner for Santi Cazorla or Aaron Ramsey.

Getty

Transfer window: Good and bad signings

Steven Defour – Anderlecht to Burnley

Good signing: If Burnley lacked experience and class last time they were in the top flight, Sean Dyche is determined to avoid the same this time. That is why they spent big on Belgium international Steven Defour, providing that extra edge in a workmanlike team.

Getty

Transfer window: Good and bad signings

Ashley Williams – Swansea to Everton

Good signing: Everton did not pay enough attention to defensive principles under Roberto Martinez and that eventually cost him his job. That is why they were so keen to buy Ashley Williams, a man who understands that his first and only job is to keep the ball out of his net.

Getty

Transfer window: Good and bad signings

N’Golo Kante – Leicester City to Chelsea

Good signing: hat Antonio Conte values more than anything else is hard work and running, and that is why Chelsea spent big on N’Golo Kante from Leicester City. He protects the back four, breaks up attacks and sets Chelsea’s own tempo. All they need now is more players like him.

Getty

Transfer window: Good and bad signings

Ahmed Musa – CSKA Moscow to Leicester City

Good signing: Improving a miracle-working team is difficult, but Ahmed Musa looks like a good start. His pace in behind and instincts in the box give Leicester City an extra edge, and he looks set to form a dangerously fast strike partnership with Jamie Vardy.

Getty

Transfer window: Good and bad signings

Sadio Mane – Southampton to Liverpool

Good signing: There are not many players in the Premier League like Sadio Mane, combining that speed with technical execution. He showed that in his brilliant debut goal for Liverpool at the Emirates and he has already given Jurgen Klopp’s side a new dimension.

Getty

Transfer window: Good and bad signings

John Stones – Everton to Manchester City

Good signing: The most important of Pep Guardiola’s signings at Manchester City is not Ilkay Gundogan or even Claudio Bravo but John Stones. Guardiola teams play out from the back and few are better at that in England than Stones, who is already flourishing with Guardiola’s coaching and trust. Could be City captain for the next 10 years.

Getty

Transfer window: Good and bad signings

Eric Bailly – Villarreal to Manchester United

Good signing: Signing centre-backs from abroad is difficult but in Eric Bailly, Manchester United appear to have found one who instantly understands what is demanded of him. A brilliant tackler and reader of the game, Bailly already looks like a player who will flourish in the pace of the Premier League.

Getty

Transfer window: Good and bad signings

Joe Allen – Liverpool to Stoke City

Good signing: Stoke City signed talented forwards last year but they were lacking in midfield. After signing Gianelli Imbula they continued their upgrade with Joe Allen, Liverpool’s brilliant little Welsh midfielder. Allen excelled at Euro 2016 where he showed his intelligence and technical skill, and is now improving the supply line to Xherdan Shaqiri and co.

Getty

Transfer window: Good and bad signings

Fernando Llorente – Sevilla to Swansea

Good signing: Swansea have bought cleverly in recent years but have struggled up front. In Fernando Llorente they have an experienced powerful number nine, who has played for Athletic Bilbao and Juventus, and will finally give them the type of player they have needed for years.

Getty

Transfer window: Good and bad signings

David Luiz – PSG to Chelsea

Questionable signing: All it took was one game for new Paris Saint Germain manager Unai Emery to decide that David Luiz was not for him. Luiz gave away a stupid penalty against Monaco so Emery authorised his sale back to Chelsea for £32m, two years after Jose Mourinho made a similar judgement. That Antonio Conte feels differently is a surprise.

Getty

Transfer window: Good and bad signings

Papy Djilobodji – Chelsea to Sunderland

Questionable signing: Famously offered unsuccessfully around the Championship before signing for Chelsea in 2015, Jose Mourinho only gave Djilobodji a few minutes in a League Cup game against Walsall. He was quickly loaned out to Germany but David Moyes saw enough in him there to spend £8m taking him to Sunderland this summer.

Getty

Transfer window: Good and bad signings

Brad Smith – Liverpool to Bournemouth

Questionable signing: Left-back has not exactly been a position of strength for Liverpool in recent years and yet Brad Smith struggled to make any impact at Anfield under Jurgen Klopp. But Bournemouth, having spent £15m on Jordon Ibe, decided to take another Liverpool youngster and paid £6m on Smith too.

Getty

Transfer window: Good and bad signings

Lucas Perez – Deportivo La Coruna to Arsenal

Questionable signing: Arsenal watched Lucas Perez extensively last season and decided earlier in the summer that he was not up to their level. It was little surprise, he had only scored 10 league goals once in his career, and has no Champions League or international experience. But when Arsenal needed a striker and saw Everton were about to sign him, they jumped in and paid the £17m fee anyway.

Getty

Transfer window: Good and bad signings

Gokhan Tore – Besiktas to West Ham

Questionable signing: It is not an easy transition to make from Turkish Super Lig to the Premier League, and so far Gokhan Tore has been slow to adjust to English football. Signed by West Ham United from Slaven Bilic’s former club Besiktas, the Turkish winger is not quite yet up to the pace of the game.

Getty

Transfer window: Good and bad signings

Yannick Bolasie – Crystal Palace to Everton

Questionable signing: Bolasie is a talented player but did not always produce consistently for Crystal Palace, who were very happy to sell him and replace him with Andros Townsend and a healthy profit. Now Everton have committed £25m and a five-year contract to a player who is far from guaranteed to deliver every week.

Getty

Transfer window: Good and bad signings

Moussa Sissoko – Newcastle to Tottenham

Questionable signing: Tottenham are never willing spenders in the transfer window but they equalled their record £30m fee late on deadline night, buying Newcastle’s Moussa Sissoko. Mauricio Pochettino wanted more speed in a team which can be a bit one-paced. But Sissoko’s performances at Newcastle were very patchy and he will need to show far more consistency to justify his fee.

Getty

Transfer window: Good and bad signings

Leroy Fer – QPR to Swansea

Questionable signing: Leroy Fer can be very dangerous in attacking positions but there is always the question of whether he does enough defensively to make up for it. At Queens Park Rangers the answer was no, as they fell apart as a unit and went down. But Swansea City are still prepared to take that risk.

Getty

Transfer window: Good and bad signings

Younes Kaboul – Sunderland to Watford

Questionable signing: Kaboul was Tottenham captain when Mauricio Pochettino arrived in 2014 but within weeks he was out on the fringes of the side. He has struggled for form and fitness ever since and yet Watford have decided to bring him into their three-man back line for the start of this season.

Getty

Transfer window: Good and bad signings

Jonathan Kodjia – Bristol City to Aston Villa

Questionable signing: This has been the summer of Championship fees exploding, and the strangest is Aston Villa paying Bristol City up to £15m for Jonathan Kodija. The relegated teams are so desperate to come straight back up that they are paying excessive fees for players who might get them there.

Getty

The summer transfer window came to a dramatic close on Wednesday night as Bournemouth sealed the season-long loan of Jack Wilshere and Tottenham signed Moussa Sissoko from Newcastle in a £30m deal completed with just three minutes to go.

The moves capped a record-breaking transfer window in which clubs spent over £1.175bn on new players, while Manchester United broke the transfer world record in signing £89m Paul Pogba from Juventus.

Clubs can still strengthen with the additions of free agents, but on the whole most clubs will embark on the season ahead with their current squads after declaring their squads for the Premier League campaign as well as European competitions.

Transfer deadline day: Who signed who

So who managed to pull off a transfer coup, and who is guilty of panic buying their way out of trouble?

Click on the gallery above to see our 10 best buys of the summer transfer window and the 10 questionable moves that could come back to haunt clubs in eight months’ time.

Join our commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies